Men with Guns

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Email
AMG AllMovie Guide:

Men with Guns

Top

Plot

A powerful political allegory set in an unnamed Latin American country, Men With Guns concerns Dr. Fuentes (Federico Luppi), an elderly physician long involved with a group that trains young people to provide health care for the poverty-stricken citizens of the outlying hill country, where small agricultural communities struggle to survive under primitive living conditions. The doctor has heard rumors that many of his former students are lost and feared dead, so he goes into the hills to investigate. The deeper he digs into the jungle, the more Fuentes finds that the people are menaced by "men with guns'" -- military forces who use torture and execution to intimidate the people, and guerillas from opposition groups whose agenda is only marginally more benign. Accumulating several travelling companions -- a defrocked priest, a deserter from the Army, a boy who survives by stealing, and a woman who has turned mute since she was raped -- Fuentes finds that his journey becomes more revealing but also more perilous the deeper he ventures into the hills. American writer and director John Sayles filmed most of Men With Guns in Spanish (an language he speaks fluently), as well as several indigenous dialects; he claims to have based most of the film's incidents on actual events that have occurred in a number of different Third World nations. Mandy Patinkin has a brief role as an American tourist Fuentes encounters in his travels. ~ Mark Deming, Rovi

Review

Men With Guns fell victim to a surprisingly cool reception upon its release, one that suggested John Sayles' long winning streak had finally been broken. This powerful and uncompromising film simply doesn't bear that notion out. Maybe the muted response had more to do with the general unwillingness to acknowledge the reality of Third World violence, a topic Sayles confronts head-on here. That he chose to set the film in an unnamed Spanish-speaking country allows him to deal with generalities rather than specifics and frees Men With Guns from the overt didacticism from which it might otherwise have suffered. In a performance of tremendous gravity, Frederic Luppi conveys the confusion of a man whose long-accepted notions of good and evil fall victim to the grim scenes he encounters, recognizing that whatever ideology they profess, it is a far more simplistic approach to politics that drives the competing bands of armed men. Ever humane, Sayles offers glimmers of hope, but overall the film remains as grim as its subject matter. This grimness may have been the source of some viewers' complaints, but it would have done a disservice to the subject to portray it otherwise. ~ Keith Phipps, Rovi

Cast

  • Federico Luppi - Dr. Fuentes
  • Damian Delgado - Domingo, the soldier
  • Dan Rivera Gonzalez - Conejo, the boy
  • Tania Cruz - Graciela, the mute girl
  • Damián Alcázar - Padre Portillo, the priest
  • Mandy Patinkin - Andrew
  • Kathryn Grody - Harriet
  • Iguandili Lopez - Mother
Nandi Luna Ramirez - Daughter; Rafael De Quevedo - General; Roverto Sosa - Bravo; Danny Rivera

Credit

Salvador Parra - Art Director, Peter Gilbert - Associate Producer, Jim De Nardo - Associate Producer, Eric Robison - Associate Producer, Doug Sayles - Associate Producer, Lizzie Curry Martinez - Casting, Bertha Navarro - Co-producer, Mayes C. Rubeco - Costume Designer, Manuel Hinojosa - First Assistant Director, John Sayles - Director, John Sayles - Editor, John Sloss - Executive Producer, Lou Gonda - Executive Producer, Jody Patton - Executive Producer, Mason K. Daring - Composer (Music Score), Felipe Fernandez del Paso - Production Designer, Slawomir Idziak - Cinematographer, Maggie Renzi - Producer, R. Paul Miller - Producer, Miguel A. Alvarez - Set Designer, Judy Karp - Sound/Sound Designer, John Sayles - Screenwriter

Previous:Men with Brooms (2002 Film), Men on the Mountains (1942 Film)
Next:Men with Guns (1998 Film), Men with Steel Faces (1940 Film)
Top
Men with Guns

DVD cover
Directed by John Sayles
Produced by Lou Gonda
Jody Patton
R. Paul Miller
Maggie Renzi
Written by John Sayles
Starring Federico Luppi
Damián Delgado
Damián Alcázar
Mandy Patinkin
Music by Mason Daring
Cinematography Slawomir Idziak
Editing by John Sayles
Studio Independent Film Channel
Clear Blue Sky
Distributed by Sony Pictures Classics
TriStar
Release date(s) September 5, 1997 (1997-09-05) (Canada)
March 27, 1998 (1998-03-27) (United States)
Running time 127 minutes
Country United States
Language Spanish
Mayan
Kuna
Nahuatl
Tzotzil
English
Budget $2.5 million
Box office $910,773[1]

Men with Guns (Spanish: Hombres armados) is a 1997 American drama film written and directed by John Sayles. The executive producers were Lou Gonda and Jody Patton, and the cast included Federico Luppi, Damián Delgado and Mandy Patinkin.[2]

Set in an unnamed Central or South American country, it is the story of one man's discovery of what actually happened in the political history of his nation as well as his students. It was filmed in Mexico and most of the crew were Mexican.

Contents

Plot

Federico Luppi and Dan Rivera Gonzalez.

Dr. Fuentes (Federico Luppi) is a medical professor near his retirement. He has taught a group that trains young people to provide health care to poverty-stricken citizens in the outlying hill country, where small agricultural communities struggle to survive. He's also been largely ignorant of the political events in his country.

