These recordings of Grieg and Tchaikovsky's piano works played by Percy Grainger -- with a little help from Vladimir Horowitz, Shura Cherkassky, and Ossip Gabrilowitsch -- are about as close to reality as recordings get. Taken from piano rolls made between 1911 and 1930, these recordings are so honest that, as Grieg himself put it, "I am astounded … and join all the admiration and praise for this instrument." Re-created here from piano rolls in the collection of Australian teacher and historian Denis Condon, the sound one gets is of a real piano played in ideal circumstances and recorded under optimal conditions by artists long dead. This allows the listener to hear exactly what earlier pianists thought was the proper style for executing Grieg and Tchaikovsky. In the case of performer and composer Percy Grainger, this style is full of rolled chords, rubato tempos, stentorian sonorities, and a blithe disregard for the letter of the score in favor of the spirit of the music. Though they differ in details from Grainger, Horowitz, Cherkassky, and Gabrilowitsch's interpretations are likewise much freer in conception and execution than more recent pianists'. Anyone interested in earlier performance practices not already familiar with these recordings will surely enjoy this disc. ~ James Leonard, Rovi