The words to this song were written by Cecil Frances Humphreys Alexander, a prolific creator of hymn texts; one of her more famous efforts was All Creatures Great and Small. Composer and organist (and lawyer and much else) Henry John Gauntlett set her words to music in 1849. He was even more prolific in his work with hymns, inspiring the exaggerated claim that he composed 10,000 of them. The melody Gauntlett used for Once in Royal David's City may have been based upon an existing traditional one, possibly of British origin. It is attractive in its simple character, the first three notes of each thematic phrase rising and seeming to push for an ascendant character, an angelic tone. The theme eventually forms a sort of arched shape, though its bright, almost ecstatic second subject has a mostly descending contour. While there is a fair amount of repetition in Gauntlett's strophic treatment throughout the six verses, it is attractive still and will appeal especially to children, the audience aimed for in Alexander's text, which tells of the birth of Christ and of his childhood. ~ Robert Cummings, All Music Guide
| 100 Hymns & Songs of Inspiration |
2004 |
| 25 All Time Christmas Favorites |
2003 |
| 40 Most Beautiful Christmas Classics |
2007 |
| 50 Most Loved Christmas Carols |
2005 |
| A Celebration of Christmas: Carols Through the Ages |
1993 |
| A Child Is Born: Carols from Trinity |
|
| A Choirboy's Christmas: The Gold Collection |
1999 |
| A Christmas Collection |
2005 |
| A Christmas Festival of Songs [Barnes & Noble Exclusive] |
2005 |
| A Classical Guitar Christmas |
|
| A Festival Of Carols |
|
| A Festival of Nine Lessons & Carols |
1999 |
| A Festival of Nine Lessons & Carols |
|
| A Festival of Nine Lessons and Carols |
|
| A Joyous Christmas |
|
| A KING’S COLLEGE CHRISTMAS – CHORAL COLLECTION |
1997 |
| A King's College Christmas |
1997 |
| A Traditional Christmas Carol Collection |
1991 |
| A Traditional Christmas Collection |
|
| A Very Madrigal Christmas |
2007 |
| A Victoria Christmas in Song |
1993 |
| Adeste Fideles: Christmas Music from Westminster Cathedral |
1993 |
| All Time Christmas Favorites [3 CD Madacy] |
2005 |
| All Time Christmas Favorites [Disc #1] |
1998 |
| Best Carols 100 |
2007 |
| Best Loved Christmas Carols |
2004 |
| Canterbury Carols |
|
| Carol Collection |
1996 |
| Carolina Brass Christmas |
|
| Carols |
1996 |
| Carols From Clare College |
1988 |
| Carols From King's College Cambridge |
1997 |
| Carols at Christmas |
|
| Carols for Christmas, Vols. 1-2 |
1984 |
| Carols from King's |
|
| Carols from St. Chad's |
1999 |
| Carols from Winchester Cathedral |
2004 |
| Celebration (Christmas Fanfares & Carols) |
1991 |
| Children's Christmas Classics, Vol. 3 |
2002 |
| Chorale Christmas |
2002 |
| Christmas Adagios |
2001 |
| Christmas Album [Intersound] |
1998 |
| Christmas Angels |
|
| Christmas Angels Series |
1995 |
| Christmas Angels: A Thousand Voices in Lincoln Cathedral |
1994 |
| Christmas Around the World |
2003 |
| Christmas At Trinity |
2001 |
| Christmas Carols |
1994 |
| Christmas Carols |
1997 |
| Christmas Carols |
1997 |
| Christmas Carols |
2008 |
| Christmas Carols |
2006 |
| Christmas Carols |
1994 |
| Christmas Carols |
1996 |
| Christmas Carols [Griffin] |
1995 |
| Christmas Carols and Motets |
2008 |
| Christmas Carols from King's College |
|
| Christmas Carols from Wells & Salisbury |
2004 |
| Christmas Carols from York Minister |
2001 |
| Christmas Choirs |
2002 |
| Christmas Choirs [Lifestyles] |
2001 |
| Christmas Fanfare |
1993 |
| Christmas Gala |
2006 |
| Christmas Joy |
1996 |
| Christmas Joy, Vol. 2 |
1999 |
| Christmas Spirit |
|
| Christmas Time is Here |
2005 |
| Christmas Under Capricorn |
1995 |
| Christmas Vespers |
2008 |
| Christmas Voices |
2008 |
| Christmas With Mantovani Orchestra: The Gold Collection |
2002 |
| Christmas With the Vienna Choir Boys/Placido Domingo/Hermann Prey |
1988 |
| Christmas at St. Paul's |
1993 |
| Christmas from Truro |
2009 |
| Christmas from Wellington Cathedral |
1998 |
| Christmas in the Valleys |
2009 |
| Christmas on Fifth Avenue |
2005 |
| Christmas with Brighouse and Ratsrick |
2006 |
| Christmas with the Academy |
1994 |
| Christmas with the Choral Scholars of King's College, Cambridge |
1998 |
