Mathematical coincidence

Wikipedia on Answers.com:

Mathematical coincidence

Top

Home > Library > Miscellaneous > Wikipedia

This article may be too technical for most readers to understand. Please help improve this article to make it understandable to non-experts, without removing the technical details. The talk page may contain suggestions. (March 2012)

This article is about numerical curiosities. For the technical mathematical concept of coincidence, see coincidence point.

A mathematical coincidence can be said to occur when two expressions show a near-equality that lacks direct theoretical explanation. For example, there is a near-equality around the round number 1000 between powers of two and powers of ten: $2^{10} = 1024 \approx 1000 = 10^3$ . Some of these coincidences are used in engineering when one expression is taken as an approximation of the other.

Introduction

A mathematical coincidence often involves an integer, and the surprising (or "coincidental") feature is the fact that a real number arising in some context is considered by some ill-defined standard as a "close" approximation to a small integer or to a multiple or power of ten, or more generally, to a rational number with a small denominator. Other kinds of mathematical coincidence than near-integer reals, such as integers simultaneously satisfying multiple seemingly unrelated criteria or coincidences regarding units of measurement. In the class of those coincidences that are of a purely mathematical sort, some simply result from sometimes very deep mathematical facts, while others appear to come 'out of the blue'.

Given the countably infinite number of ways of forming mathematical expressions using a finite number of symbols, the number of symbols used and the precision of approximate equality might be the most obvious way to assess mathematical coincidences; but there is no standard, and the strong law of small numbers is the sort of thing one has to appeal to with no formal opposing mathematical guidance.^{[citation needed]} Beyond this, some sense of mathematical aesthetics could be invoked to adjudicate the value of a mathematical coincidence, and there are in fact exceptional cases of true mathematical significance (see Ramanujan's constant below, which made it into print some years ago as a scientific April Fools' joke^[1]). All in all, though, they are generally to be considered for their curiosity value or, perhaps, to encourage new mathematical learners at an elementary level.

Some examples

Rational approximants

Sometimes simple rational approximations are exceptionally close to interesting irrational values. These are explainable in terms of large terms in the continued fraction representation of the irrational value, but further insight into why such improbably large terms occur is often not available.

Rational approximants (convergents of continued fractions) to ratios of logs of different numbers are often invoked as well, making coincidences between the powers of those numbers.^[2]

Many other coincidences are combinations of numbers that put them into the form that such rational approximants provide close relationships.

Concerning π

The first convergent of π, [3; 7] = 22/7 = 3.1428..., was known to Archimedes,^[3] and is correct to about 0.04%. The third convergent of π, [3; 7, 15, 1] = 355/113 = 3.1415929..., found by Zu Chongzhi,^[4] is correct to six decimal places;^[3] this high accuracy comes about because π has an unusually large next term in its continued fraction representation: π = [3; 7, 15, 1, 292, ...].^[5]

A coincidence involving π and the golden ratio φ is given by $\pi \approx 4 / \sqrt{\varphi} = 3.1446\dots$ . This is related to Kepler triangles.

The Feynman point is a sequence of six 9s that begins at the 762nd decimal place of the decimal representation of pi. For a randomly chosen normal number, the probability of any chosen number sequence of six digits (including 6 of a number, 658 020, or the like) occurring this early in the decimal representation is only 0.08%. Pi is conjectured, but not known, to be a normal number.

Concerning base 2

The coincidence $2^{10} = 1024 \approx 1000 = 10^3$ , correct to 2.4%, relates to the rational approximation $\textstyle\frac{\log10}{\log2} \approx 3.3219 \approx \frac{10}{3}$ , or $2 \approx 10^{3/10}$ to within 0.3%. This relationship is used in engineering, for example to approximate a factor of two in power as 3 dB (actual is 3.0103 dB – see 3dB-point), or to relate a kilobyte to a kibibyte; see binary prefix.^[6]^[7]

This coincidence can also be expressed $5^3 = 125 \approx 128 = 2^7$ , and is invoked for instance in shutter speed settings on cameras, as approximations to powers of two in the sequence of speeds 125, 250, 500, etc.^[2]

