What would you like to do?

What are the criticism of stoicism philosophy?

already exists.

Would you like to merge this question into it?

already exists as an alternate of this question.

Would you like to make it the primary and merge this question into it?

exists and is an alternate of .

There are three main criticisms of Stoicism; 1) a logical difficulty involving the ideas of freedom and predestination 2) the idea of indifference has consequnces which seem paradoxical to common sense, 3) the fact that stoicism appeals only in unusual circustances; thus cannot be accepted as a universal ethic. Firstly, Stoics believe that everything in life is predetermined by a divine beeing or God or fate; thus everything ranging from the decision to go to the toilet, or to go to the park, or thinking about food during a meeting or to murder a person are all actions or evnts which had already peen predestined by some devine beeing. Therefore, if these events were destined to occur, then there is nothing which can be done to alter them. Thus, humans are not 'free' but rather chained to a destiny created by a divine plan. This is inconsistent with the stoic view as they believ that a person can alter their charachter. According to stoicism, a person can learn to become indifferent to things which had once been an important aspect of their lives. Thus, the stoics are implying, that humans are free to alteir their charachter; thus man is both free and not free. is we accept the latter then it is pointless to tell a person to change ones character, because if a charachter is already predetermined then how can it be changed? Contrary to this, if we are free to alter our charachters then the whole thory that everything is predetermined must be false!!! Secondly, the theory of indifference is oten rejcted by people of common sense. This is because if something bad were to happen, for example a friend were to die, then the idea that indifferenc were the best way to deal with the situation would seem rather caluous. Furthemore, if one were to attain an indifferent stance to allt hings around them, then acts which would have once seemed immoral would b accepted if treated with indifference such as murder. Thirdly; stoicism gives advice for people living through harsh conditions rather than those in prosperous ones. It provides advice on how to avoid bein affecte dby d situations; however, it would be ashame not to allow oneself to become affected by frienship, love and so on. There are three main criticisms of Stoicism; 1) a logical difficulty involving the ideas of freedom and predestination 2) the idea of indifference has consequnces which seem paradoxical to common sense, 3) the fact that stoicism appeals only in unusual circustances; thus cannot be accepted as a universal ethic. Firstly, Stoics believe that everything in life is predetermined by a divine beeing or God or fate; thus everything ranging from the decision to go to the toilet, or to go to the park, or thinking about food during a meeting or to murder a person are all actions or evnts which had already peen predestined by some devine beeing. Therefore, if these events were destined to occur, then there is nothing which can be done to alter them. Thus, humans are not 'free' but rather chained to a destiny created by a divine plan. This is inconsistent with the stoic view as they believ that a person can alter their charachter. According to stoicism, a person can learn to become indifferent to things which had once been an important aspect of their lives. Thus, the stoics are implying, that humans are free to alteir their charachter; thus man is both free and not free. is we accept the latter then it is pointless to tell a person to change ones character, because if a charachter is already predetermined then how can it be changed? Contrary to this, if we are free to alter our charachters then the whole thory that everything is predetermined must be false!!! Secondly, the theory of indifference is oten rejcted by people of common sense. This is because if something bad were to happen, for example a friend were to die, then the idea that indifferenc were the best way to deal with the situation would seem rather caluous. Furthemore, if one were to attain an indifferent stance to allt hings around them, then acts which would have once seemed immoral would b accepted if treated with indifference such as murder. Thirdly; stoicism gives advice for people living through harsh conditions rather than those in prosperous ones. It provides advice on how to avoid bein affecte dby d situations; however, it would be ashame not to allow oneself to become affected by frienship, love and so on.
1 person found this useful
Thanks for the feedback!

What is a stoicism?

  Stoicism is a Hellenistic philosophy founded by Zenon of Citium in Athens.

What is stoicism?

The philosophy of stoicism as espoused by the Greeks (notably Zeno, 334 BC-262 BC) saw negative emotions as failures to act with wisdom and virtue. They believed that virtue a

The school of philosophy called Stoicism held what beliefs?

In ancient times, the school of philosophy that came to be known as  Stoicism held a variety of distinctive (and influential) beliefs.  Most famously, they believed that the

What is Stoicism How does Brutus show that he follows this philosophy?

Stoicism is an ancient Greek school of philosophy. The founder of Stoicism is Zeno of Citium in Athens in 3rd century BC. The Stoics believed that destructive emotions arose d

What philosophy is the opposite of stoicism?

Stoicism is, at its heart, unconditional trust in the gods and the perfect harmony of nature, so the opposite would be Epicureanism. Epicureans believed that the gods didn't c

Why were the Romans attracted to the philosophy of Stoicism?

Stoicism was not the most influential philosophical school only among the Romans. It was so among the Greeks as well. Stoicism became the foremost philosophy among the Greek

Who was part of the ancient philosophy of stoicism?

 Stoicism was founded in  Athens by  Zeno of Citium in the early 3rd century BC. Important Greek  stoic philosophers were Cleanthes, Chrysippus, Diogenes of Babylon, 

Why Stoicism is part of philosophy?

It attracted widespread support in Rome,as a major line of thoughtand so, like others such as Platonism, Cynicis m, Epicureanism and Sophism , it is part ofthe historical b