Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Email
Answers.com

Borderline

 
Movies:

Borderline

  • Director: Kenneth MacPherson
  • AMG Rating: star
  • Genre: Drama
  • Movie Type: Melodrama, Message Movie
  • Themes: Interracial/Cross-Cultural Romance, Race Relations
  • Release Year: 1930
  • Country: UK

Plot

Starring Paul Robeson (one of the first black movie actor/singers to achieve mainstream popularity) in a rare silent role, this experimental drama was thought lost until the 1990s when it was rediscovered by the British Film Institute. The Switzerland-set melodrama takes place in a resort and chronicles the reaction of patrons when an interracial couple shows up for a stay. Some critics claim that careful, sensitive viewers may be able to pick out gay subtext running throughout the story. ~ Sandra Brennan, All Movie Guide

Review

Borderline is a fascinating film, although it is likely to only truly be enjoyed by film students. The only feature directed (and written) by film theorist Kenneth MacPherson, Borderline's fascination is intellectual; the film will not really engage most viewers, who will find its technical virtuosity cannot compensate for its willful obscurity and its lack of a clearly-told story. Indeed, taken as just a film, Borderline is not very good. The story, which is simple at base, is not told well, and the direction is far too concerned with cleverness and effect for their own sakes rather than in the service of drama. And while the cast is quite good, the direction -- which emphasizes lengthy shots whose dramatic function is unclear mixed with editing that is jarring and discomfiting -- mutes the impact of the performers, including even the intensely powerful Paul Robeson and his enigmatic wife, Eslanda Robeson. However, those willing to submit to Borderline on its own terms will find it filled with memorable images, striking compositions and edits and juxtapositions which make a tremendous impact. MacPherson was rebelling against the use of sound in films, and this silent film was his statement on film as a purely visual medium. It's not a successful experiment by any means, but it is a unique cinematic experience. ~ Craig Butler, All Movie Guide

Cast

Paul Robeson

Credit

Kenneth MacPherson - Director

Similar Movies

Uncle Tom's Cabin; Symbol of the Unconquered; Within Our Gates
Search unanswered questions...
Enter a question here...
Search: All sources Community Q&A Reference topics
Wikipedia: Borderline (1930 film)
Top
Borderline
Directed by Kenneth MacPherson
Produced by The Pool Group
Winfred Ellerman
Kenneth MacPherson
Hilda Doolittle
Written by Kenneth Macpherson
Hilda Doolittle
Starring Paul Robeson
Eslanda Robeson
Hilda Doolittle
(billed as 'Helga Doorn')
Cinematography Kenneth MacPherson
Editing by Kenneth MacPherson
Release date(s) 1930
Running time 63 mins
Country United Kingdom
Language English

Borderline is a 1930 experimental silent film by Kenneth MacPherson and the Pool Group, starring Paul Robeson. In the film two couples-White and Black-intersect with racial values, each other, and the small town in which they find themselves. The Pool Group consisted of Winfred Ellerman, her bisexual husband Kenneth McPherson and her lover (and Kenneth MacPherson's), the poet H.D. (Hilda Doolittle). Borderline was the last film that the POOL group would complete before disbanding and has become a classic of early experimental cinema.

Contents

Plot

Adah, a black woman, has an affair with Thorne, a white man, much to the dismay of some of the prejudiced townsfolk and Thorne's wife, Astrid. Adah attempts a reconciliation with her man, Pete, but eventually leaves him and the town. Meanwhile, Astrid goes mad and cuts Thorne's face and arm with a knife, but then mysteriously dies. Thorne is tried but acquitted. Because of the events, the mayor sends Pete a letter asking him to leave town for the good of all concerned.

The border town scenes were shot on location in Switzerland. Real-life partner Essie Robeson co-starred with Paul in this avant garde film which was never shown in public theaters. The filmmakers was most concerned with avant garde film technique and unconventional editing, though one critic who did notice the film noted that in the character portrayal, "Borderline is an attempt...to treat the Negro as a sensitive and intelligent being."

Film and legacy details

For many years, the film Borderline was largely inaccessible to film scholars, with rare copies in a few archives around the world and seldom screened in public. Many film historians of avant-garde and experimental film-making, feel that it represents one of the last, examples of modernism of the 1920s, when many artists had hoped that artistic experimentation and commercial viability need not be mutually exclusive. For feminist literary modernists, it is not only the film that H. D. starred in, but it also serves as a study imbued by her unique aesthetic vision. Highly influenced by the psychological realism of GW Pabst and Sergei Eisenstein's complex montage format, Macpherson embellished this story by portraying the extreme psychological states of the characters.

A booklet that Macpherson and Doolittle wrote to accompany the film concentrated not on narrative coherence but on psychological metaphors. Macpherson was also influenced by Hans Sachs, Winfred Ellerman's analyst at the time of filming. The booklet became a piece later published in the Pool Groups' literary journal, Close Up.[1]

In May 2006, a presentation of Borderline with a new score written and performed live by British composer and saxophonist Courtney Pine at Tate Modern attracted 2,000 people.

Cast

External links

Notes

  1. ^ Mandel, Charlotte. "Garbo/Helen: The self-projection of beauty by H.D.". Women's Studies 7, 1980. 127–35. Retrieved on February 14, 2009.

 
 

 

Copyrights:

Movies. Copyright © 2009 All Media Guide, LLC. Content provided by All Movie Guide ®, a trademark of All Media Guide, LLC. All rights reserved.  Read more
Wikipedia. This article is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Borderline (1930 film)" Read more