Concerning musical intervals

The coincidence $2^{19} \approx 3^{12}$ , from $\frac{\log3}{\log2} \approx 1.5849\dots \approx \frac{19}{12}$ leads to the observation commonly used in music to relate the tuning of 7 semitones of equal temperament to a perfect fifth of just intonation: $2^{7/12}\approx 3/2;$ , correct to about 0.1%. The just fifth is the basis of Pythagorean tuning and most known systems of music. From the consequent approximation ${(3/2)}^{12}\approx 2^7,$ it follows that the circle of fifths terminates seven octaves higher than the origin.^[2]

The coincidence $\sqrt[12]{2}\sqrt[7]{5} = 1.33333319\ldots \approx \frac43$ leads to the rational version of 12-TET, as noted by Johann Kirnberger.^{[citation needed]}

The coincidence $\sqrt[8]{5}\sqrt[3]{35} = 4.00000559\ldots \approx 4$ leads to the rational version of quarter-comma meantone temperament.^{[citation needed]}

The coincidence $\sqrt[9]{0.6}\sqrt[28]{4.9} = 0.99999999754\ldots \approx 1$ leads to the very tiny interval of $2^{9}3^{-28}5^{37}7^{-18}$ (about a millicent wide), which is the first 7-limit interval tempered out in 103169-TET.^{[citation needed]}

Numerical expressions

Concerning powers of pi

$\pi^2\approx10;$ correct to about 1.3%.^[8] This can be understood in terms of the formula for the zeta function $\zeta(2)=\pi^2/6.$ ^[9] This coincidence was used in the design of slide rules, where the "folded" scales are folded on $\pi$ rather than $\sqrt{10},$ because it is a more useful number and has the effect of folding the scales in about the same place.^{[citation needed]}
$\pi^2\approx 227/23,$ correct to 0.0004%.^[8]
$\pi^3\approx 31,$ correct to 0.02%.
$\pi\approx\left(9^2+\frac{19^2}{22}\right)^{1/4},$ or $22\pi^4\approx 2143;$ ^[10] accurate to 8 decimal places (due to Ramanujan: Quarterly Journal of Mathematics, XLV, 1914, pp350–372). Ramanujan states that this "curious approximation" to $\pi$ was "obtained empirically" and has no connection with the theory developed in the remainder of the paper.

Some plausible relations hold to a high degree of accuracy, but are nevertheless coincidental. One example is:

$\int_0^\infty \cos(2x)\prod_{n=1}^\infty \cos\left(\frac{x}{n}\right)dx \approx \frac{\pi}{8}$

The two sides of this expression only differ after the 42nd decimal place.^[11]

Containing both pi and e

$\pi^4+\pi^5\approx e^6$ , within 0.000 005%^[10]

$e^\pi - \pi\approx 19.99909998$ is very close to 20 (Conway, Sloane, Plouffe, 1988); this is equivalent to $(\pi+20)^i=-0.999 999 999 2\ldots -i\cdot 0.000 039\ldots \approx -1$ ^[10]

$\pi^{3^2}/e^{2^3}\approx 9.9998$ ^[10]

Containing pi or e and 163

${163}\cdot (\pi - e) \approx 69$ , within 0.0005%^[10]

$\frac{163}{\ln 163} \approx 2^{5}$ , within 0.000004% ^[10]

Ramanujan's constant: $e^{\pi\sqrt{163}} \approx (2^6\cdot 10005)^3+744$ , within $2.9\cdot 10^{-28}%$ , discovered in 1859 by Charles Hermite.^[12] This very close approximation is not a typical sort of accidental mathematical coincidence, where no mathematical explanation is known or expected to exist (as is the case for most others here). It is a consequence of the fact that 163 is a Heegner number.

