Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Email
Answers.com

A Song for You

 
Album Review: A Song for You

  • Artist: Carpenters
  • Rating: StarStarStarStarHalf Star
  • Release Date: 1972 06
  • Total Time: 36:50
  • Type: Lyrics are included with the album
  • Genre: Rock

Review

The duo's best album, and the place to start beyond the hits compilations. Up to the release of A Song for You, the Carpenters' success had seemed an awesome if somewhat fluky phenomenon, built on prodigious talent, some beautifully crafted pop sensibilities, and a very fortunate choice of singles -- their albums Close to You and Carpenters, though they were top-sellers, both seemed just a bit thrown together. Then came A Song for You, a seemingly unified concept album written and recorded during a frantic period of concert activity, and brimming with lovely musical ideas even more lovingly executed, laced with good humor, and enough hits of its own to have established any artist's career on its own. And even in between the hits, the album was built on material that could have made a whole career for anyone. The duo's version of a then-new Carole King song, "It's Going to Take Some Time," not only became a hit single but helped them in the "cool" department, Carole King being about the hottest musical personality there was at that particular time. One song, "Top of the World," which Richard Carpenter had only visualized as album track, became an unexpected hit single and one of the most popular songs of the decade. And where the Close to You LP had included some beautiful album tracks ("Crescent Noon," " "Maybe It's You"), A Song for You was dripping with masterpieces, including "Crystal Lullaby" and "Road Ode"; Richard Carpenter's "Piano Picker," a confessional piece sung by the composer, also marked the high point of his solo vocal contributions to the duo's music. Even the two cuts that reach back into the past -- the soft jazz instrumental "Flat Baroque," a 1966-vintage Richard Carpenter composition that he resurrected for this release, and "Bless the Beasts and the Children," the B-side of "Superstar" from more than a year earlier (written for a Stanley Kramer movie) -- slot in perfectly among the new songs. The high point of their recording career, A Song for You marked the last time that their music (and the only occasion that one of their albums) would be accepted in the rock world on its own terms, without the duo's squeaky-clean image and sound, and middle-class dorkiness becoming a drag on their sales and image. A Song for You has been released several times on CD, the best of which by far is the 1999 A&M remastering with new notes and full lyrics. ~ Bruce Eder, All Music Guide

Tracks

Track TitleComposersPerformersTime
A Song for You Leon Russell The Carpenters (4:42)
Top of the World (Lyrics) W. Henderson, Richard Carpenter, John Bettis The Carpenters (2:56)
Hurting Each Other (Lyrics) Gary Geld, Peter Udell The Carpenters (2:46)
It's Going to Take Some Time (Lyrics) Toni Stern, Carole King The Carpenters (2:55)
Goodbye to Love (Lyrics) Richard Carpenter, John Bettis The Carpenters (3:50)
Intermission (Lyrics) Richard Carpenter The Carpenters (:22)
Bless the Beasts and Children (Lyrics) Perry Botkin, Jr., Barry De Vorzon The Carpenters (3:07)
Flat Baroque Richard Carpenter The Carpenters (1:45)
Piano Picker (Lyrics) Randy Edelman The Carpenters (1:59)
I Won't Last a Day Without You (Lyrics) Roger Nichols, Paul Williams, Roger Nichols The Carpenters (3:47)
Crystal Lullaby (Lyrics) John Bettis, Richard Carpenter The Carpenters (3:58)
Road Ode (Lyrics) Gary Sims, Danny Woody Woodhams, Gary Sims The Carpenters (3:50)
A Song for You (Reprise) Leon Russell The Carpenters (:53)

