A Woman of Paris

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Email
AMG AllMovie Guide:

A Woman of Paris

Top

Plot

Charles Chaplin's first, long-awaited, independent production for United Artists begins with an only partially true caveat from its creator: "To The Public -- In order to avoid any misunderstanding, I wish to announce that I do not appear in this picture. It is the first serious drama written and directed by myself. Charles Chaplin," -- Chaplin does appear in a walk-on as a train-station porter. It is indeed a serious drama but it is much more than that. It is a film that set new standards in silent dramatic acting and directing. It influenced other filmmakers so deeply that many of its innovations seem outdated only because of their constant imitation in films by others. It is a study in the psychology of the vagaries of love.

Marie St. Clair (Edna Purviance), a simple girl living in a small French town, plans to elope with her lover, artist Jean Millet (Carl Miller), even though her suspicious stepfather attempts to stop her. Jean brings her to his home, but they are also scorned by his father. Jean and Marie resolve to leave for Paris that night. They go to the railroad station, where Jean leaves Marie with money for tickets, while he returns home to pack. A final parting with his parents brings on a fatal stroke to his father, and when Marie calls to find out why he's late, Jean tells her that he must stay. Taking this as a rejection, Marie boards the train by herself.

A year later in Paris, Marie is a kept woman, and her keeper is Pierre Revel (Adolphe Menjou), the richest bachelor in town and one of the slimiest. When a magazine article announces Pierre's engagement to an equally wealthy woman, Marie tries to react coolly, but her body language shows she is clearly upset. Later, Marie confronts him about the engagement and is told that it will make no difference in their relationship, that "we can go on just the same," but Marie refuses to go out with Pierre. Later, she is invited to a wild party in the bohemian Latin Quarter, and she gets the address wrong, accidentally arriving at the studio where Jean and his mother now live. The two are glad to see each other, but the passage of time has made them formal and they conceal their real emotions. Observing their penurious condition, Marie hires Jean to paint her portrait.

As the days pass and the portrait nears completion, Jean again falls in love with Marie, but when he professes his love, Marie is noncommittal. She confronts Pierre with her desire for marriage and children, and he chides her, pointing to her pearl necklace as evidence of her happiness. Pierre in turn confronts her about the artist and she admits that she loves and will marry him, news that he takes coolly and dubiously, telling her that he'll see her for dinner the next evening. In the artists garret, Jean and his mother argue about Marie, and, browbeaten by his disapproving mother, he finally declares that he has reconsidered his proposal. He is overheard by Marie, and she coolly confirms that the proposal was a mistake. Later as he sets out to stalk Marie in hopes of re-establishing their relationship, the desperate Jean is seen loading a revolver. At the fancy restaurant where Pierre and Marie dine that night, Jean confronts the couple. ~ Phil Posner, Rovi

Review

A Woman of Paris is a startlingly effective drama, and not at all what one expects from a Charles Chaplin film. Granted, Chaplin is not a performer in the film (a tiny cameo appearance aside), but he did write, direct, produce and even score the film, and it is a treasure. Granted, the passage of time has made portions of it somewhat melodramatic; most viewers have seen "wronged woman" tales many times since this one appeared in 1923. But Chaplin's handling of the material is still so expert that most will overlook the excesses of the story. Chaplin, working with cinematographers Rollie Totheroh and Jack Wilson, has created a beautiful visual palette. It's simple in its cinematic flourishes, but has a visual consistency and an unerring eye for camera placement that is as surprising as it is lovely. Chaplin is also blessed with an incandescent performance from his leading lady, Edna Purviance, and an irresistible one from Adolphe Menjou as the roué who "keeps" her. Purviance's work is delicate and surefooted, nuanced yet still capable of filling the screen in the "silent movie" manner. Her range of emotions and the sense of subtext that she conveys is invaluable to Woman's success. As her true love, Carl Miller is a bit wan, but not damagingly so. The ending is remarkably satisfying and demonstrates Chaplin's exceptional skill in this film. ~ Craig Butler, Rovi