Fuentes has recently heard rumors that his former students are lost and possibly dead, so he musters up the courage and travels into the outlands to investigate. As Fuentes digs into the jungle he discovers that his students have been menaced by many men with guns. This indicates military forces who use torture and execution to intimidate people. He discovers that the guerillas from opposition political groups are only marginally less aggressive.

On his journey he accumulates a few travelling companions: Padre Portillo (Damián Alcázar), a defrocked priest who's lost his faith; Domingo (Damián Delgado), a deserter from the Army without a country; Conejo (Dan Rivera Gonzalez), an orphan who survives by stealing; and Graciela (Tania Cruz), a woman who has turned mute after she was raped by the military.

Fuentes finds that his journey is revealing but also perilous the deeper he ventures. He ends up travelling into the hill country, looking for his last student, who is rumored to be living in an Edenic village high in the mountains, safe from the violence which has engulfed the countryside. As the doctor and his companions get closer to this half-mythical place, the journey becomes a quest for both safety and an assurance for Fuentes that his life has had some meaning.

Cast

Background

Principal photography was done in thirty-seven shooting days in January and February 1997 and filmed in over forty locations.

John Sayles' films tend to be politically aware and social concerns are a theme running through most of his work. This film's idea came from his friends, one of whom was the novelist Francisco Goldman. He had an uncle who was a doctor in Guatemala and was involved in an international health program. A few years later he came to find out that most of his students, whom he had sent off to serve as rural doctors, had been murdered by the government that supported the program.

Sayles does not name the country in the film, and the music he uses is quite eclectic and not tied to any specific Latin American country. This is because Sayles didn't want people to think that it can "only happen in El Salvador, that can only happen in Guatemala or Mexico". He felt the film has universal overtones and the events portrayed in the story could have happened anywhere on the planet.[3] It should be noted, however, that logically the setting cannot be Mexico, because during an argument with Mandy Patinkin's character, Fuentes claims that the human sacrifices the tourist claims took place in Fuentes' country actually occurred in Mexico, committed by "foreigners from the north."

Filming locations
The movie was filmed entirely in Mexico, in 40 locations, including: Mexico City; Ciudad Nezahualcóyotl; Pueblo Naranjal, Xonotzintla, Soledad Atzompa, Zongolica, and Jalapilla, all in Veracruz; Palenque and San José Babilonia, both in Chiapas.

Distribution

Men with Guns was first presented at the Telluride Film Festival, Colorado, the weekend of August 29 - September 1, 1997.[4] A few days later its international debut was at the Toronto Film Festival on September 5, 1997. It opened in the United States on March 27, 1998.[5]

The film was featured at various international film festivals, including: the Deauville Film Festival, France; the Donostia-San Sebastián International Film Festival, Spain; the Edinburgh International Film Festival, Scotland; the Helsinki International Film Festival, Finland; the Reykjavik Film Festival, Iceland; and others.

Critical reception

Roger Ebert, film critic writing for the Chicago Sun-Times, liked the film, and wrote, "Men With Guns is immensely moving and sad, and yet because it dares so much, it is an exhilarating film. It frees itself from specific stories about this villain or that strategy, to stand back and look at the big picture: at societies in collapse because power has been concentrated in the hands of small men made big with guns."[6]

Critic Jack Mathews liked Sayles straightforward unadorned style, and he wrote, "Men With Guns is a slow-paced trip, with a lot of translated conversation, and Sayles keeps it pure. The actors are said to be speaking in four dialects, and there's nothing about the film, other than the ill-conceived couple (Mandy Patinkin and Kathryn Grody) used as comic relief, to give away its American origin. Sayles has never been a visual stylist, and his latest film is as straightforward and plot-bound as any of the earlier ones."[7]

The review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes reported that 88% of critics gave the film a positive review, based on twenty-five reviews.[8]

Soundtrack

CD cover

An original motion picture soundtrack was released by Rykodisc on February 24, 1998. The CD contains twenty-three tracks (00:43:10), and includes songs heard in the film and the film score written by Mason Daring.

The music is universally Latin in flavor. The various styles include: cumbias, the Colombian dance music; a brass band; an orquestra, of Mayan culture; Peruvian Susana Baca singing a cappella; El General's funky hip-hop; and Mason Daring's bass marimba and Spanish guitar-driven score.[9]

Awards

Wins

Nominated

References

  1. ^ Box Office Mojo web site.
  2. ^ Men With Guns at the Internet Movie Database.
  3. ^ Men with Guns, Sony Classic Pictures Official Web Site, production section.
  4. ^ Willman, Chris. Entertainment Weekly, "Fathers and Guns: Cinema Tales from Telluride," issue #396, September 12, 1997.
  5. ^ Vulcan Productions web site, September 4, 1997.
  6. ^ Ebert, Roger. Chicago Sun-Times, film review, March 27, 1998.
  7. ^ Mathews, Jack. Los Angeles Times, "Sayles Again Goes His Own Way With Effective Guns," March 13, 1998.
  8. ^ Men with Guns at Rotten Tomatoes. Last accessed: November 28, 2009.
  9. ^ Moerer, Keith. Amazon.com, Editorial Review.
  10. ^ Film Festivals web page, SSIFF.

External links


Post a question - any question - to the WikiAnswers community:

Copyrights:

Mentioned in

Men With Guns (1998 Crime Film)
Men with Guns (Hombres Armados) [Rykodisc] (1998 Album by Original Soundtrack)
Lachy Hulme (Actor, Writer, Crime/Science Fiction)