| Christmas with the Pro Arte Singers |
2000 |
| Christmas with the Stars [Elektra/Asylum] |
1998 |
| Christmas: A Gift to You |
2008 |
| Christmas: A Gift to You |
2008 |
| Christmastide |
1990 |
| Classic Carols for Christmas |
2008 |
| Classic Christmas |
1991 |
| Classic Christmas Carols |
2008 |
| Dagen Är Kommen |
1996 |
| Dedicated to Peace: Requested Holiday Favourites |
2006 |
| Early English Christmas Collection |
1996 |
| Encore! Christmas |
|
| Essential Carols: The Very Best of King's College Choir, Cambridge |
2005 |
| Essential Carols: The Very Best of King's College Choir, Cambridge |
2005 |
| Family Carols |
1995 |
| Favorite Christmas Carols |
|
| Favourite Carols From King's |
1990 |
| Feast of Christmas Carols |
2002 |
| Feast of Christmas Carols |
2002 |
| Festival of Lessons & Carols from King's Choir of King's College, Cambridge |
1996 |
| Festival of Lessons & Carols from King's Choir of King's College, Cambridge |
1996 |
| First Nowell: Carols from Westminster Cathedral |
2002 |
| Gabriel's Message: One Thousand Years Of Carols |
1999 |
| Greatest Christmas Carols [Platinum] |
1999 |
| Greatest Christmas Collection: Christmas Brass |
1999 |
| Greatest Christmas Collection: Great Gift |
1999 |
| Greatest Christmas Show on Earth |
1998 |
| Gruber, Mendelssohn and Gauntlett |
|
| Hark! A Thrilling Voice: Christmas at the Church of Incarnation, Dallas |
2001 |
| Harrods Christmas Nutcracker |
1997 |
| Have Yourself a Choral Little Christmas |
2001 |
| Heavenly Peace |
2006 |
| Holiday Favorites [Madacy] |
2002 |
| Holiday Instruments |
2002 |
| Holly and the Ivy [Platinum Disc] |
2001 |
| Home for the Holidays [Madacy #1] |
2004 |
| Impressions of Christmas: Musical Footsteps in the Snow |
2007 |
| In Celebration Of Christmas |
1991 |
| In Dulci Jubilo: Festive and Christmas Music |
1995 |
| Instrumental Christmas [Lifestyles] |
2001 |
| Joy To The World |
2003 |
| Joy to the World [Naxos] |
2003 |
| Joy to the World: A Garland of Christmas Music |
1997 |
| Julesang & Messingklang |
|
| King's Christmas Collection |
1998 |
| King's Christmas Collection |
1998 |
| Love Came Down at Christmas |
2005 |
| Make We Joy |
2001 |
| Merry Christmas with Plácido Domingo, Hermann Prey and the Vienna Choir Boys |
|
| Nativitas |
|
| Noel: Christmas at Kings |
1995 |
| Noël: 25 Hymns of Christmas |
2005 |
| O Magnum Mysterium |
2001 |
| On Christmas Day |
1989 |
| Once In Royal David's City 'A Celebration with the Roberts Harp Ensemble' |
2007 |
| Once Were Christmas Angels: The Pure Sound of Boy Trebles |
2006 |
| Our Dancing Day |
2004 |
| Rejoice! A String Quartet Christmas, Vol. 2 |
1997 |
| Requiem |
1999 |
| Ring Christmas Bells |
|
| See Amid the Winter's Snow: Christmas from Gloucester |
2008 |
| Simply Christmas [Universal] |
2003 |
| Small Wonder |
2003 |
| Songs of Good Cheer |
2002 |
| The #1 Christmas Album [Decca] |
2001 |
| The Best Carols in the World...Ever! |
1998 |
| The Best Of Christmas [Madacy Box] |
1996 |
| The Best of Christmas [BCI] |
2002 |
| The Christmas Album |
1995 |
| The Christmas Collection |
1997 |
| The Christmas Spirit |
1996 |
| The Complete New English Hymnal, Vol. 8 |
|
| The Gifts of Christmas |
2004 |
| The Heart of Christmas |
2007 |
| The Holly & the Ivy |
1956 |
| The Holly and the Ivy |
2006 |
| The Incredible Christmas Album |
2003 |
| The Magic of Christmas [Special Music] |
1994 |
| The Riverside Years, Vol. 2: The Choir |
|
| The Spirit of Christmas Present |
1996 |
| The Stan Kenton Christmas Carols |
2006 |
| The Traditions of Christmas |
|
| The Ultimate Christmas Album |
2008 |
| The Ultimate Relaxation Christmas Album 2 |
2005 |
| Tomorrow Shall Be My Dancing Day: Christmas at Emory University |
1994 |
| Totally Christmas, Vol. 1 |
2004 |
| Traditional Christmas Favourites |
2005 |
| Traditional English Christmas Carols |
2000 |
| Traditions: The Time Life Treasury of Christmas |
2009 |
| Ultimate Classical Christmas Album of All Time |
2002 |
| Veni, Veni, Emmanuel |
1996 |
| Victorian Christmas for Brass |
2006 |
| Vienna Boys' Choir Christmas Favorites |
1999 |
| Voices of Xmas |
2002 |
| What Sweeter Music |
2004 |
| Winter: A Collection of Seasonal Classics |
2005 |
| World's Most Beautiful Christmas Music: Silent Night |
1995 |
| Yuletide Favorites |
2001 |
