Origin: 1818
Once again we have to thank the Dutch, who brought us Cookies (1703), for a tasteful innovation in our language and our cuisine. They had undoubtedly been baking crullers for well over a century in their settlements in the Hudson River valley, but it was by the early nineteenth century that their Yankee neighbors were taking note. Washington Irving mentions the cruller lovingly in his 1818 Legend of Sleepy Hollow as he describes the object of Ichabod Crane's affection:
A similar, though less eloquent sentiment was expressed in the Boston Transcript in December 1842: "The ole-kochen, crullers and cookies were of a quality that proved the skilful hand of some genuine Dutch housewife in the manufacture."
Crullers nowadays are familiar throughout the Northeast, the upper Midwest, and California. But what are they? An early recipe from Massachusetts for "Crullers, Matrimony or Love Knots" says to "Roll thin, cut in strips and tie in knots, or braid three strips together." Others use the term cruller for an unraised doughnut without a hole, also called a fried cake or cake doughnut. The author of A Word Geography of the Eastern United States (1949) found that the difference in usage "gives rise to many a lively discussion in New England." Among the opinions recorded there in the 1930s: "Cruller contains more egg and less milk than a doughnut" (Shrewsbury, Massachusetts); "Crullers are nothing more than doughnuts, only they're twisted" (Boston); "Anybody that would call a cruller a doughnut would be laughed out of court" (New Milford, Connecticut).