Other numerical curiosities

$10! = 6! \cdot 7! = 1! \cdot 3! \cdot 5! \cdot 7!$ .^[13]
$\sin(666^\circ) = \cos(6\cdot6\cdot6^\circ) = - \varphi/2$ , where $\varphi$ is the golden ratio^[14] (an amusing equality with an angle expressed in degrees) (see Number of the Beast)
$\,\phi(666)=6\cdot6\cdot6$ , where $\phi$ is Euler's totient function^[14]
$\, 2^3=8$ and $3^2=9\,$ are the only non-trivial (i.e. at least square) consecutive powers of positive integers (Catalan's conjecture).
$\tan(30^\circ) = \frac{\sqrt{3}}{3}$ = 0.57735, very close to the Euler–Mascheroni constant, 0.57721...
$\,4^2 = 2^4$ is the only positive integer solution of $a^b = b^a, a\neq b$ ^[15] (see Lambert's W function for a formal solution method)
31, 331, 3331 etc. up to 33333331 are all prime numbers, but then 333333331 is not.^[16] See also Formula for primes.
The Fibonacci number F₂₉₆₁₈₂ is (probably) a semiprime, since F₂₉₆₁₈₂ = F₁₄₈₀₉₁ × L₁₄₈₀₉₁ where F₁₄₈₀₉₁ (30949 digits) and the Lucas number L₁₄₈₀₉₁ (30950 digits) are simultaneously probable primes.^[17]
The solution to F_x=x+1, when multiplied by 200 is, to 4 decimal places is 1119.0000, almost exactly 1119.
In a discussion of the birthday problem, the number $\lambda=\frac{1}{365}{23\choose 2}$ occurs, which is "amusingly" equal to $\ln(2)$ to 4 digits.^[18]

Decimal coincidences

$2^5 \cdot 9^2 = 2592$ . This makes 2592 a nice Friedman number.^[19]
$\,1! + 4! + 5! = 145$ . The only such factorions (in base 10) are 1, 2, 145, 40585.^[20]
$\frac {16} {64} = \frac {1\!\!\!\not6} {\not6 4} = \frac {1} {4}$ , $\frac {26} {65} = \frac {2\!\!\!\not6} {\not6 5} = \frac {2} {5}$ , $\frac {19} {95} = \frac {1\!\!\!\not9} {\not9 5} = \frac {1} {5}$ , $\frac{49}{98}=\frac{4\!\!\!\not9}{\not98}=\frac{4}{8}$ (anomalous cancellation^[21])
$\,(4 + 9 + 1 + 3)^3 = 4{,}913$ and $\,(1 + 9 + 6 + 8 + 3)^3=19{,}683$ .^[22]
$\,2^7 - 1 = 127$ . This can also be written $\,127 = -1 + 2^7$ , making 127 the smallest nice Friedman number.^[19]
$\,1^3 + 5^3 + 3^3 = 153$ ; $\,3^3 + 7^3 + 0^3 = 370$ ; $\,3^3 + 7^3 +1^3 = 371$ ; $\,4^3 + 0^3 +7^3 = 407$ — all narcissistic numbers^[23]
$\,(3 + 4)^3 = 343$ ^[24]
$\,588^2+2353^2 = 5882353$ and also $\, 1/17 = 0.0588235294117647\ldots$ when rounded to 8 digits is 0.05882353. Mentioned by Gilbert Labelle in ~1980.^{[citation needed]} 5882353 also happens to be prime.
$\,2646798 = 2^1+6^2+4^3+6^4+7^5+9^6+8^7$ . The largest such number is 12157692622039623539.^[25]
73 is the 21st prime and 37 is the 12th prime. Both are reverse numbers. It is the only known combination.
The final 21 digits of 99⁹⁹, 999779999159200499899, is prime in addition to having 12 copies of the digit 9.^[26]
If one considers primes that give primes via digital substitution from bases 2 and 3 to base 10 (reading a representation of a number in one base to be that of a--different--number in another) twice in succession for both, the 4th of these is the first to also give a prime this way from base 4 to base 10 and the 44th is the first to do so twice. These two numbers, furthermore, both happen to lead with 234 in base 10.^[27]

Numerical coincidences in numbers from the physical world

Speed of light

The speed of light is (by definition) exactly 299,792,458 m/s, very close to 300,000 km/s. This is a pure coincidence.^[28] It also roughly equals to one foot per nanosecond (the actual number is 0.9836 ft/ns).

Earth's diameter

The polar diameter of the Earth is equal to half a billion inches, to within 0.1%.^[29]

Gravitational acceleration

While not constant but varying depending on latitude and altitude, the acceleration caused by Earth's gravity on the surface lies between 9.74 and 9.87, which is quite close to 10. This means that as a result of Newton's second law, the weight of a kilogram of mass on Earth's surface corresponds roughly to 10 newtons of force exerted on an object.^[30]

This is actually related to the aforementioned coincidence that the square of pi is close to 10. Originally, the meter was defined as the length of a pendulum whose half swing had a period equal to one second. Since the period of the full swing of a pendulum is approximated by the equation below, algebra shows that if this definition was maintained, gravitational acceleration measured in meters per second would be exactly equal to the square of pi.