Cast

Clarence Geldert - Marie's Father; Betty Morrissey - Fifi. Marie's Friend; Malvina Polo - Paulette, Marie's Friend; Nellie Bly Baker - Masseuse; Henry Bergman - Head Waiter; Charles Chaplin - Station Porter; Karl Gutman - The Orchestra Conductor; Harry S. Northrup - Man About Town

Credit

Charles Chaplin - Director, Monta Bell - Editor, Charles Chaplin - Composer (Music Score), Roland H. "Rollie" Totheroh - Cinematographer, Rollie Totheroh - Cinematographer, Jack Wilson - Cinematographer, Charles Chaplin - Producer, Charles Chaplin - Screenwriter, Eric James - Additional Music

Previous:A Woman of Mystery (1957 Film), A Woman of Independent Means (1995 Film)
Next:A Woman of Pleasure (1919 Film), A Woman of Substance (1984 Film)
Wikipedia on Answers.com:

A Woman of Paris

Top
A Woman of Paris

US DVD cover
Directed by Charlie Chaplin
Produced by Charlie Chaplin
Written by Charlie Chaplin
Starring Edna Purviance
Clarence Geldart
Carl Miller
Lydia Knott
Charles K. French
Adolphe Menjou
Music by Louis F. Gottschalk (original score)
Charlie Chaplin (1976 release)
Distributed by United Artists (1923 release)
Release date(s)
  • September 26, 1923 (1923-09-26)
Running time 93 minutes
Country United States
Language Silent film
English intertitles

A Woman of Paris is a feature-length silent film that debuted in 1923. The film, an atypical drama film for its creator, was written, directed, produced and later scored by Charlie Chaplin. It is also known as A Woman of Paris: A Drama of Fate.[1]

Contents

Plot

Marie St. Clair and her beau, aspiring artist Jean Millet, plan to leave their small French village for Paris, where they will marry. On the night before their scheduled departure, Marie climbs down from her second-floor bedroom for a rendezvous with Jean. Her stepfather sees them strolling down a lane and locks her out of the house. When the couple returns, Jean furiously knocks on the front door and reminds the older man that he's locked out his daughter. The stepfather dismisses Jean's complaint and tells Marie, "Perhaps (Jean) will give you a bed for the night."

Jean does invite Marie to his home, but he makes it clear that he lives with his parents and his mother will fix a bed for Marie. It turns out that Jean's parents are not thrilled with their son's romance with Marie, either. Marie goes to the train station, with Jean promising to follow her. But Jean's father has died while sitting in his chair in front of the fireplace, and when Jean telephones Marie at the station to tell her he can't go with her to Paris, she gets on the train and makes the trip alone.

In Paris, Marie enjoys a life of luxury as the mistress of wealthy businessman Pierre Revel. One night when Marie is alone in the apartment Revel has provided for her, a friend calls and invites her to a raucous party in the Latin Quarter. The friend gives Marie the address, but admits that she can't remember whether the apartment is in the building on the right or the left. Marie, arriving by taxi, enters the wrong building and is surprised to be greeted by Jean Millet. Marie tells Jean she would like for him to paint her portrait and gives him a card with her address.

Jean calls on Marie at her apartment to begin the painting, and Marie notices he is wearing a black armband. She asks why he is in mourning, and Jean tells her his father has died. Marie asks when and Jean replies, "The night you left."

Marie and Jean revive their romance, and Marie begins to distance herself from Pierre Revel. Pierre knows about Jean but also realizes that Marie has become fond of the luxuries she enjoys as his mistress.

Jean finishes Marie's portrait, but instead of painting her wearing the elegant outfit she chose for the sitting, he outfits her in the simple dress she wore on the night she left for Paris.

Jean proposes to Marie. Marie tells Pierre she'll be leaving soon, but Pierre isn't so sure.

Jean's mother, with whom he shares the simple Paris apartment, argues with him about marrying Marie. Jean starts to leave in anger but, after opening the door, leaves the door ajar as he goes to apologize to his mother. He tells his mother the proposal was spur-of-the-moment and not serious. Marie happens to arrive unexpectedly outside Jean's apartment at that moment. A chastened Marie returns to Pierre Revel.

