AMG AllMovie Guide:

The Battle of Shaker Heights

Top

Plot

The Battle of Shaker Heights is directed by the team of Efram Potelle and Kyle Rankin. Kelly Ernswiler (Shia LaBeouf) is a quirky 17-year-old whose greatest passion is reenacting battles from World War II. After meeting Bart Bowland (Elden Henson), someone who is nothing like him but shares his passion, Kelly ends up putting his battlefield knowledge to work in real life. The script by Erica Beeney was the winner of the second Project Greenlight competition. ~ Perry Seibert, Rovi

Review

Those who watched the second season of Project Greenlight will view this coming-of-age dramedy with an eye for the changes wrought by producers Chris Moore and Jeff Balis, who cut out the more saccharine moments in an attempt to save it. Those who didn't watch will just get an overwhelming sense of something missing from the truncated 79-minute Battle of Shaker Heights, the prize awarded to screenwriter Erica Beeney and directors Efram Potelle and Kyle Rankin in HBO's reality contest. What's onscreen can be funny and charming, due in large part to the talents of Shia LaBeouf, who gives an improvisational spark to Beeney's dialogue. But this can't cover up for the massive failure to complete character arcs or resolve plot threads, circumstances complicated by the directors' famous inability to stick to shooting schedules or grab enough usable footage during the brief periods their actors were available. Still, the film's most schizophrenic element was in the script all along -- LaBeouf's Kelly Ernswiler, a Character with a capital C, who's written as a mélange of quirky (and often contradictory) traits rather than a totally believable person. Although he seems the essence of a liberal free spirit, he reenacts famous military conflicts, fetishizes weapons, and drives an army jeep. He also spends too much time lamenting his participation in a harmless revenge plot against a bully who never showed him the same consideration. Without LaBeouf making him so likeable, Kelly's character deficiencies might have been even more apparent. Ultimately, The Battle of Shaker Heights shows more promise than the first Greenlight effort, Pete Jones's Stolen Summer, but also a greater sense of how amateurs can waste their opportunity. ~ Derek Armstrong, Rovi

Cast

Shiri Appleby - Sarah; William Sadler - Abe Ernswiler; Ray Wise - Harrison Bowland; Philipp Karner - German Soldier; Anson Mount - Miner Weber

Credit

Alex Keledjian - Associate Producer, Larry Tanz - Associate Producer, Marc Joubert - Associate Producer, Joseph Middleton - Casting, Stacie Goodman - Casting, Bega Metzner - Costume Designer, Dennis Benatar - First Assistant Director, Efram Potelle - Director, Kyle Rankin - Director, Richard Nord - Editor, Ben Affleck - Executive Producer, Matt Damon - Executive Producer, Joel Hatch - Executive Producer, Rick Schwartz - Executive Producer, Richard Marvin - Composer (Music Score), Peter Soldinger - Musical Direction/Supervision, Lisa K. Sessions - Production Designer, Thomas E. Ackerman - Cinematographer, Chris Moore - Producer, Jeff Balis - Producer, Lisa Penaranda - Set Designer, Mike Florimbi - Sound/Sound Designer, Erica Beeney - Screenwriter, John Ziegler - Special Effects Coordinator, Stephen Barden - Supervising Sound Editor

Previous:The Battle of San Pietro (1944 Film), The Battle of Russia (1943 Film)
Next:The Battle of Shiloh (1914 Film), The Battle of Toreon (1914 Film)

The Battle of Shaker Heights

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Email
TV listings:

The Battle of Shaker Heights

Top
Wikipedia on Answers.com:

The Battle of Shaker Heights

Top
The Battle of Shaker Heights

Theatrical release poster
Directed by Efram Potelle
Kyle Rankin
Produced by Ben Affleck
Matt Damon
Written by Erica Beeney
Starring Shia La Beouf
Elden Henson
Amy Smart
Shiri Appleby
Kathleen Quinlan
William Sadler
Music by Richard Marvin
Cinematography Thomas E. Ackerman
Editing by Richard Nord
Distributed by Miramax Films
Release date(s) August 22, 2003
Running time 79 minutes
Country United States
Language English
German
Budget $1 million
Box office $280,351[1]

The Battle of Shaker Heights is a 2003 comedy-drama film co-directed by Efram Potelle and Kyle Rankin. It starred Shia La Beouf, Elden Henson, Kathleen Quinlan, Amy Smart, and Shiri Appleby. The film was the winning script for the second season of Project Greenlight.

