Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Email
Answers.com

Live at the Witch Trials

 
Album Review: Live at the Witch Trials

  • Artist: The Fall
  • Rating: StarStarStarStar
  • Release Date: 1979 01
  • Type: Live
  • Genre: Rock

Review

That the first Fall album in a near endless stream would not only not sound very punk at all but would be a downright pleasant listen at the start (thanks to Yvonne Pawlett's electric piano on "Frightened") seems perfectly in keeping with Smith's endlessly contrary mind. His inimitable drawl/moan and general vision of the universe (idiots are everywhere and idiotic things are rampant) similarly sprawls all over the music -- there's no question who this is or whose band it is as well. That said, most of Live at the Witch Trials is co-written with Martin Bramah, whose guitar work here is noticeably much more inclined to chime and ring instead of brutally scratching away like Craig Scanlon's awesome work would soon do. Bramah's not just there to sound tuneful, though, and the killer Marc Riley/Karl Burns rhythm section both keeps up the energy and provides surprising grooves. On chugging tracks like "Two Steps Back," it's not hard to tell Smith's Krautrock fandom is coming into play. With Pawlett's keyboards providing a pretty garage kick on top of it all, the result is an all-around treat. Brilliantly scabrous tracks are everywhere, one of the most memorable being "Rebellious Jukebox," simultaneously one of the most tuneful and aggressive songs from the early lineup, Smith pouring it on along with the band as a whole. The driving funk of "Music Scene," meanwhile, redefines misanthropy (and more) with a particularly central Smith target in mind. "No Xmas for John Quays," meanwhile, almost establishes the Fall formula on its own -- Smith chanting and yelling over a quick, semi-rockabilly shamble and attack punctuated with unexpected stops and starts. Note -- the Cog Sinister CD re-release of the album, in keeping with similar perverse reissues in the Fall's back catalog, is mastered directly from vinyl, and more than once sounds it. ~ Ned Raggett, All Music Guide

Tracks

Track TitleComposersPerformersTime
Frightened Tony Friel, Mark E. Smith The Fall (4:57)
Crap Rap 2/Like to Blow Mark E. Smith, Martin Bramah The Fall (2:02)
Rebellious Jukebox Mark E. Smith, Martin Bramah The Fall (2:51)
No Xmas for John Quays Mark E. Smith The Fall (4:32)
Mother-Sister! Mark E. Smith, Una Baines The Fall (3:18)
Industrial Estate Martin Bramah, Mark E. Smith, Tony Friel The Fall (1:59)
Underground Medecin Mark E. Smith, Martin Bramah The Fall (2:05)
Two Steps Back Martin Bramah, Brix Smith The Fall (4:56)
Live at the Witch Trials Mark E. Smith The Fall (:50)
Futures and Pasts The Fall The Fall (2:33)
Music Scene Yvonne Pawlett, Marc Riley, Martin Bramah, Mark E. Smith The Fall (7:46)

Credits

Robin Ayling (Coordination), Kay Carroll (Management), Karl Burns (?), Mark E. Smith (Vocals), Mark E. Smith (?), Martin Bramah (Guitar), Marc Riley (Producer), Alvin Clark (Engineer), Karl Burns (Producer), Yvonne Pawlett (Piano (Electric)), Martin Bramah (Guitar (Electric)), Karl Burns (Drums), Martin Bramah (Arranger), Yvonne Pawlett (Keyboards), Martin Bramah (Vocals), Marc Riley (Bass), Marc Riley (Guitar), Yvonne Pawlett (Producer), Bob Sargeant (Producer), Martin Bramah (Producer), Marc Riley (?), Steve Lyons (Photography), Yvonne Pawlett (?)
Search unanswered questions...
Enter a question here...
Search: All sources Community Q&A Reference topics
Wikipedia: Live at the Witch Trials
Top
Live at the Witch Trials
Studio album by The Fall
Released 16 March 1979
Recorded Camden Sound Suite
15 December 1978
Genre Post punk
Length 38:33
Label Step Forward
Producer The Fall, Bob Sargeant
Professional reviews
The Fall chronology
Live at the Witch Trials
(1979)
Dragnet
(1979)
Alternate cover
Cover of original US edition

Live at the Witch Trials is the debut album by The Fall, first released on 16 March 1979. It is not, despite its title, a live album, but was recorded in the studio in one day and mixed by producer Bob Sargeant the next. In 2004, bassist Marc Riley told the BBC that the group had been booked into the studio for a week but that Mark E. Smith had fallen ill, leading to the cancellation of the first 3 days. No singles were taken from the album, a practice that would be commonplace for the group until the late 80s.

