0
Why do some military historians regard the Battle of Antietam to be inconclusive?
ChuckSiata
In pure military assessments of the Battle of Antietam, military historians see the battle as being one of inconclusive results. When military experts sweep away all the political ramifications of that battle, they see an inept and numerically superior Union army, Yes, Lee had to retreat, in fact no matter what happened in Sharpsburg, Lee did not have enough men or supplies to stay in Maryland. Military minded people say that Lee's other objectives were met, thereby, in a sense, nullify the results at Antietam. Militarists point out that Lee's invasion prevented a combined effort by McClellan and General John Pope to advance on Richmond. Lee's positions before and after Antietam transferred all military operations to Northern Virginia. Based on Southern newspapers, the Southern public was not discouraged by the setback in Maryland. Also, the Army of Northern Virginia remained a force that within seven weeks doubled its size.
With all the above said, Antietam was a political victory for Lincoln and the Union. Lincoln was then resolved to release his first emancipation proclamation.
Wiki User
∙ 8y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Who claimed the victory of the battle Antietam?
The battle's outcome was inconclusive, but the North claimed victory.
What correctly describes the outcome of the American Revolutionary Battle of Monmouth?
The American Revolutionary War Battle of Monmouth was fought in New Jersey in 1778. The Americans were outnumbered but held their own against the British. Most historians write that the battle was a draw or inconclusive. Historians often vary on close battles. For example, although Robert E. Lee "lost" the Battle of Antietam, and had to retreat, most military historians claim the battle was a "technical draw".
Where did the single bloodiest day in American military history occurred at?
The battle of Antietam.
What was the bloody battle in Maryland won by the union?
The union won the battle Antietam in Maryland. It was the bloodiest battle in the war.
What was a crucial Civil War battle?
The Battle of Antietam was an important Civil War battle. Even though it was tactically inconclusive, it was enough of a victory to give President Abraham Lincoln the confidence to announce the Emancipation Proclamation, which discouraged the British and French governments from recognizing the Confederacy.
Who claimed the victory of the battle Antietam?
The battle's outcome was inconclusive, but the North claimed victory.
What correctly describes the outcome of the American Revolutionary Battle of Monmouth?
The American Revolutionary War Battle of Monmouth was fought in New Jersey in 1778. The Americans were outnumbered but held their own against the British. Most historians write that the battle was a draw or inconclusive. Historians often vary on close battles. For example, although Robert E. Lee "lost" the Battle of Antietam, and had to retreat, most military historians claim the battle was a "technical draw".
What was improtant about the Battle of Antietam?
A military base was attacked.
Who won the US Civil War Battle of Williamsburg in 1862?
In early May of 1862, Confederate General Longstreet battled Union General McClellan at the Battle of Williamsburg. For tactical reasons, Longstreet disengaged the battle. Military historians rate this confrontation as inconclusive.
Where did the single bloodiest day in American military history occurred at?
The battle of Antietam.
What army won the US Civil War Battle of Antietam?
Based on military criteria, the Battle of Antietam was a draw. This is an important military term for the actual results of that battle. It's true that General Lee retreated to Virginia, however, this was a raid and there was no intention of occupying Maryland.
What is the significance the battle of Antietam?
what is the significance of the battle of Antietam
What is the significance of Battle of Antietam?
what is the significance of the battle of Antietam
Short description of the battle of Antietam?
Battle of Antietam was the bloodiest battle of all
What was the bloody battle in Maryland won by the union?
The union won the battle Antietam in Maryland. It was the bloodiest battle in the war.
What is considered to be the climax of General George B McClellan's military career?
Clearly the so-called Maryland campaign was the climax of Major General George B. McClellan's military career and the Battle of Antietam his greatest and most important battle. The Battle of Antietam is legendary as the bloodiest day in US military history with over 25,000 casualties in one day which includes both sides of the battle.
When did the Battle of Antietam?
The Battle of Antietam ended in Semptember 17 1862.
