| For Us, The Living: A Comedy of Customs | |
|---|---|
 First edition cover |
|
| Author | Robert A. Heinlein |
| Country | United States |
| Language | English |
| Genre(s) | Science fiction novel |
| Publisher | Scribner |
| Publication date | November 28, 2003 |
| Media type | Print (Hardcover & Paperback) |
| Pages | 288 pp (first edition, hardback) |
| ISBN | ISBN 0-7432-5998-X (first edition, hardback) |
| OCLC Number | 53145408 |
| Dewey Decimal | 813/.54 22 |
| LC Classification | PS3515.E288 F67 2004 |
For Us, The Living: A Comedy of Customs is a science fiction novel by Robert A. Heinlein, written in 1938 but published for the first time in 2003. Heinlein admirer and science fiction author Spider Robinson entitled his introductory essay "RAH DNA", as he believes this first, unpublished novel formed the DNA of Heinlein's philosophy.
The published version of the novel contains an afterword by Robert James, Ph.D., Heinlein Society member and Heinlein scholar, explaining how the only known surviving typescript of this "lost" work was finally discovered in a garage.[1]
Contents |
Plot summary
In the novel, Perry Nelson, a normal 1939 engineer, is driving his automobile when he has a blowout, skids over a cliff, and wakes up after the car accident in the year 2086. Though he was apparently killed in the summer, he re-appears in extremely cold snow, nearly dies again of by freezing, and is saved by a fur-clad woman named Diana. The exact circumstances of his being killed and reborn after a century and half is never explained.
As Spider Robinson comments in the forward, the later 21st Century people seem strangely incurious, showing little interest in how he had come to be among them and rather take his appearance for granted and proceed to explain to him the details of the social and political set-up of their world.
Background
Spider Robinson says that the book is more a lecture series than a true novel. A number of people have remarked on its resemblance to H. G. Wells' The Shape of Things to Come; the "sleeper wakes into pseudo-utopia" plot was popularised by Edward Bellamy's best-selling Looking Backward. The character Diana's background is clarified in a multiple-page footnote from the author. The future society has a somewhat leftist version of a Social Credit structure — something which may come as a surprise to those who were not acquainted with Heinlein's early political leanings.
The title comes from Abraham Lincoln's Gettysburg Address and appears to have no relation to Ayn Rand's similarly titled We the Living (published in 1936). Earnings from the novel go to the advancement of human exploration of space. The subtitle appears to be a bow to James Branch Cabell's 1919 novel Jurgen, A Comedy of Justice - a writer and book he stated he was influenced by. (Heinlein's 1984 novel Job: A Comedy of Justice continues his homage.)
There is an autobiographical element in the protagonist being (as Heinlein himself was at the time of writing) freshly of the US Navy and fondly recalling his days there, in numerous contexts in the course of the book commenting "In the Navy we did...".
Connections to other Heinlein works
For Us, the Living contains many foreshadowings of Heinlein's later writings. The 2086 of the book has a significant resemblance to both Beyond This Horizon and the Earth of Methuselah's Children. Other familiar elements include the "Covenant" from Coventry, a variation on Starship Troopers's suffrage only through federal service, rolling roads and a cat as a minor character.
Also appearing already in this early stage of Heinlein's career is the fanatic and dictatorial religious leader Nehemiah Scudder. However, in Heinlein's later Future History Scudder succeeds in getting elected President and establishing a theocratic dictatorship dominating the US for most of the 21st Century. Conversely, in "For Us, The Living", Scudder does establish for several years a de-facto domination over the Mississippi Valley, and terrorises much of the rest of the country by Ku Klux Klan-type thugs - but he is stopped at the last moment by the counter-mobilisation of Libertarians, and despite mass voter intimidation carries only Tennessee and Alabama.
In fact, the Libertarian regime seen in full bloom in the book's 2086 came into being in direct reaction to Scudder's attempt to impose Puritanical mores on the entire American society. (For example, the complete abolition of the nudity taboo, which is an important aspect of the book's plot.)
Concepts and Themes
The Second World War
At the time of writing, there was already a widespread expectation of a new war breaking out in Europe in the near future, and Heinlein followed this assumption. However, in the book's timeline the US stays out of the war, and it ends due to Germany's economic collapse rather than its military defeat (similar to the scenario given in H.G.Wells' "The Shape of Things to Come", four years before). Heinlein did correctly predict that Hitler would end up committing suicide, once his schemes of conquest collapsed.
President Roosevelt
The book assumes that by 1938-39 FDR's New Deal had failed due to the constant attacks by his opponents, that in the 1940 elections Roosevelt would prove unelectable, that his downfall would drag the Democratic Party to ruin and that a sharp drift to the Right would culminate in an extreme-right dictatorship in the late 1940's - which would, however, prove short-lived and after which the pendulum would swing sharply to the Left again.
