Polonaise for piano No. 5 in F sharp minor, Op. 44, CT. 154

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Email
AMG AllMusic Guide to Classical Music :

Polonaise for piano No. 5 in F sharp minor, Op. 44, CT. 154

Top

Review

Despite its title, this is a composite work, with a mazurka embedded in the middle of the polonaise. (A polonaise is usually a dance in triple meter and moderate tempo, with the accent seeming to fall on the first beat thanks to its typical rhythmic pattern: an eighth note followed by two sixteenth notes, then four more eighths. A triple-meter mazurka, in Chopin's hands, tends to sound less belligerent and more graceful, with the accents shifting to the second or third beats.) The piece is dedicated to Princess Ludmilla de Beauveau, a prominent member of the Polish émigré community in Paris.

A short, menacing opening passage announces one of Chopin's most disturbing creations, a bold theme, defiant and rather sinister, with hammering chords and growling trills. It's answered, between statements, by a series of less aggressive melodic bits, sometimes apparently trying to soothe the main matter's fury, sometimes rising passionately across the keyboard. A second section takes this same material and strips it down to a savage bass ostinato with melodic fragments fluttering above. Suddenly the mood changes as the mazurka section begins. This is delicate music of moonlight and romance, its initial tinkly nature calling the courtly eighteenth century to mind. But soon the music slips into more ominous harmonies, two isolated torrents of notes dismiss the tender mazurka section, and the violent polonaise material from the beginning rumbles back in. At length, this reprise loses its force and seems about to fade into oblivion, but Chopin dismisses the work with one final angry gesture, a fortissimo chord of octaves. ~ James Reel, Rovi

