Although Things You Can Tell Just by Looking at Her does bear some similarities to Short Cuts and Magnolia in its setting (Southern California) and mood (modern malaise), and its multiple story format, its focus is exclusively on female characters, and it's possible to view each story on its own. The film begins with a prologue: Police detectives are investigating the apparent suicide of a Hispanic woman (Elpidia Carillo). "This Is Dr. Keener" deals with Dr. Elaine Keener (Glenn Close), a single professional woman attempting to care for her aging and infirm mother and deal with her own loneliness. She invites Christine (Calista Flockhart), a tarot card reader, into her home to make some sense of her life. "Fantasies About Rebecca" profiles a successful bank manager (Holly Hunter) involved with a married man (Gregory Hines). When she learns that she is pregnant, he coldly advises her to take care of the "problem." Before she visits Dr. Keener to have an abortion, she impulsively has a fling with a colleague (Matt Craven). She is also confronted by a female street person in the bank's parking lot. "Someone for Rose" is about a single mother (Kathy Baker), a writer of children's books. She is attracted to a new neighbor, a dwarf (Danny Woodburn), and he catches her spying on him in his house. She's also amazed to find that her son is more sexually active than she knew -- and more than she is herself. "Good Night Lilly, Good Night Christine" details the relationship between the tarot card reader Christine and her lover, Lilly (Valeria Golino), who is critically ill with an unnamed disease. The final story, "Love Waits for Kathy," concerns two sisters, Carol (Cameron Diaz), a lovely blind woman with an active social life, and her police detective sibling, Kathy (Amy Brenneman), one of the detectives who appeared in the prologue. Kathy is attracted to the medical examiner in the suicide case, and her story ends with him taking her out on a date. In an epilogue, Dr. Keener drops in to a bar, where she meets a male character from one of the earlier stories. Debuting director Rodrigo Garcia, a noted cinematographer, is the son of writer Gabriel Garcia Marquez. Things You Can Tell made its debut on cable television, although it was originally intended to be a theatrical release. ~ Tom Wiener, All Movie Guide
Review
Hollywood's lack of confidence in woman-centered films -- even one with such recognizable names and faces as Holly Hunter, Cameron Diaz, Glenn Close, and Calista Flockhart -- to draw ticket buyers to theaters has never been more obvious than in MGM's handling of this charming and provocative set of slightly overlapping stories. Developed at the Sundance Institute and shown to acclaim at its 2000 festival, Things You Can Tell was picked up for theatrical distribution by MGM, who then backed out of backing the film and shipped it off to a cable channel for its debut. Garcia's script cleverly positions each leading female character with someone who depends on them and a yearning quality to their lives. Dr. Keener (with an invalid mother), a woman of science, resorts to a fortune teller in search of romantic happiness; Rebecca (with a married lover), a competent professional, wonders if the men she works with find her attractive; Rose (with a teenaged son) is strangely attracted to a neighbor; Christine (with an ill lesbian lover) dreams of a time when her lover was healthy and they were happier; Kathy (with a blind sister) is disturbed by parallels between her own loneliness and that of a suicide she is investigating. Things You Can Tell is much less dreary than that sounds; the film has moments of humor (especially in the story involving the single mom and the dwarf), and a light touch. The brevity of each story discourages any wallowing in the trenches of pity. ~ Tom Wiener, All Movie Guide
Marnie Waxman - Casting, George Little - Costume Designer, Van A. Hayden - First Assistant Director, Rodrigo García - Director, Amy E. Duddleston - Editor, Andrew Stevens - Executive Producer, Elie Samaha - Executive Producer, Effie Brown - Line Producer, Ed Shearmur - Composer (Music Score), Jaren Millard - Makeup, Jerry Fleming - Production Designer, Emmanuel Lubezki - Cinematographer, Jon Avnet - Producer, Lisa Lindstrom - Producer, Marsha Oglesby - Producer, Betty Berberian - Set Designer, Jose Antonio Garcia - Sound/Sound Designer, Cormac Funge - Sound Editor, Rodrigo García - Screenwriter
“Things You Can Tell Just by Looking at Her” is a film about five stories or vignettes that are in some way or another loosely tied together. Five women are presented in their own lives each facing problems such as loneliness, dissatisfaction, longing, and or desire. The first time director, Rodrigo Garcia assembled this film with a loaded cast of actresses who can tell you everything you need to know just by their body language and facial expressions. Their individual stories show us what “things you can tell just by looking at her.”
The film begins with a prologue. Police detectives are investigating the apparent suicide of an unknown woman. The movie continues on with Dr. Keener (Glenn Close), who is a middle-aged doctor who is attempting to care for her aging mother and deal with her own loneliness. She avoids intimacy but also longs for it at the same time as she sits around and waits by the phone for a male colleague to call. Dr. Keener decides to invite Christine (Calista Flockhart) who reads tarot cards, to her home to help her deal with her loneliness and better understand her life. Christine’s lesbian lover (Valeria Golino) is critically ill with an unnamed disease.
Rebecca (Holly Hunter) is a successful bank manager whose motto is “I’m not big on regrets.” She has been involved with a married man (Gregory Hines) for the past three years and once she finds out she is pregnant with his baby, he coldly advises her to take care of the “problem.” Before Rebecca visits Dr. Keener to get an abortion, she has a fling with one of her colleagues (Matt Craven). She is also confronted by a female street person in the bank’s parking lot.
Rosie (Kathy Baker) is a single mother who is writing children’s books. She is an endearing woman who develops a sweet crush on a new dwarf neighbor (Danny Woodburn). The neighbor catches Rosie spying on him in his house. Rosie amazed to find out that her son is more sexually active then she knew of, and also more sexually active than herself.
Carol Faber (Cameron Diaz) is a lovely blind woman who has an active social life and her sister Kathy (Amy Brenneman) is one of the detectives who appeared in the prologue. Kathy is attracted to the medical examiner in the suicide case, and her story ends with him taking her out on a date. In an epilogue, Dr. Keener drops in to a bar, where she meets with a male character from one of the earlier stories.