Credits

Hal Blaine (Drums), Tim Weisberg (Flute), Karen Carpenter (Drums), Richard Carpenter (Liner Notes), Roland Young (Art Direction), Jim McCrary (Photography), Red Rhodes (Slide Guitar), Tony Peluso (Vocals), Earl Dumler (Oboe), Ray Gerhardt (Engineer), Red Rhodes (Guitar), Tony Peluso (Keyboards), Earl Dumler (Wind), Tony Peluso (Bass), Louie Shelton (Guitar), Bob Messenger (Wind), Bob Messenger (Flute (Alto)), Bob Messenger (Sax (Tenor)), Roger Young (Remixing), Karen Carpenter (Vocals), Richard Carpenter (Orchestration), Tony Peluso (Guitar), Red Rhodes (Guitar (Steel)), Joe Osborne (Bass), Bob Messenger (Bass), Roger Young (Assistant Engineer), Bob Messenger (Flute), Jack Daugherty (Producer), Roland Young (Artwork), Norm Herzberg (Bassoon), Richard Carpenter (Arranger), Earl Dumler (Horn (English)), Tim Weisberg (Flute (Bass)), Richard Carpenter (Vocals), Richard Carpenter (Keyboards), Norm Herzberg (Wind)
Search unanswered questions...
Enter a question here...
Search: All sources Community Q&A Reference topics
Wikipedia: A Song for You (The Carpenters album)
Top
A Song for You.png
Studio album by The Carpenters
Released June 13, 1972
Recorded 1971-1972
Genre Pop
Length 37:17
Label A&M
Producer Jack Daugherty Productions
Professional reviews
The Carpenters chronology
Carpenters
(1971)
A Song for You
(1972)
Now & Then
(1973)
Singles from A Song for You
  1. "Bless the Beasts and Children"
    Released: August 12, 1971
  2. "Hurting Each Other"
    Released: December 23, 1971
  3. "It's Going to Take Some Time"
    Released: April 13, 1972
  4. "Goodbye to Love"
    Released: June 19, 1972
  5. "Top of the World"
    Released: September 17, 1973
  6. "I Won't Last a Day Without You"
    Released: March 25, 1974

A Song for You is the fourth album released by the Carpenters. It was released on June 13, 1972. According to Richard Carpenter, "A Song for You was intended to be a concept album (of sorts) with the title tune opening and closing the set and the bookended selections comprising the 'song'."[1] In Cash Box's Top 100 Albums of 1972, A Song for You was ranked #26.[2] A special gold-plated disc CD of A Song for You was later sold to the general public.

The recording is generally considered the finest original release by the Carpenters.[weasel words] Six songs were released as A-side singles internationally: "Hurting Each Other," "It's Going to Take Some Time," "Goodbye to Love," "Top of the World," "I Won't Last a Day Without You," and "Bless the Beasts and Children."

Contents

Original LP track listing

Side A

  1. "A Song for You" - 4:42 (Leon Russell)
  2. "Top of the World" - 2:56 (Richard Carpenter, John Bettis)*
  • "Top of the World" became the Carpenters' second #1 single on December 1 (& 8th) of 1973, and was released around the same time of Lynn Anderson's version.
  1. "Hurting Each Other" - 2:46 (Peter Udell, Gary Geld)*
  2. "It's Going to Take Some Time" - 2:55 (Carole King, Toni Stern)*
  3. "Goodbye to Love" - 3:50 (Richard Carpenter, John Bettis)*
  • "Goodbye to Love" became the first soft ballad to have a hard-rock style electric guitar solo in it.
  1. "Intermission" - 0:22 (Richard Carpenter)

Side B

  1. "Bless the Beasts and Children" - 3:07 (Barry De Vorzon, Perry Botkin, Jr.)
  • "Bless the Beasts and Children" was originally the theme song to the film of the same name in 1971.
  1. "Flat Baroque" - 1:45 (Richard Carpenter)
  • "Flat Baroque" was written in 1966 for the original RCA recording sessions. It was revived in 1970 for the "Your Navy Presents" radio show, but wasn't officially released until this album was released.
  1. "Piano Picker" - 1:59 (Randy Edelman)
  2. "I Won't Last a Day Without You" - 3:46 (Paul Williams, Roger Nichols)*
  3. "Crystal Lullaby" - 3:58 (Richard Carpenter, John Bettis)
  4. "Road Ode" - 3:50 (Gary Sims, Dan Woodhams)
  5. "A Song for You" (Reprise) - 0:53 (Leon Russell)

"*" denotes song was released as a single in the United States.