Jean fails to convince Marie he didn't mean what she overheard him say to his mother in an attempt to appease the older woman. One night Jean slips a gun into his coat pocket and goes to the exclusive restaurant where Marie and Pierre are dining. Jean asks the maitre d' to give Marie a note asking her to meet him one last time. Pierre sees the note and invites Jean to join them. Jean and Pierre get into a scuffle and Jean is ejected from the dining room. Jean stands by the fountain in the restaurant's foyer, pulls out the gun and fatally shoots himself.

The police carry Jean's body to his apartment. Jean's mother retrieves the gun and goes to Marie's apartment. Marie's maid tells her that Marie has gone to her son's studio. Jean's mother returns to the apartment and finds Marie kneeling by Jean's body and sobbing.

Jean's mother is touched by Marie's display of grief. The two women reconcile and return to the French countryside, where they open a home for orphans in a country cottage.

One morning Marie and one of the girls in her care walk down the lane to get a pail of milk. Marie and the girl meet a group of sharecroppers with a horse-drawn wagon, who offer them a ride back in the wagon. At the same time, Pierre Revel and another gentleman are riding through the French countryside in a chauffeur-driven automobile. Pierre's companion asks him, "What ever happened to that Marie St. Clair?" Pierre replies that he doesn't know. Pierre's automobile and the horse-drawn wagon then pass each other, heading in opposite directions.

Production

Several things set this film apart from Chaplin's other work. The first, most obvious, is that he does not appear in the film, at least not in his traditional role of the tramp. He has a brief cameo as a porter in a train station. This role was supposed to be inconspicuous and he is not even listed in the credits for it (though he precedes the film with a title card which explains that he does not appear). Most people seeing the film will not realize that it is actually Chaplin; this was intended. The other major difference between this and most of Chaplin's other work is that the film is supposed to be a serious drama. There is no slapstick comedy.

Edna Purviance plays the lead as Marie St. Clair. Chaplin had several reasons for producing this film, and one of these reasons was to help Purviance gain recognition as an actress without Chaplin at her side. Another was because he wanted to try staying behind the camera and attempt his first real drama. Despite this attempt, Edna Purviance was never able to achieve the level of success that she had in films with Chaplin's Tramp at her side. However, the film did help Adolphe Menjou gain some recognition.

The film was largely inspired by Chaplin's brief 1922 romance with Peggy Hopkins Joyce, whose stories of her romantic adventures in Europe provided the framework of the screenplay.

Reception

The public did not receive this film very well. Chaplin was very popular at this time, and many went to this film expecting to see Chaplin in his traditional role. There were two efforts made to help "ease" the public into the idea of Chaplin doing a film without Chaplin in it. On the night the film premiered, Chaplin had flyers given to those in line. The flyers essentially state that this is a deviation from his normal work, and that he hopes the public will find these deviations enjoyable. The film also contains a message at the beginning stating that Chaplin will not be appearing in the film. Some film historians have speculated about what the public's reaction would have been if they did not know A Woman of Paris did not star Chaplin — it may have been received much differently.

Critical response to the film was very positive, and it is credited with influencing later filmmakers. In particular, the film's characters and their motivations had a complexity that was new to cinema. Some consider it to be the first true Chaplin feature, since it is the first feature done under the company he co-founded United Artists.

The film's box office failure was painful for Chaplin, and after its initial release it was not seen by the public for over fifty years. Chaplin reissued the edited film with a new musical score -- replacing the original score by Louis F. Gottschalk -- in 1976, a year before his death. In fact, the score he composed is credited as being the final completed work of his 75 year career.

Cast

References

External links


Post a question - any question - to the WikiAnswers community:

Copyrights:

Mentioned in

Henry François Becque (French dramatist)
Road to Ruin (1991 Comedy Film)
Blame the Woman (1932 Crime Film)
Pacific Palisades (1990 Drama Film)
Helen (daughter of Zeus and Leda and wife of Menelaus)