Albums with Complete Performances of the Work

Title Date
Alfred Brendel 1999
Alfred Brendel Collection, Vol. 5
Arthur Rubinstein plays Chopin [Box Set] 1993
Arthur Rubinstein: The Complete Album Collection 2011
Arthur Rubinstein: The Complete Album Collection 2011
Arthur Rubinstein: The Complete Album Collection 2011
Artur Rubinstein: The Chopin Recordings
Bach: Goldberg Variations; Beethoven: Piano Sonatas "Moonlight", "Appassionata", "Les Adieux"; Chopin: Polonaises 1992
Bach: Prelude in B minor; Handel: Chaconne in G major; Beethoven: Soanta Op. 31 No. 2 "The Tempest"; etc. 1994
Brahms: Paganini-Variationen; Chopin: Polonaise; Liszt: Réminiscences 2007
Chopin 2010
Chopin 2010
Chopin 2011
Chopin 2011
Chopin 200 Great Recordings 2009
Chopin Complete Edition
Chopin Complete Edition
Chopin Complete Edition
Chopin Exploration Vol. 10 1999
Chopin Favorites
Chopin I: Polonaises 1992
Chopin Polonaises 1996
Chopin Recitals 1999
Chopin, Volume 1 1993
Chopin: Piano Works 1996
Chopin: 11 Polonaises 2008
Chopin: 11 Polonaises 2008
Chopin: 200th Anniversary Edition
Chopin: 4 Scherzos and Other Works for Piano Solo 2004
Chopin: 5 Polonaises; 4 Impromptus; 2 Chants polonaise; etc.
Chopin: 7 Polonaises; Andante spianato; Grand polonaise brillante
Chopin: 9 Polonaises 1999
Chopin: 9 Polonaises; 23 Mazurkas 2002
Chopin: Ballada f-moll; Nokturny Es-dur, As-dur; Barkarola; Mazurki Op. 30 2011
Chopin: Ballades & Polonaises
Chopin: Ballades, Mazurkas, Polonaises 2003
Chopin: Ballades; Mazurkas; Polonaises 2003
Chopin: Compact Edition
Chopin: Complete Impromptus & Other Works 1995
Chopin: Complete Piano Music (Box Set) 1995
Chopin: Complete Piano Music, Vol. 8 1999
Chopin: Complete Piano Works 2011
Chopin: Complete Solo Piano Works in Opus Order
Chopin: Complete Solo Piano Works in Opus Order - Op. 39-47
Chopin: Complete Works [Box Set]
Chopin: Complete Works [Box Set]
Chopin: Etudes; Préludes; Polonaises 1980
Chopin: Intégrale de l'oeuvre pour piano seul (Box Set)
Chopin: Mazurkas; Polonaises; Scherzi 1993
Chopin: Nocturnes; Romantic Piano Etudes & Preludes 2006
Chopin: Paris - Nohant (1840-1841)
Chopin: Piano Concerto No. 2; Polonaise; Nocturne; 2 Etüden
Chopin: Piano Concerto in E minor; Works for Piano Solo 2012
Chopin: Piano Music (Complete) Vol. 3 (Box Set) 1993
Chopin: Piano Sonatas 2 & 3 / Polonaise Op. 44 1996
Chopin: Piano Works 1997
Chopin: Piano Works 2001
Chopin: Piano Works 2004
Chopin: Piano Works 2011
Chopin: Piano Works, Vol. 2 2001
Chopin: Poland (Box Set) 1999
Chopin: Polonaise in F sharp minor; Nocturne in B flat minor; Ballade No. 1 2000
Chopin: Polonaise; 4 Scherzi; 4 Ballades
Chopin: Polonaises 1994
Chopin: Polonaises
Chopin: Polonaises 1994
Chopin: Polonaises 1976
Chopin: Polonaises 1998
Chopin: Polonaises 1976
Chopin: Polonaises 1996
Chopin: Polonaises 2005
Chopin: Polonaises
Chopin: Polonaises 2007
Chopin: Polonaises
Chopin: Polonaises 1996
Chopin: Polonaises
Chopin: Polonaises & Waltzes
Chopin: Polonaises (Complete), Vol. 1 1992
Chopin: Polonaises No6; Grande Polonaise in Ef 1991
Chopin: Polonaises No6; Polonaises No7
Chopin: Polonaises No6; Polonaises No7
Chopin: Polonaises No6; Polonaises No7 1991
Chopin: Polonaises Nos. 1-5, 6 "Heroique" & 7 "Polonaise Fantaisie"; Andante Spinato e Grande Polonaise Brillante
Chopin: Polonaises Nos. 1-7 1997
Chopin: Polonaises; Andante Spianato; Minor Works 1999
Chopin: Polonaises; Fantaisie Impromptu; Tarantella; Berceuse 1991
Chopin: Polonaises; Mazurkas
Chopin: Polonaises; Polonaise-Fantasie; Andante Spianato & Grande Polonaise 1999
Chopin: Polonez; Etiudy; Sonata; Koncert 2011
Chopin: Polonezy; Mazurki; Nokturny
Chopin: Préludes; Etudes; Polonaises; Allegro de Concert; Marche funèbre; Ecossaises
Chopin: Scherzo/Mazurkas/Polonaise/Preludes 1993
Chopin: Scherzos No2; Fantasie in Ffm
Chopin: Solo Piano Works 2010
Chopin: Solo Piano Works 2010
Chopin: Solo Piano, Vol. 2 2005
Chopin: Sonatas for piano No3; Fantasie in Ffm
Chopin: The Complete Piano Works, Vol. 5 - Polonaises & Impromptus 1994
