• Born: Mar. 2, 1836, South Lee, Mass.
• Education: Yale College, B.A., 1856; studied briefly at Yale Law School and Harvard Law School
• Previous government service: U.S. deputy marshal, 1861; assistant U.S. attorney, Detroit, Mich., 1863–68; circuit judge, Wayne County, Mich., 1868; federal judge, Eastern District of Michigan, 1875–90
• Appointed by President Benjamin Harrison Dec. 23, 1890; replaced Samuel Miller, who died
• Supreme Court term: confirmed by the Senate Dec. 29, 1890, by a voice vote; retired May 28, 1906
• Died: Sept. 4, 1913, New York, N.Y.
Henry B. Brown became a lawyer in 1860 in Detroit, Michigan, after finishing his formal education at Yale. After a 15-year career as a federal district judge in Michigan, Brown joined the U.S. Supreme Court.
Justice Brown's strong support of property rights and free enterprise, and his tendency to resist strong government regulation of business, reflected the dominant opinions of his time. So did Brown's views about civil rights for black Americans, which were expressed in his opinion for the Court in Plessy v. Ferguson (1896). The Plessy decision supported a Louisiana state law that required black and white railroad passengers to sit in separate railway cars. Justice Brown, writing for the Court, argued that this Louisiana law did not violate the “equal protection of the laws” clause of the 14th Amendment. Brown used a “separate but equal” doctrine to support the Court's decision. He stated that separate facilities could be required by law for blacks and whites as long as the facilities provided for one group were equal to the facilities provided for the other group. He wrote, “We consider the underlying fallacy of the plaintiff's argument to consist in the assumption that the enforced separation of the two races stamps the colored race with a badge of inferiority.”
The Court's decision in the Plessy case led to widespread enactment of state laws to segregate blacks from whites, to keep them apart, in the use of public facilities, such as schools, rest rooms, parks, cemeteries, and so forth.
Justice Brown left the Court in 1906 because of failing eyesight. He was popular then, but is not well regarded today because of his opinion for the Court in the Plessy case. Most Americans today strongly reject the legal segregation of blacks and whites, which Justice Brown defended in the 1890s. However, Brown and his Supreme Court colleagues expressed the prevailing view of that era about black-white relationships.
See also Plessy v. Ferguson




