What would you like to do?

Why are checkpoints legal if police need probable cause to make a traffic stop?

already exists.

Would you like to merge this question into it?

already exists as an alternate of this question.

Would you like to make it the primary and merge this question into it?

exists and is an alternate of .

It depends on the type of motorist checkpoint. Roadblocks, as they are referred to by the courts, fall under what is known as a special needs exception to the 4th Amendment. The special needs exception requires that the primary purpose of the search/seizure be for regulatory, not law enforcement, purposes. Under this theory, things like drivers license/vehicle registration checkpoints pass muster because the purpose is to ensure motorists have complied with state licensing requirements. And as stated below, if there are observable signs of other wrongdoing, police may also gain probable cause for further searches at this type of checkpoint. DUI checkpoints require more though. When police officers extend the checkpoint from checking licensing with passive observation for signs of intoxication to actively testing every driver for intoxication (e.g. flashlight tests, simple cognitive tests, etc...), the purpose has shifted from regulatory to criminal enforcement. In Michigan v. Sitz, the court effectively ignored the regulatory requirement of special needs searches in coming to their holding that DUI checkpoints fall under the special needs exception (the court also likened DUI checkpoints to airport and boarder checks without addressing that there is no other way for the interests protected by those checks to be advanced). Rather, the court merely recognized that there was a compelling government interest, and that DUI checkpoints were a means of advancing that interest. In a later case, Indianapolis v. Edmond, the Supreme Court held that "narcotics checkpoints" were an unconstitutional violation of the 4th Amendment. While these checkpoints were identical to DUI checkpoints, except that police would also lead a drug dog around the motorists vehicle. The court refused to extend the special needs exception where the "primary purpose" is "to detect evidence of ordinary criminal wrongdoing." As such, motorist checkpoints are legal only so long as the primary purpose is regulatory rather than general criminal enforcement, except in the anomolous DUI checkpoint situation, and in boarder or airport security checks. Answer A checkpoint is not a traffic stop. While it depends on the state, in Texas, a person is required to furnish their license on the request of a peace officer while operating a motor vehicle on a public roadway. Therefore, the checkpoint, primarily, is designed to ascertain whether the person is legally operating a motor vehicle. And, if the peace officer has reasonable suspicion to believe a person is intoxicated, he may perform a Field Sobriety Test. Answer A checkpoint isn't a stop. It's designed with safety in mind, such as a seatbelt check. When they approach the vehicle to see that you're wearing a seatbelt, they also observe the driver to see if he/she is intoxicated. Since it's illegal to drive intoxicated and they observed you drive, they can stop you. Answer I believe they get away with it because their checkpoints are announced publicly. They are in the newspaper, on the police departments website, and even sometimes the news will say it. This goes along too with "hiding places" you know when they sit in someone's driveway or so. Also, checkpoints are very well visible. If you think you might be stopped or questioned and you have something to worry about, stay put, or find another way out. All vehicles pass through the checkpoint and therefore any of the vehicles are subject to being stopped, the driver and passengers being asked for identification and so forth. Such action does not legally constitute profiling or harassment. Answer In British Columbia Canada we often have check points and it is about seat belts (very strict here) as well as to check to see that the driver is not intoxicated. Police officers have that right. We see many cars pulled over and abandoned for towing.
Answer Because the Supreme Court ruled in Michigan Department of State Police vs. Sitz that it was constitutional. The majority acknowledge that it violates the 4th amendment, but said that the state interest in reducing drunk driving outweighed the infringement. The dissenting justices pointed out that there is no "state interest" clause or anything else in the Constitution to provide an exception.
68 people found this useful
Thanks for the feedback!

Does a misdemeanor warrant give a police officer probable cause to search a vehicle during a traffic stop?

  During any arrest, while you were in your car, the officer has the right and duty to himself to check as thoroughly as possible that he and you are not in danger from an

Can you legally tape record a police officer during a traffic stop?

Some states have laws that prohibit making a sound recording of any communication unless all of the parties have been advised the recording is being made. This applies even if

What give police probable cause to search car during traffic stop?

  Police can do almost what ever they want. Very few people have the means. legal resources time and energy to combat injustice. When the Colonies were subject to British

Does a police officer need probable cause to search persons?

Define what YOU mean by "search." Your definition may well be different from what the law calls a search. If a law officer does a routine interrogation stop on you, they may p

What do police say on a traffic stop?

  There is no set scenario. Generally they introduce themselves and tell you the reason they stopped you.... where the conversation goes from there is pretty much up to yo

Are police able to make traffic stop in driveway?

Yes. Being on private property does not insulate you from law enforcement. If police observe something that warrants a traffic stop, they can make it regardless of whether you

What qualifications do you need to be in the traffic police?

Depending on the specific agency, the geographic location and municipality type (city, town or county), becoming a local police patrol officer or traffic cop can begin with a

When can a police officer make a traffic stop?

they have to have probable cause to pull you over, but you dont know if they have that or not so its good to go ahead and pull over anyways. Another View: Police officers are

Do police need probable cause to search garbage?

If it is on your property (i.e.: backyard, etc) yes, they do. However once you "throw it away" and transport it somewhere to be disposed of or picked up, the law considers it
In Crime

Does a police officer needs probable cause to make you get out of the vehicle?

It CAN depend on the circumstances prevailing at the time of the stop, but it is within the officer's discretion. It has been ruled permissible, having to do with officer safe
In Crime

Does a police officer need probable cause to search someone?

Under stop and search powers Police require a reason to stop and search members of the public, this includes persons in vehicles. Reasons may be due to matching descriptions b