One of the better ports of the era, Ms. Pac-Man has much of the charm and appeal of the 1981 arcade classic, including cute intermissions, a nice rendition of the theme song, solid controls (surprise, surprise), white-eyed ghosts (as opposed to the empty-stare ghosts in the 5200 version of Pac-Man), and four accurately designed mazes (even though they are square instead of rectangular). Sure, Ms. Pac-Man has a craggy mouth, and the action is a little slower than the original, but this is one game Atari 5200 owners should not miss.
~ Brett Alan Weiss, All Game Guide
Review: Overall
Riding on the strengths of Lady Bug, Mouse Trap, Oil's Well, and Pepper
II, the ColecoVision is generally thought to be superior to the Atari 5200 in terms
of maze games. Ironically, the greatest arcade maze game of all time, Ms. Pac-Man,
never made it to the ColecoVision, but it is available for the 5200. Unfortunately,
speed, one of the things that made Ms. Pac-Man such a great arcade game, is missing
from this version. The ghosts are fast enough, but Ms. Pac-Man herself moves along
as though each dot she eats briefly slows her down, making the character sluggish and the
animation choppy, even in the later rounds. She speeds up some as you progress through
game, but not enough for this jaded gamer.
Another problem with this game lies with the Atari 5200's pesky non-centering
joysticks. These too-flexible controls are not a problem with free-roaming games such as
Missile Command or Centipede, but they don't work well for games such as this
that demand precision movements.
On a brighter note, the graphics match the arcade game pretty well. Ms. Pac-Man
isn't quite as round as she should be, and her mouth is a little craggy, but the game has a
nice overall look to it. The sound is very good: the game even includes the animated
musical intermissions. However, if you've already got the 2600 version of the game,
which has better controls and gameplay, you shouldn't knock yourself out hunting down
the 5200 version.
Ms. Pac-Man is based on a very solid formula, that of maneuvering around a maze,
gobbling up dots while avoiding ghosts. It worked for Pac-Man, and it works for this
game. If you can forgive its faults, you'll manage to have a pretty good time playing
Ms. Pac-Man for the 5200.
~ Brett Alan Weiss, All Game Guide
Review: Enjoyment
After playing the arcade game and the 2600 port, you'll wonder why this game couldn't have been sped up a bit.
~ Brett Alan Weiss, All Game Guide
Review: Graphics
Ms. Pac-Man could stand to be cleaned up a little, but this is a cute and colorful game.
~ Brett Alan Weiss, All Game Guide
Review: Sound
The sound effects and musical numbers are fun.
~ Brett Alan Weiss, All Game Guide
Review: Replay Value
If you've already got the {!2600} version, don't bother with this one, unless ugraded graphics and sound effects are more important to you than gameplay.
~ Brett Alan Weiss, All Game Guide
Review: Documentation
The manual, which folds out into a poster of sorts, is attractive and informative.