Contents

Plot

The plot revolves around Kelly Ernswiler (Shia La Beouf), a young war reenactment enthusiast, who works at his local store with love interest Sarah (Shiri Appleby) and his friend, Bart Bowland (Elden Henson) as they use military strategy against high school bully Lance (Billy Kay). Kelly's father, Abe (William Sadler), works with drug addicts, being clean himself for over 5 years, which is scorned by an angry Kelly, who, when told this, replies, "So what? I've been clean the whole time." His mother, Eve (Kathleen Quinlan), is a commercial artist who works out of their garage and is desperate for Kelly to forgive his father. When confronted as to when he is going to forgive him, Kelly replies, "I'll forgive him when I can go to college. But I can't, can I, because he used all my college fund to buy Mexican Black Tar." Kelly is furious at his father for the torture he put him through.

At the same time, Kelly attempts to woo Bart's older sister, Tabby (Amy Smart), even though she's set to get married to Miner Weber (Anson Mount), a handsome businessman. Kelly becomes a regular at Bart's house, being over for dinner often, and he impresses Bart's father, Harrison (Ray Wise), with their common fondness for war memorabilia, and Bart's mother by complimenting her on her flowers, and he often talks to Tabby in her workshop, pretending to know about painting in order to impress her after bluffing his way through conversation they had in an art store where he was collecting supplies for his mother. During this time, Sarah asks him to go to an Aerosmith concert, which she has a spare ticket for, telling him it would be good for him to get out more. When he bluntly makes it clear that he knows it would be a date, he tells her he is seeing someone else, obviously meaning Tabby. Before Kelly and Bart perform their plan for Lance's humiliation, Bart makes it clear to Kelly that he knows he has "his own agenda", at which Kelly is insulted and angry, and Bart displaces it as "pre-mission nervous energy". They recreate an invasion on the street where Lance lives and drag him out of the house pointing guns at him and shouting at him with German accents. They videotape the whole thing and he urinates out of fear.

Afterwards the boys are drinking whiskey at Bart's house and Bart passes out in a chair by the fire. Kelly makes to go home and goes to the workshop to say goodbye to Tabby. He walks in on her crying, as she now thinks the marriage will be off and goes to comfort her, and they kiss. As Kelly is leaving, Bart sees him and is furious as he knew he was in the workshop. The next day, as Kelly is on a set for a war programme that Bart got them in, Bart hasn't turned up. Kelly is cast in a role to be a jeep driver and when his cue is called, Bart turns up out of the bushes and confronts him about Tabby. Kelly denies it at first and then becomes speechless. As he is about to drive for his cue, Bart attacks him in the jeep and they make a mess of the set.

The next day, Abe is taken into care again for relapsing and Kelly is emotionless. He goes to the wedding the same day, only to have an annoyed Bart tell him that he can't let him in. He sneaks into Tabby's limo before it pulls in and he talks to her, and it is a moment in which he finally realizes he must grow up. He gets out of the car and everyone at the wedding sees him and are all confused. He goes round the back of the church to get his bike and leave and meets Minor again, who has no idea of what happened with Kelly and Tabby, and is civil towards him. Kelly cycles to the clinic where his father is staying and is surprised. They begin to watch television and his mother walks in and is surprised and happy to see Kelly.

In the end, it shows the voicemail message where Kelly apologizes to the Bowlands for his behaviour and asks Bart if he will meet him where he will be selling all his old memorabilia, and gives a hat Bart acquired for him back. He is shown walking down the street with Sarah and they hold hands. Kelly sees Lance again on his lawn where they faked the invasion, and goes over to him and confesses, only to be punched in the jaw. The film ends with Kelly lying on the lawn, holding his bruised jaw saying, "I deserved it".

Cast

References

Sources
  • "Shaker lends only its name; weather gets blame", The Plain Dealer, August 24, 2003.

External links


Post a question - any question - to the WikiAnswers community:

Copyrights:

Mentioned in

Episode 014: Project Greenlight (TV Episode) (2003 Reality Show TV Episode)
Philipp Karner (Actor, Comedy Drama/Comedy)
Episode 024: Project Greenlight (TV Episode) (2003 Reality Show TV Episode)
Amy Smart (Actor, Comedy/Drama)
Episode 013: Project Greenlight (TV Episode) (2003 Reality Show TV Episode)