Chopin: The Complete Polonaises
Chopin: The Complete Waltzes and Polonaises 1994
Chopin: The Complete Works 2008
Chopin: The Great Polonaises 2010
Chopin: The Masterpieces for Piano, Vol. 1 2003
Chopin: The Most Famous Polonaises
Chopin: The Piano Works [Box Set] 1995
Chopin: The Piano Works [Box Set]
Chopin: Works for Solo Piano 2000
Chopin: Œuvres pour piano [Box Set] 2003
Classical Evolution: Chopin: Famous Piano Works II 2002
Constantin Lifschitz: Live in Milano 1994
Constantin Lifschitz: Live in Milano 1994
Favorite Chopin, Vol. 2 1987
Frederic Chopin: Polonaises
Frédéric Chopin: Piano Concerto No. 2 1983
Gabriela Montero en Concert à Montréal
Gabriela Montero en Concert à Montréal
Genuine Chopin 1991
Georges Cziffra: Ses Enregistrements Studio, 1956-1986 2008
Georges Cziffra: Ses Enregistrements Studio, 1956-1986 2008
Golden Piano [Collector's Edition] [Box Set] 2008
Golden Piano, Vol. 1 2008
Great Chopin Performers
Great Chopin Performers
Great Chopin Performers, Vol. 4: Maurizio Pollini & Halina Czerny-Stef
Great Chopin Performers: The Warsaw Recordings
Great Pianists of the 20th Century: Alfred Brendel 3 1999
Great Pianists of the 20th Century: The Complete Edition (Box 1) 1999
Great Pianists of the 20th Century: The Complete Edition (Box 2) (Box Set) 1999
Great Pianists of the Century 1996
Great Pianists of the Golden Era 1990
Grigory Sokolov & Janusz Olejniczak Play Chopin
Horowitz Plays Chopin 2003
Horowitz Plays Chopin: Sonata No. 2; Polonaises 2003
Howrani: Alma Mater 1999
Ingrid Fliter Plays Chopin
Inspiration: Homage to Maria Curcio 2011
Kemal Gekic in Concert 1999
Kissin Plays Chopin 2010
Les Rarissimes de Thierry de Brunhoff: Weber, Chopin, Schumann 2004
Malcuzynski plays great romantic piano music 2000
Maurizio Pollini 2 1999
Maurizio Pollini Plays Chopin: Warsaw 1960
Mazurkas: Chopin, Szymanowski, Maciejewski 2011
Piano Solo 2000
Romantic Piano Music
Rubinstein Collection, Vol. 28 1999
Rubinstein Collection, Vol. 4 1999
Rubinstein Collection, Vol. 48 1999
Rubinstein Collection, Vol. 62 1999
Rubinstein: Chopin Polonaises 2001
Schumann/Chopin
Simply Chopin 2007
The Alfred Brendel Collection
The Art of Guiomar Novaes 1994
The Art of Maurizio Pollini 2012
The Art of Maurizio Pollini 2012
The Best of Chopin 2011
The Chopin Collection 1991
The Chopin Collection 1995
The Chopin Collection 1991
The Chopin Collection: Polonaises 1965
The Chopin Collection: Polonaises 1965
The Chopin Experience (1928-1937)
The Chopin Recordings 2010
The Complete 1950s Chopin Recordings [Box Set]
The Complete Edition, Vol.11
The Complete Masterwork Recordings, 1962-1973 [Box Set]
The Complete Masterworks Recordings, Vol. 4: The Legendary 1968 TV Concert 1993
The Complete Vox, Turnabout and Vanguard Solo Recordings
The Genesis Recordings of Legendary Pianists, Vol. 1 1999
The Great Pianists, Vol. 8: Artur Rubinstein
The Original Chopin 1995
The Real Chopin
The Rubinstein Collection (Limited Edition) 1999
The Rubinstein Collection (Limited Edition) 1999
The Rubinstein Collection (Limited Edition) 1999
The Rubinstein Collection (Limited Edition) 1999
The World's Greatest Composers: Chopin [Collector's Edition Music Tin] 2008
The World's Greatest Composers: Chopin [Collector's Edition] 2008
The young Arthur Rubinstein, 1919 - 1924: the master Duo-Art Piano rolls 1999
Vladimir Horowitz Live at Carnegie Hall 1988
Vladimir Horowitz: The Complete Original Jacket Collection
Vladimir Horowitz: The Complete Original Jacket Collection
Vladimir Tropp Plays Chopin 1997
Vlado Perlemuter Plays Chopin (Box Set) 1993
Welte-Mignon Piano Rolls, 1905-1927 2003
Yevgeny Kissin in Tokyo 1990
Yevgeny Kissin in Tokyo [DVD Video] 2007

Albums with Excerpt Performances of the Work

Title Date
Chopin & George Sand: Letters & Music
Story Of Chopin In Words And Music 1993

Previous:Polonaise for piano No. 4 in C minor, Op. 40/2, CT. 153
Next:Polonaise for piano No. 6 in A flat major ("Héroique"), Op. 53, CT. 155

Post a question - any question - to the WikiAnswers community:

Copyrights: