What is the hierarchy of binding precedents within the federal court system?

already exists.

Would you like to merge this question into it?

already exists as an alternate of this question.

Would you like to make it the primary and merge this question into it?

exists and is an alternate of .

  1. US Supreme Court decisions are binding on all federal courts, but are most likely to be applicable to cases heard in US District Courts or appealed to US Court of Appeals Circuit Courts.

    The Supreme Court's decisions are also binding on State courts if they involve constitutional amendments that have been incorporated to the states.
  • US Court of Appeals Circuit Court decisions are binding on all US District Courts within that Circuit, but only carry persuasive precedential weight in other Circuits. The decisions are not binding on other Circuits or on any state courts.

    • US District Court decisions are not binding on other courts, but may be cited as persuasive precedents by other courts, regardless of which Circuit the court belongs to.

When US Court of Appeals Circuit Courts issue conflicting decisions on substantially similar matters (called a Circuit Split), they may induce the US Supreme Court to grant certiorari for a case that can be used to resolve or clarify the constitutional issue. The Supreme Court decision will then create a binding precedent used in deciding similar future cases.

When Circuit Splits are unresolved, the individual decisions -- although conflicting -- remain binding within each Circuit, but not outside the Circuit. This raises the possibility that one or more of the other ten regional Circuits* will further complicate matters by creating a third split, resulting in inconsistent constitutional interpretations and application of law. For this reason, reviewing cases that address Circuit Splits are high on the US Supreme Court's list of priorities.

* The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has special subject matter jurisdiction and is less likely to be affected by decisions made in the regional Circuits.
4 people found this useful

Are decisions of any federal trial court binding on any federal appellate court?

No, that's backwards. Binding precedents are set from the top-down. . US Supreme Court decisions are binding on all relevant federal (and state) courts . . US Court of

Is the US Tax Court an independent body within the federal judicial system?

Yes . US Tax Court, an Article I tribunal, is independent of the other courts in the federal judiciary. The Courts of general jurisdiction (US District Court, US Court of Appe

Is there a hierarchy of court within the organisation of courts Explain?

Although the names or titles of the courts may differ from jurisdiction to jurisdiction - from low to high they usually are> Justice of The Peace Court or Magistrate's Court

Why does a federal court follow a precedent?

Because in United States courts (federal) and most state courts (except Louisiana) we follow a common western legal system known as "Common Law" with bases itself on previous
In US Constitution

Explain how precedent is applied with reference to the court hierarchy?

Basically how precedents relate to the hierarchy of courts is that all the lower level courts within the judicial system applies the rule of law or precedent that was created
In US Constitution

What is a binding precedent?

Binding Precedent is a judgement that must be followed. The SupremeCourt is not bound by any other court or it's own previousjudgements. However in European matters it is boun
In Criminal Law

What is hierarchy court system in Tanzania?

Starts with primary court, followed up by District court which exercises horizontal power with Resident Magistrate's Court it has greater powers though,above all is the High C
In Florida

What is the hierarchy of the Florida court system?

The State of Florida has a four tier court system: . Florida Supreme Court . Florida District Courts . Florida Circuit Courts . Florida County Courts *(#4 being L