Agnes Bernauer, a five-act tragedy in prose, ‘Ein deutsches Trauerspiel’, by F. Hebbel. Written in 1851, it was first performed under the direction of F. Dingelstedt in the Munich Hoftheater in March 1852. It was published in 1855. The action is based on an episode in Bavarian history (1428-36), the secret marriage of Albrecht (see Albrecht III), heir to the Wittelsbach Duke Ernst (see Ernst I) of Bavaria/Munich, which ended in the arrest of his wife, the Augsburg barber's daughter Agnes Bernauer. She was tried, condemned to death for witchcraft, and drowned in the Danube at Straubing in 1435.
Hebbel adapted the historical figures to suit his purpose. Agnes rejects the courtship of Theobald, the barber's assistant, against the advice of her father, Caspar Bernauer, who urges her to marry within her class. Albrecht's friends, Graf Törring, Nothafft von Wernberg, and Rolf von Frauenhoven, likewise try to prevent the young duke from rashly marrying the barber's daughter, whom he meets during his visit, and who is known as the ‘angel of Augsburg’ because of her exceptional beauty. Caspar blesses the couple, accepting Agnes's conviction that her love is an expression of God's will. Duke Ernst, fearing for the safety of his dynasty, disinherits Albrecht at a tournament in Regensburg in favour of his nephew Adolf. At the castle of Straubing Albrecht, as he is about to go to a tournament at Ingolstadt, learns of Adolf's death. Hardly has he left the castle than Agnes is arrested. Offered the choice of renouncing Albrecht or suffering death, she chooses the latter and is drowned in the Danube. Duke Ernst accepts full responsibility for her execution which he has ordered for no reason other than to safeguard his dynasty, for Adolf's death has left his son Albrecht as the only possible heir. Ernst's chancellor von Preising confirms that Agnes has to die because she is ‘beautiful and virtuous’. On hearing the news of Agnes's death, Albrecht revolts against his father, who is taken prisoner by Albrecht's men. But the Emperor's herald arrives to pronounce ban and excommunication upon the rebel duke. In the final confrontation between father and son, Ernst recognizes Agnes, in death, as duchess, her low station having prevented him from doing so during her life. He abdicates, and passes the ducal staff to his son. Albrecht's acceptance reaffirms the dynasty.
By executing one innocent of any crime Duke Ernst appears inhuman, although Hebbel, under the impact of the 1848 revolutions, finds motivation for the political theme of the play. He also intended Agnes's tragedy to demonstrate his conception of tragic guilt inherent in the beauty and purity which constitute Agnes's unwitting ‘hubris’. Hebbel also saw his play as a modernization of Sophocles's Antigone, in that Agnes, like Antigone, represented the ‘absolute right’, which was in conflict with the ‘relative right’, embodied in the state and represented by King Creon and Duke Ernst respectively. In such a conflict the representatives of secular power must inevitably incur personal guilt in the administration of the law. Duke Ernst emerges fully aware of the ethical conflict which destroys his humanity.
Critical comments on the political theme have not ceased since the first performance of the play, which has nevertheless maintained its position as one of Hebbel's major tragedies. For other treatments of the subject see Bernauer, Agnes.




