You keep fishing in old pond and keep using bait fish
go to the old pond
Cast 30ft. With bait fish.
Try old pond with maggots, max cast
Just tap the cast button so it's at about 19 feet and use bait fish. Fish at the old pond.
Ived catched "Old Mog" but i didn't get The big catch trophy why,
Go to the old pond and cast max (30 feet) with maggots it will take patience but I caught him at 37lbs
non game ar
over 25ft
You go to the old pond and cast 29-30 feet with bait fish be patient GOOD LUCK
Old pond with maggots or night fishing with luncheon meat. If u can, use the red fishing rod
they are in extreme mode and in story waters mix the to and get big fish. The monster or named fish in flick fishing do not have to caught in extreme mode. Although you will need a golden charm form the old man in the lighthouse to catch them. So you will have to finish all his quest first to catch them. There is at least one special fish in each location just make sure oyu have the right bait
In lake shiny. A lure and low casts are going to give you a bigger chance of collectibles.