Heinlein assigned to Fiorello H. La Guardia - at the time of writing a reformer Mayor of New York and outspoken supporter of Roosevelt, despite being nominally a Republican - the role of picking up FDR's torch, as a militant reforming President in the 1950's who would lead a head-on confrontation with the banking system, effectively nationalise the banks and institute the system of Social Credit.
Several decades later, a John Delano Roosevelt is mentioned among the six highly-regarded reformers who revise the US Constitution and institute the Libertarian regime seen in 2086.
Economic Independence
At a number of points in For Us, the Living, Heinlein describes an environment in which individuals are able to choose whether or not to accept a job. Passing references are made to the large number of individuals who take up art or other careers that traditionally do not pay well. The book also points out the short working hours and high wages paid to employees. The book ascribes this flexible working environment to the social credit system (the "Dividend") adopted by the United States.
For Us, the Living also depicts an early example of homesourcing in fiction. The character of Diana, a nationally-renowned dancer, is shown performing in her own home for a broadcast audience, which sees her dancing on sets added by the broadcasting company to her original feed. The mechanism for this homesourcing is not described in much technical detail, but it appears to be similar to a high-definition video signal interfaced with something like modern chroma key technology.
Social/Governmental
'For Us, the Living' also depicts graphically the transition between the society that Perry left in 1939 and how it is transformed through a series of acts by the Government. Of specific note is the 'War Voting Act'. In this act, if the United States wished to engage in armed conflict with any other country, a national referendum was required to be held. Voting was not obligatory for all citizens, but in the event that the article was passed and the country was to go to war, those who had voted for war were the first to be enlisted in the armed forces, those who abstained were the second conscripted, and those who voted 'No' were the third group. Heinlein states that in the history of the 'War Voting Act', the process had been enacted twice, and both times the entire citizenry were actively engaged in very vocal debate as to the whether the conflict was warranted. Both times, he states, the measures to go to war were defeated.
After the transition has been completed, the social norms of the society are effectively transformed. One of the most curious and pervasive, is the distinction between 'public sphere' and 'private sphere'. The society as a whole respects what are considered private sphere events, such as intimacy, closeness, friendship, between other people. As there is a great deal of information in the society, this becomes rather critical in moving the society toward a point away from information fetishism and toward a just society where persons have respect for one another and work as a society for the betterment of all.
Feminist Critique
Cynthia Brown noted in her review that "(...)Heinlein depicts a society where it is taken for granted that a woman may freely pursue a career, as well as choose her sexual partner(s) and live openly with a man without need of any sanction by a religious or secular authority. Already many decades before 2086, we live in such a society, and tend to forget that in 1939 when the book was written this was still quite a radical vision, and that this may well have been a major reason for publishers to reject it. We have not yet gotten to the point where possessiveness over another person and the use of even "mild" violence in pursuit of such possessiveness is regarded by society at large as an intolerable social and mental aberration; perhaps by 2086 we will get there, too.
(...) Still, Heinlein was far from completely and unequivocally accepting the full implications of gender equality - neither in this book nor in his later written and earlier published ones. The retrograde side raises its head in the later part, dealing with Heinlein's pet subject of space exploration. The protagonist Perry, who can be said to stand for Heinlein himself, is astonished at seeing a woman about to take up an experimental rocket, and exclaims: "But that's man's work!". He does not get told - as might have been expected - that the utopian society of 2086 has long since abolished any such distinction and concept. Rather, his interlocutor lamely explains that this particular woman, Vivian, was given a special privilege because she had designed the fuel for the rocket. A few pages later, the rocket crashes and Vivian is very severely punished for trying her hand at "a man's work": she was "burned to a crisp" and lost her right leg, and Heinlein neglects to tell the reader whether or not the doctors managed to save her life. It is left to the male hero from the past to take up the mission to which the poor Vivian was not equal, design a new and better rocket fuel and triumphantly take off to "Where no man had gone before". To Perry's two love interests, Diana and Olga, is left the ultra-traditional female role, to tearfully embrace and kiss their hero and then wait fretting at home for his safe return - and to this reviewer is left a quite nasty aftertaste from the ending which followed a rather promising prelude" [2].
Editions
- January 2004, Scribner Book Company, ISBN 5-551-28585-5
- January 2004, Scribner Book Company, ISBN 5-551-28586-3
- January 6, 2004, Scribner, hardcover, 288 pages, ISBN 0-7432-5998-X
- December 1, 2004, Pocket Books, paperback, 352 pages, ISBN 0-7434-9154-8
References
- ^ *Rule, Deb Houdek "The finding and publishing of For Us, the Living" 31 Aug. 2003
- ^ Cynthia Brown's review in "Gender Equality Quarterly", Autumn 2006
This entry is from Wikipedia, the leading user-contributed encyclopedia. It may not have been reviewed by professional editors (see full disclaimer)