$T \approx 2\pi \sqrt\frac{L}{g}$

When it was discovered that the circumference of the earth was very close to 40,000,000 times this value, the meter was redefined to reflect this, as it was a more objective standard. This had the effect of increasing the length of the meter by less than 1%, which was within the experimental error of the time.

Rydberg constant

The Rydberg constant, when multiplied by the speed of light and expressed as a frequency, is close to $\frac{\pi^2}{3}\times 10^{15} \text{Hz}$ :^[28]

$\underline{3.2898}41960364(17) \times 10^{15} \text{Hz} = R_\infty c$ ^[31]

$\underline{3.2898}68133696... = \frac{\pi^2}{3}$

Birth of Twins

In May of 2011, a pair of Conjoined twins was born in China 6 days short of the 200th anniversary of the birth of Chang and Eng and described to be similarly attached (Conjoined twins may be attached to each other in various ways). The mathematical coincidence is that 200*365.25-6=73044=36*2029, 2029 being the larger member of the first pair of 'Twin prime years' of this millennium.

References

^ Reprinted as Gardner, Martin (2001), "Six Sensational Discoveries", The Colossal Book of Mathematics, New York: W. W. Norton & Company, pp. 674–694, ISBN 0-393-02023-1.
^ ^a ^b ^c Manfred Robert Schroeder (2008). Number theory in science and communication (2nd ed.). Springer. pp. 26–28. ISBN 978-3-540-85297-1. http://books.google.com/?id=2KV2rfP0yWEC&pg=PA27&dq=coincidence+circle-of-fifths+1024+7-octaves+%22one+part+in+a+thousand%22.
^ ^a ^b Petr Beckmann (1971). A History of Pi. Macmillan. pp. 101, 170. ISBN 978-0-312-38185-1. http://books.google.com/?id=TB6jzz3ZDTEC&pg=PA101&dq=pi+113+355++digits.
^ Yoshio Mikami (1913). Development of Mathematics in China and Japan. B. G. Teubner. p. 135. http://books.google.com/?id=4e9LAAAAMAAJ&q=intitle:Development+intitle:%22China+and+Japan%22+355&dq=intitle:Development+intitle:%22China+and+Japan%22+355.
^ Eric W. Weisstein (2003). CRC concise encyclopedia of mathematics. CRC Press. p. 2232. ISBN 978-1-58488-347-0. http://books.google.com/?id=_8TyhSqHUiEC&pg=PA2232&dq=pi+113+355++292+convergent.
^ Ottmar Beucher (2008). Matlab und Simulink. Pearson Education. p. 195. ISBN 978-3-8273-7340-3. http://books.google.com/?id=VgLCb7B3OtYC&pg=PA195&dq=3.0103+1024+1000.
^ K. Ayob (2008). Digital Filters in Hardware: A Practical Guide for Firmware Engineers. Trafford Publishing. p. 278. ISBN 978-1-4251-4246-9. http://books.google.com/?id=6nmnbIxpY3MC&pg=PA278&dq=3.0103-db.
^ ^a ^b Frank Rubin, The Contest Center – Pi.
^ Why is $\pi^2$ so close to 10?, Noam Elkies
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f Weisstein, Eric W., "Almost Integer" from MathWorld.
^ http://crd.lbl.gov/~dhbailey/dhbpapers/math-future.pdf
^ Barrow, John D (2002). The Constants of Nature. London: Jonathan Cape. ISBN 0-224-06135-6.
^ Harvey Heinz, Narcissistic Numbers.
^ ^a ^b Weisstein, Eric W., "Beast Number" from MathWorld.
^ Ask Dr. Math, "Solving the Equation x^y = y^x".
^ Prime Curios!: 33333331 at The Prime Pages.
^ David Broadhurst, "Prime Curios!: 10660...49391 (61899-digits)".
^ Richard Arratia, Larry Goldstein, and Louis Gordon (1990). "Poisson approximation and the Chen-Stein method". Statistical Science 5 (4): 403–434. http://www.stat.wisc.edu/courses/st992-newton/smmb/files/align/arratia.pdf.
^ ^a ^b Erich Friedman, Problem of the Month (August 2000).
^ (sequence A014080 in OEIS)
^ Weisstein, Eric W., "Anomalous Cancellation" from MathWorld.
^ (sequence A061209 in OEIS)
^ (sequence A005188 in OEIS)
^ Prime Curios!: 343.
^ (sequence A032799 in OEIS)
^ Prime Curios!: 999779999159200499899
^ Prime Curios!:4
^ ^a ^b Michon, Gérard P.. "Numerical Coincidences in Man-Made Numbers". Mathematical Miracles. http://www.numericana.com/answer/miracles.htm. Retrieved 29 April 2011.
^ Smythe, Charles (2004). Our Inheritance in the Great Pyramid. Kessinger Publishing. p. 39. ISBN 1-4179-7429-X. http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=xB0WSOokTg0C&pg=PA39.
^ Cracking the AP Physics B & C Exam, 2004-2005 Edition. Princeton Review Publishing. 2003. p. 25. ISBN 0-375-76387-2. http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=XcX_TvhNjK0C&pg=PA25&dq=approximation.
^ "Rydberg constant times c in Hz". Fundamental physical constants. NIST. http://physics.nist.gov/cgi-bin/cuu/Value?rydchz. Retrieved 25 July 2011.