Stereo tape listing

The stereo tape for A Song for You had songs in a different order.

Side 1

  1. "A Song for You"
  2. "Top of the World"
  3. "Piano Picker"
  4. "Flat Baroque"
  5. "I Won't Last a Day Without You"
  6. "Goodbye to Love"
  7. "Intermission"

Side 2

  1. "Hurting Each Other"
  2. "Crystal Lullaby"
  3. "It's Going to Take Some Time"
  4. "Bless the Beasts and Children" (Soundtrack version)
  5. "Flat Baroque"
  6. "Road Ode"
  7. "A Song for You (Reprise)"
  8. "Intermission" (same version as side one)

Singles

  • Hurting Each Other
US 7" single (1971)  A&M 1322
1.Hurting Each Other
2.Maybe It's You
  • Bless The Beasts And Children
JP 7" single (1972)  AM-114
1.Bless The Beasts And Children
2.Help
  • It's Going To Take Some Time
US 7" single (1972)  A&M 1351
1.It's Going To Take Some Time
2.Flat Baroque
  • Goodbye To Love
US 7" single (1972)  A&M 1367
1.Goodbye To Love
2.Crystal Lullaby
  • Top Of The World
US 7" single (1973)  A&M 1468
1.Top Of The World
2.Heather
  • I Won't Last A Day Without You
US 7" single (1974)  A&M 1521
1.I Won't Last A Day Without You
2.One Love

Information on the Songs

"Hurting Each Other," a cover of an obscure Ruby & the Romantics tune, was the first single issued from A Song for You in early 1972, and reached number two, becoming the Carpenters' sixth straight gold single. A cover of Carole King's "It's Going to Take Some Time" followed and peaked at number 12, and was followed by the number seven hit "Goodbye to Love," which was refused airplay on some easy listening radio stations because of a fuzz-guitar solo by Tony Peluso. The song had a significant impact on the power ballad songs which followed. The album also included the Carpenters' version of the Academy Award nominated title song from the 1971 film Bless the Beasts and Children, which had already charted at number 67 on the Hot 100 as the flip side of the duo's version of "Superstar."

The album's biggest hit single, the number one smash "Top of the World," was not issued until over a year after the album's release. According to Richard Carpenter, who co-wrote the song with John Bettis, the reason for the song's late release in the U.S. was that he had misjudged the song's commercial appeal, but was proven wrong when the Carpenters' "Top of the World" became a hit in Japan in 1972 and Lynn Anderson's cover reached #2 on the U.S. country charts in 1973. The song went through a few minor revisions, including a slight remix, before it was finally released as a single in the U.S. The Carpenters' treatment of the much-covered Paul Williams/Roger Nichols composition "I Won't Last a Day Without You" also got a belated single release in 1974, and peaked at number eleven on the Hot 100.

With the exception of "Bless the Beasts..." which peaked at number 26 on the AC chart, all of the album's charted singles made either number one ("Hurting Each Other," "I Won't Last a Day Without You") or number two on the Adult Contemporary chart. The album and its singles were also successful internationally; "Goodbye to Love" and "I Won't Last a Day..." made the top ten on the UK singles chart as a double A-side, and "Top of the World" made the Oricon singles chart in Japan on three separate occasions (#21 in 1972, #52 in 1973, and #83 in 1996).

References

  1. ^ "A Song for You" CD Insert
  2. ^ Cash Box YE Pop Albums - 1972

Shopping: A Song for You
Top
 
 
Learn More
song (Idiom)
Kunstlied
Liederkranz

What is that song? Read answer...
What is his songs? Read answer...
What is a song? Read answer...

Help us answer these
Is can can a song?
What is your Song about?
How do you get songs on this?

Post a question - any question - to the WikiAnswers community:

 

Copyrights:

Album Review. Copyright © 2009 All Media Guide, LLC. Content provided by All Music Guide ®, a trademark of All Media Guide, LLC. All rights reserved.  Read more
Wikipedia. This article is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "A Song for You (The Carpenters album)" Read more