| Year |
Goalkeeper |
Defenders |
Midfielders |
Forwards |
| 1996 |
 Mark Dodd, Dallas |
 Leonel Alvarez, Dallas
John Doyle, San Jose
Robin Fraser, Los Angeles |
 Mauricio Cienfuegos, Los Angeles
 Roberto Donadoni, MetroStars
 Marco Etcheverry, DC United
Preki, Kansas City
Carlos Valderrama, Tampa Bay |
 Eduardo Hurtado, Los Angeles
Roy Lassiter, Tampa Bay |
| 1997 |
Brad Friedel, Columbus |
Jeff Agoos, DC United
Thomas Dooley, Columbus
 Richard Gough, Kansas City
Eddie Pope, DC United |
Mark Chung, Kansas City
Marco Etcheverry, DC United
Preki, Kansas City
Carlos Valderrama, Tampa Bay |
Ronald Cerritos, San Jose
Jaime Moreno, DC United |
| 1998 |
Zach Thornton, Chicago |
Thomas Dooley, Columbus
Robin Fraser, Los Angeles
 Lubos Kubik, Chicago
Eddie Pope, DC United |
Chris Armas, Chicago
Mauricio Cienfuegos, Los Angeles
Marco Etcheverry, DC United
 Peter Nowak, Chicago |
 Stern John, Columbus
Cobi Jones, Los Angeles |
| 1999 |
Kevin Hartman, Los Angeles |
Jeff Agoos, DC United
Robin Fraser, Los Angeles
Lubos Kubik, Chicago |
Chris Armas, Chicago
Mauricio Cienfuegos, Los Angeles
Marco Etcheverry, DC United
Eddie Lewis, San Jose
Steve Ralston, Tampa Bay |
Jaime Moreno, DC United
Jason Kreis, Dallas |
| 2000 |
Tony Meola, Kansas City |
Robin Fraser, Los Angeles
Greg Vanney, Los Angeles
Peter Vermes, Kansas City |
Chris Armas, Chicago
Peter Nowak, Chicago
Steve Ralston, Tampa Bay
 Hristo Stoichkov, Chicago
Carlos Valderrama, Tampa Bay |
 Mamadou Diallo, Tampa Bay
Clint Mathis, MetroStars |
| 2001 |
Tim Howard, MetroStars |
Jeff Agoos, San Jose
Carlos Llamosa, Miami
Pablo Mastroeni, Miami
Greg Vanney, Los Angeles |
Chris Armas, Chicago
Peter Nowak, Chicago
Preki, Miami |
 Alex Pineda Chacon, Miami
Diego Serna, Miami
John Spencer, Colorado |
| 2002 |
Tim Howard, MetroStars |
Wade Barrett, San Jose
Carlos Bocanegra, Chicago
Alexi Lalas, Los Angeles |
Mark Chung, Colorado
 Ronnie Ekelund, San Jose
Óscar Pareja, Dallas
Steve Ralston, New England |
Jeff Cunningham, Columbus
 Carlos Ruiz, Los Angeles
Taylor Twellman, New England |
| 2003 |
 Pat Onstad, San Jose |
Carlos Bocanegra, Chicago
 Ryan Nelsen, DC United
Eddie Pope, MetroStars |
Chris Armas, Chicago
DaMarcus Beasley, Chicago
Mark Chung, Colorado
Landon Donovan, San Jose
Preki, Kansas City |
John Spencer, Colorado
Ante Razov, Chicago |
| 2004 |
Joe Cannon, Colorado |
Jimmy Conrad, Kansas City
Robin Fraser, Columbus
Ryan Nelsen, DC United
Eddie Pope, MetroStars |
Eddie Gaven, MetroStars
Amado Guevara, MetroStars
 Ronnie O'Brien, Dallas
Kerry Zavagnin, Kansas City |
Brian Ching, San Jose
Jaime Moreno, DC United |
| 2005 |
Pat Onstad, San Jose |
Chris Albright, Los Angeles
Danny Califf, San Jose
Jimmy Conrad, Kansas City |
Clint Dempsey, New England
Dwayne De Rosario, San Jose
 Christian Gomez, DC United
 Shalrie Joseph, New England
Ronnie O'Brien, Dallas |
Jaime Moreno, DC United
Taylor Twellman, New England |
| 2006 |
Troy Perkins, DC United |
Bobby Boswell, DC United
Jose Burciaga Jr., Kansas City
Jimmy Conrad, Kansas City |
Ricardo Clark, Houston
Clint Dempsey, New England
Dwayne De Rosario, Houston
Christian Gomez, DC United
Justin Mapp, Chicago |
Jeff Cunningham, Salt Lake
Jaime Moreno, DC United |
| 2007 |
Brad Guzan, Chivas USA |
Jonathan Bornstein, Chivas USA
Michael Parkhurst, New England
Eddie Robinson, Houston |
Guillermo Barros Schelotto, Columbus
Dwayne De Rosario, Houston
Christian Gomez, DC United
Shalrie Joseph, New England
Ben Olsen, DC United |
Juan Pablo Angel, New York
 Luciano Emilio, DC United |
| 2008 |
Jon Busch, Chicago |
Jimmy Conrad, Kansas City
 Bakary Soumare, Chicago
Chad Marshall, Columbus |
Guillermo Barros Schelotto, Columbus
Sacha Kljestan, Chivas USA
Robbie Rogers, Columbus
Shalrie Joseph, New England
 Cuauhtémoc Blanco, Chicago |
Landon Donovan, Los Angeles
Kenny Cooper, Dallas |