External links

(Russian) В. Левшин. – Магистр рассеянных наук. – Москва, Детская Литература 1970, 256 с.
Hardy, G. H. – A Mathematician's Apology. – New York: Cambridge University Press, 1993, (ISBN 0-521-42706-1)
Weisstein, Eric W., "Almost Integer" from MathWorld.
Various mathematical coincidences in the "Science & Math" section of futilitycloset.com
Press, W. H., Seemingly Remarkable Mathematical Coincidences Are Easy to Generate

This entry is from Wikipedia, the leading user-contributed encyclopedia. It may not have been reviewed by professional editors (see full disclaimer)

Donate to Wikimedia

Mathematical coincidence

Top

Home > Library > History, Politics & Society > FiveMinPersistent

Click to Play

Record of Agarest War - Battle Sequence Video

Click to Play

How Coincident TV's Online Video Player Works

Click to Play

Learn about Parallel, Perpendicular, Intersecting, and Coinciding Lines

Click to Play

Learning English - Lesson 11 (Irony

View more Science videos

Help us answer these

What is a unique mathematical property of Euler the mathematical constant?

What is the difference between mathematical sentence and mathematical phrase?

Difference between mathematical and non mathematical ecomomics?

What are mathematical experiments?

Post a question - any question - to the WikiAnswers community:

Copyrights:

Cite

Wikipedia on Answers.com This article is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article Mathematical coincidence. Read

Answer these

What are the mathematical symbols to mathematical verbs?

What is not mathematical?

What is coincidence?

How do mathematical proof and mathematical reason related?

» more

Featured guides

» More

Mentioned in

Strong Law of Small Numbers

Special case

Almost integer

Coincidence

Experimental mathematics

» More

Company
About
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
IP Issues
Disclaimer

Community
Guidelines
Reputation
Roles
Help

Updates
Email
Watchlist
RSS

International sites
English
|
Deutsch
|
Español
|
Français
|
Italiano
|
Tagalog

facebook
twitter
youtube

Featured topics:

Mathematical coincidence

Mathematical coincidence

Introduction

Some examples

Rational approximants

Concerning π

Concerning base 2

Concerning musical intervals

Numerical expressions

Concerning powers of pi

Containing both pi and e

Containing pi or e and 163

Other numerical curiosities

Decimal coincidences

Numerical coincidences in numbers from the physical world

Speed of light

Earth's diameter

Gravitational acceleration

Rydberg constant

Birth of Twins

See also

References

External links

Mathematical coincidence

Related answers

Help us answer these

Post a question - any question - to the WikiAnswers community:

Copyrights:

Related answers

Answer these

Featured guides

Mentioned in

Ads by Google

Site

Company

Community

Updates

International sites