Some songs dated from earlier incarnations of the group with both Tony Friel and Una Baines featuring on the writing credits. Described by AMG as "brilliantly scabrous"[1], the album was given a generally positive reception, with Record Mirror in particular giving it a full five stars and describing the album as "a rugged, concerned, attuned, rebellious jukebox"[2]. Melody Maker was less impressed, being especially negative about the group's then-rhythm section of Marc Riley and Karl Burns[3]. In the event, by the time the album was released, Burns had already left the band and guitarist Martin Bramah also quit shortly afterwards to form Blue Orchids, leaving Mark E. Smith as the sole remaining founder member.

Contents

Track listing

Original UK edition

Side one

  1. "Frightened" (Mark E. Smith, Tony Friel) – 5:02
  2. "Crap Rap 2" / "Like to Blow" (Martin Bramah, Smith) – 2:04
  3. "Rebellious Jukebox" (Smith, Bramah) – 2:51
  4. "No Xmas for John Quays" (Smith) – 4:38
  5. "Mother-Sister!" (Smith, Una Baines) – 3:20
  6. "Industrial Estate" (Friel, Bramah, Smith) – 2:00

Side two

  1. "Underground Medecin" (Bramah, Smith) – 2:08
  2. "Two Steps Back" (Bramah, Smith) – 5:03
  3. "Live at the Witch Trials" (Smith) – 0:51
  4. "Futures and Pasts" (Bramah, Smith) – 2:36
  5. "Music Scene" (Bramah, Yvonne Pawlett, Smith, Marc Riley) – 8:00

Original US edition

The US release of the album, also in 1979, came in alternate artwork and removed "Mother-Sister!" and "Industrial Estate", replacing them with "Various Times", the b-side of the group's second single "It's The New Thing". All subsequent editions have followed the original UK tracklisting.

Reissues

The album was available in its original form until the late '80s, being reissued on vinyl, cassette and CD by IRS Records in 1989. In 1997, Mark E. Smith's own Cog Sinister label issued a CD edition that was poorly mastered from a below-standard vinyl copy. However, in conjunction with Voiceprint, Cog Sinister reissued the album again in 2002 in greatly improved sound quality and adding the tracks from the group's first two singles, "Bingo Master's Breakout" and "It's The New Thing". In 2004, Castle Music released a definitive 2 CD edition of the album, mastered from the original tapes and with a vastly expanded tracklisting.

Disc one - 2004 edition

  1. "Frightened"
  2. "Crap Rap 2" / "Like to Blow"
  3. "Rebellious Jukebox"
  4. "No Xmas for John Quays"
  5. "Mother-Sister!"
  6. "Industrial Estate"
  7. "Underground Medecin"
  8. "Two Steps Back"
  9. "Live at the Witch Trials"
  10. "Futures and Pasts"
  11. "Music Scene"
  12. "Bingo-Master's Break-Out!"
  13. "Psycho Mafia"
  14. "Repetition"
  15. "It's The New Thing"
  16. "Various Times"
  17. "Dresden Dolls"
  18. "Psycho Mafia"
  19. "Industrial Estate"
  20. "Stepping Out"
  21. "Last Orders"

Tracks 12-14 formed the "Bingo Master's Break-Out!" EP, originally released August 1978 with tracks 15 and 16 being the group's second single, originally issued November 1978. Tracks 17-19 were a summer 1977 rehearsal tape which had previously emerged on a bootleg single whilst tracks 20 and 21 were October, 1977 live recordings previously issued on a Virgin Records compilation Short Circuit - Live At The Electric Circus.

Disc two - 2004 edition

  1. "Rebellious Jukebox"
  2. "Mother-Sister!"
  3. "Industrial Estate"
  4. "Futures And Pasts"
  5. "Put Away"
  6. "Mess Of My"
  7. "No Xmas For John Key" (sic)
  8. "Like To Blow"
  9. "Like To Blow"
  10. "Stepping Out"
  11. "Two Steps Back"
  12. "Mess Of My"
  13. "It's The New Thing"
  14. "Various Times"
  15. "Bingo-Master's Break-Out!"
  16. "Frightened"
  17. "Industrial Estate"
  18. "Psycho Mafia"
  19. "Music Scene"
  20. "Mother-Sister!"

Tracks 1-4 were the group's first session for John Peel, tracks 5-8 being their second. The remainder were taken from Liverpool 78, a live album recorded at Mr Pickwick's in Liverpool on 22 August 1978. The sound quality is inferior but the recording is of historical interest.

Miscellanea

In his autobiography Head On, Julian Cope claims that the lyric of "Two Steps Back" refers to him; the song does contain the line "Julian says 'How was the gear?'".

Personnel

External links


 
 

 

Copyrights:

Album Review. Copyright © 2009 All Media Guide, LLC. Content provided by All Music Guide ®, a trademark of All Media Guide, LLC. All rights reserved.  Read more
Wikipedia. This article is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Live at the Witch Trials" Read more