0
That's a matter of opinion. If you share his views and agree with his decisions, he was. If you disagree, he wasn't. Historians should not answer this question because it's opinionated. Of course, that's just my opinion.
Lee was excellent on the defensive. His spoiling attacks repulsed several Union offensives. He was able to fend off vastly superior forces through rapid outflanking maneuvers, confounding the enemy command. He was far less successful on the offensive. Both of his invasions of the North were turned back after crushing defeats incurring great loss of life. His experience in the Mexican War may have worked against him on the offensive, where he had been able to dislodge numerically superior forces with superior firepower. At Gettysburg, that led him to order Pickett's Charge, which ended disastrously. He did take responsibility for the debacle, and never lost the respect of his men.
Wiki User
∙ 11y ago
Wiki User
∙ 6y agoClearly Lieutenant Robert E. Lee was a great general. His counterparts in both the South and the North did not have the ability to win battles or escape from severe danger if they were outnumbered.Grant, Sherman, Halleck, McClellan, Burnside, Pope, Hooker, Rosencrans, and Buell always, except for perhaps a few instances, fought with more troops and had more access to supplies than did Lee.
Also, Union generals had warship & gunship support on Southern waterways.
On the Rebel side, a case can be made for Stonewall Jackson. His exploits are legendary.
Credit and consideration should also be given to J. Johnston, Beauregard and Longstreet, also to AP Hill.
Wiki User
∙ 7y agoNo. He commanded marines before the US Civil War when putting down the John Brown raid at Harper's Ferry.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Commander of the north virginia army?
General Robert E. Lee was the commander the Army of Northern Virginia. There was also the Army of Tennessee , a great army that suffered from poor leadership, though Joe Johnston was a great general in his own way but had trouble with Jefferson Davis.
What great general served Augustus?
Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.
Who is the great confederate general?
General Stonewall Jackson
What great American general led American and U.N. forces in the Korean War?
General Douglas MacArthur
What was Alexanders ability as a general?
The answer is in the name - Great.
Commander of the north virginia army?
General Robert E. Lee was the commander the Army of Northern Virginia. There was also the Army of Tennessee , a great army that suffered from poor leadership, though Joe Johnston was a great general in his own way but had trouble with Jefferson Davis.
In the Battle of Chickamauga which Confederate general lost his job?
Lieutenant General Braxton Bragg, for whom Fort Bragg, North Carolina was named, and who is my Great grandfather several times removed.COMMENT.Sorry to contradict you but Lieutenant General Braxton Bragg was relieved from his command after the Battle of Chattanooga and not after that of Chickamauga.The general who lost his command after Chickamauga was the Union General Rosencrans.
Was catharina blount General Robert e lee's great grandmother?
yes
What were the Civil War stategies of General Robert E. Lee?
To never give up. He was my great great great great grandpa.
Who was the great general of Carthage?
Hannibal was the Great General Of Carthage.
Which is higher a major or a colonel?
Lieutenant Colonel (LTC) is a higher rank than 1st Lieutenant (1LT). LTC is a fairly senior rank, while 1LT is a junior officer. In the US Army, (commissioned) officer ranks from lowest to highest are: Second Lieutenant First Lieutenant Captain Major Lieutenant Colonel Colonel Brigadier General Major General Lieutenant General General General of the Army (AKA "five star general" - this rank was only awarded to WWII era generals like MacArthur and Eisenhower) In the US Army, junior officers (Second Lieutenant - Captain) are referred to as company grade officers, while Majors-Colonels are referred to as field grade. General officers are also known as "flag officers" because they're entitled to fly a personal flag with their rank insignia on it.
What twentieth-century American general had a grandfather who was a confederate brigadier general in the Civil War and a great -great-great-grandfather who was a general in the Revolution?
General George S Patton
What great general served Augustus?
Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.Marcus Agrippa was the great general who served Augustus. He was also an admiral.
Who is the great confederate general?
General Stonewall Jackson
Is Mark Catesby related to Robert Catesby?
Robert Catesby of Henton, England. circa 16oo. Robert is Mark Catesby's great grandfather. Information gathered from History of General William Woodford (related to Catesby) by Mrs. Catesby Willis Stewrt, "The Life of General William Woodford of American Revolution,
What general was Caesar's great rival?
Pompey was the general who was Caesar's great rival. Of course, this was after he was no longer Caesar's son-in-law.Pompey was the general who was Caesar's great rival. Of course, this was after he was no longer Caesar's son-in-law.Pompey was the general who was Caesar's great rival. Of course, this was after he was no longer Caesar's son-in-law.Pompey was the general who was Caesar's great rival. Of course, this was after he was no longer Caesar's son-in-law.Pompey was the general who was Caesar's great rival. Of course, this was after he was no longer Caesar's son-in-law.Pompey was the general who was Caesar's great rival. Of course, this was after he was no longer Caesar's son-in-law.Pompey was the general who was Caesar's great rival. Of course, this was after he was no longer Caesar's son-in-law.Pompey was the general who was Caesar's great rival. Of course, this was after he was no longer Caesar's son-in-law.Pompey was the general who was Caesar's great rival. Of course, this was after he was no longer Caesar's son-in-law.
Why was Robert E. Lee a great confederate generals and examples?
Robert E. Lee was a great general in the fact that he was able to turn sure defeat into resounding victories. He was greatly loved by his men and respected by friend and foe alike. He has been called the most beloved general in United States history. For information on examples of why he was so well loved and respected, read the book Recollectons of General Lee by Dr. John F. Maury.
