A Soldier's Daughter Never Cries

Plot

James Ivory directed this drama adapted from Kaylie Jones's 1990 autobiographical novel in which the character Bill Willis is based on her father, James Jones, author of From Here to Eternity and A Thin Red Line. Ruth Prawer Jhabvala's screenplay about expatriate Americans in Paris during the 1960s/1970s offers a portrait of a normal family (as opposed to the dysfunctional families of The Ice Storm and many other 1990s films), seen from the point of view of daughter Channe. Her father is Bill Willis (Kris Kristofferson), a successful novelist and WWII veteran who's married to enthusiastic poker-player Marcella (Barbara Hershey). Divided like the sections of a novel, the story's first chapter is titled, "Billy," in which French orphan Benoit (Samuel Gruen) is brought to the Willis household for adoption, while his unmarried biological mother (Virginie Ledoyen) writes about him in her diary. Six-year-old Benoit has been shipped through so many orphanages and foster homes that he doesn't unpack his suitcase. Benoit's presence prompts the young Channe (Luisa Conlon) to turn to her protective Portuguese nanny Candida (Dominique Blanc). After Benoit becomes acclimated to his new family, he asks that his name be changed to Billy. In the second segment "Francis" a strong friendship develops between Channe (Leelee Sobieski) and fatherless Francis Fortescue (Anthony Roth Costanzo). Obsessed with opera, Francis lives with his expatriate British mother (Jane Birkin). The family's French idyll is disrupted when Bill Willis plans a return to the United States because he wants American doctors to treat his bad heart. The closing act "Daddy" takes place in North Carolina during the 1970s as Bill's health worsens, Billy (Jesse Bradford) grows up, and an alienated Channe seeks acceptance through sex. A bedridden Bill dictates his fiction to Channe, who transcribes tapes and types his manuscript pages. During intimate conversations about boys and sex, Willis helps his daughter find her footing on the path of life. This movie arrived only 14 weeks prior to the release of Terrence Malick's 1998 adaptation of the elder Jones' The Thin Red Line. Shown at 1998 film fests (Venice, Toronto). ~ Bhob Stewart, Rovi

Review

Following the critical disappointments of Jefferson in Paris (1995) and Surviving Picasso (1996), A Soldier's Daughter Never Cries (1998) represented a return to form for Merchant and Ivory. The film's material broke new ground for the team; while they had presented character studies of expatriates before, these portraits had never taken place in the 1960s and '70s. The emotional center of the film lies with the unconventional Willis family, introduced to the viewer by daughter Channe (Leelee Sobieski). Kris Kristofferson finds the perfect balance for Billy Willis, a kindly father with a few rough edges. He offers straightforward and practical advice to his children, even about sex; and it is this supportive, honest approach that binds the family together. Both Barbara Hershey, as Marcella, and Jesse Bradford, as Billy, deliver fine performances as the mother and adopted son of the Willis clan. A Soldier's Daughter Never Cries offers a positive portrait of how a family can survive crises and remain healthy; their shared experiences are the emotional glue that binds this somewhat loosely structured film. There are a number of sensitively played scenes, and the natural language of Ruth Prawer Jhabvala's screenplay works well for these. The only small glitch in the film involves failing to resolve a plot concerning Candida (Dominique Blanc), the Willis' housekeeper in the first two sections of the film. Bradford and Sobieski's performances would bring them to wider attention, while Merchant and Ivory would return to Victorian literary material in 2000 with The Golden Bowl. ~ Ronnie D. Lankford, Jr., Rovi

Cast

• Kris Kristofferson - Bill Willis
• Barbara Hershey - Marcella Willis
• Leelee Sobieski - Channe Willis
• Jesse Bradford - Billy Willis
• Anthony Roth Costanzo - Francis Fortescue

Dominique Blanc - Candida; Jane Birkin - Mrs. Fortescue; Virginie Ledoyen - Billy's Mother; Samuel Gruen - Benoit; Luisa Conlon - Young Channe; Isaach de Bankolé - Mamadou

Credit

Celestia Fox - Casting, Tricia Tomey - Casting, Annette Trumel - Casting, Paul Bradley - Co-producer, Carol Ramsey - Costume Designer, James Ivory - Director, Noëlle Boisson - Editor, Richard Hawley - Executive Producer, Jane Barclay - Executive Producer, Sharon Harel - Executive Producer, Nayeem Hafizka - Executive Producer, Richard Robbins - Composer (Music Score), Jacques Bufnoir - Production Designer, Pat Garner - Production Designer, Jean-Marc Fabre - Cinematographer, Ismail Merchant - Producer, Ludovic Henault - Sound/Sound Designer, James Ivory - Screenwriter, Ruth Prawer Jhabvala - Screenwriter, Kaylie Jones - Book Author

Previous:	A Soldier and a Man (1916 Film), A Society Sensation (1918 Film)
Next:	A Soldier's Plaything (1931 Film), A Soldier's Story (1984 Film)