["But you don't even know the meaning of the words I'm sorry","You don't even know the meaning of the words, I'm sorry","","And question my own questions on and on","","It should be illegal to deceive a woman's heart","The way you've done it","Wondering for days and hours","It should be illegal to deceive a woman's heart","","Always supportive, always patient, what did I do wrong?","","You said you would love me until you die","Anyhow, anyhow","When I'm still so close","And since you have been gone","I wish you both all the best","And as far as I know you're still alive, baby","You don't even know the meaning of the words I'm sorry","You said you would love me until you die","","It should be illegal to deceive a woman's heart","","I'm starting to believe","So deliberate, so determined","I bite my nails for days and hours","","It should be illegal to deceive a woman's heart","That you could hurt me","You don't even know the meaning of the words, I'm sorry","I'm starting to believe","I hope you get along","You don't even know the meaning of the words I'm sorry","Open heart, open heart","And as far as I know you're still alive, baby","","I tried so hard to be attentive, to all you wanted","So tell me now, tell me now","And as far as I know you're still alive, baby","Who would have thought","You don't even know the meaning of the words I'm sorry","It's clear, it isn't here where you belong","I'm starting to believe","","Open heart, open heart","Why you're so far away?","You said you would love me until you die","","It should be illegal to deceive a woman's heart",""]
Performed by: Shakira Written by: Shakira Mebarak Ripoll; Lester A Mendez
Credits: Mebarak Ripoll, Shakira (Songwriter); Mendez, Lester A (Songwriter); ANIWI MUSIC LLC (Publisher); APOLLINAIRE MUSIC (Publisher); EMI BLACKWOOD MUSIC INC. (Publisher)
"Illegal" features a musical collaboration between Shakira and Carlos Santana. The song has been well-received by critics and has been highlighted as an example of Shakira's ever-developing strength as an English-language songwriter. Allmusic reviewer Stephen Thomas Erlewine has said that Shakira's chorus alludes to the Alanis Morissette hit "You Oughta Know", but since her sound is much more softer than Morissette's, she takes her music into unexpected directions.[1]
Track listing and formats
CD 1
"Illegal" [Album Version] (featuring Carlos Santana) – 03:54
"Illegal" [Ali Dee Remix] (featuring Carlos Santana) – 03:49
"Illegal" [Johnny Vicious Warehouse Radio Mix] 3:45
"Illegal" [Johnny Vicious Roxy Mix] 8:00
"Illegal" [Johnny Vicious Roxy Radio Mix] 4:14
"Illegal" [Johnny Vicious Ballroom Mix] 7:28
"Illegal" [Johnny Vicious Ballroom Dub] 5:37
"Illegal" [Johnny Vicious Electro Mix] 6:10
Release Information
The single was set for a worldwide release, and the single had already been playing on American and Australian stations and music video programs, such as SAFM and Rage; it even peaked at #9 on the American TRL Countdown. However, as Hips Don't Lie still prevailed on the charts in these non-European countries, the single was cancelled.
Music video
Shakira kissing the boxer; she mends his wounds.
The music video for "Illegal" was shot in Mexico City on October 17, 2006, during a short break in the schedule of Oral Fixation Tour, between concerts in Mexico and Guatemala. The filming took a full day, and some American and Mexican fans were invited over as extras. Jaume de Laiguana and Shakira were the co-directors of the video.
The video features Shakira as the girlfriend of a boxer. Throughout most of the video, Shakira is shown in the empty boxing venue where her former boyfriend boxes. Through flashback, she remembers the good times in their relationship, with them shown in the ring while no one is there, affectionately messing around, among other things. At the end of the video, it is shown why they are no longer together. Shakira comes to see her boyfriend boxing in the championship match. He wins, and not realizing Shakira is there, another girl steps in the ring, and he kisses her, revealing to Shakira he is cheating on her. Her boyfriend, to his shock, finally sees that Shakira is watching him kiss this other girl. Shakira looks back at him, clearly hurt, before turning away and leaving.
The music video officially premiered on 16 November on MTV's Total Request Live. It debuted on the countdown the next day, at # 9 and peaked at #7.
Chart performance
Because of the massive hit "Hips Don't Lie" consistently remaining on the charts in the US and Australia, the song was canceled two weeks after the release in those countries. In November 2006, "Illegal" debuted on the Italian Singles Chart at number nine and then rose to number four.[2] The song spent fourteen consecutive weeks in the chart's top twenty.[2]