answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

This is highly unlikely. The Divisions between Sunnis and Shiites have persisted for centuries. Once a religious sectarian division comes into existence it is impossible to theologically heal it unless at least one side concedes that its position on the theological issues that the two sects disagree on is wrong. However, a theological union is not necessary for a political or social union, so it is worth asking why the two groups remain politically and socially acrimonious. (Note that the majority of Sunnis and Shiites do not feel this way, but a large vocal minority in each camp still do.) There are several reasons for this animosity.

1) Historical Grievances: The primary reason this division persists is that there has never been an atonement by either side for the pain and persecution that it has suffered when the other was in power over a given territory. Although, Shiites endured more persecution at the hands of Sunnis than the reverse, this is not to say that Sunnis have not endured persecution at Shiite hands. Both groups remain defiant that since they have the moral high-ground as granted from their faith, their actions in repressing the other sect, torturing its adherents, and murdering its leaders was progress towards removing the heresy. Compare this to the Catholics, who have apologized for the Rape of Byzantium, which was huge historical grievance between them and the Orthodox.

2) Ethnic Identities: In many countries, especially Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon, people identify "ethnically" by their sect of religion. Therefore saying somebody is Shiite in Iraq is similar to how people view being Irish-American or Japanese-American in the United States. It marks you socially and it determines who your friends are, who you marry, what jobs you take, who you love, who you despise, etc. As a result, whenever conflict has broken out, each religious group comes together to defend its people's interests. This results in political and social hatred of the other religion in addition to any theological issues.

3) Rumors of the Other's Theology:
Some Sunnis think that Shiites are deluded into believing that 'Ali was a second prophet, which would violate Mohammed being the final capstone of the Prophets, a huge theological issue. Some Shiites believe that Sunnis were paid off to accept the three Rightly-Guided Caliphs before 'Ali and that Sunni Islam was therefore corrupt and ineligible to continue the Islamic tradition. Both have alleged the other was deceived by Jews, which says more about how Muslims view Jews than each other. Of course, both of these are mis-characterizations of the actual theologies of these two sects, but the point remains that as long as these problematic rumors exist, the two sides cannot reconcile.

4) Approaches to Government: Ever since the abolition of the Caliphate in 1936, Sunni Islam has been leaderless and there has come to be an understanding that religion does not participate in actual governance. (This is not a separation of church and state since the two can cooperate closely, but this prevents direct theocracy.) Shiites, on the other hand, have religious leaders called Ayatollahs who do attempt to have terrestrial authority and in Iran have actually achieved it.

User Avatar

Wiki User

9y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

10y ago

According to Shia Islam yes.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Can sunnis and shias pray together?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

How do you pray if you are Shiite?

You pray the same way. The only difference is Sunnis have to pray 5 times but Shias can pray 3 times But the shia adhan adds Ali's name [Please see the Discussion Section.]


How many mins do you cut fast before magrib prayer?

well for shias you open your fast at maghrib time which is after the sun has totally set but for sunnis i dont. but for shias it is reccomended to pray maghrib first then open fast.


How are sunni and shia diffrent?

They are different in their rituals and practices and in their understanding of who was the successor of Muhammad; Shias say Ali and Sunnis say it was Abu Bakr. They differ in how they pray, with Shias praying with their hands by their side and prostrating on a piece of clay, and they believe in twelve imams, the final one of which who is hiding.


Can you find a online video of a Muslim praying?

Actually the way that Shias pray is different from how Sunnis pray so if you want to watch a video on how a Muslim prays, when you search up the video, you have to put what kind of Muslim do you want to see praying. And yes you can find a video of a Muslim praying.


What do you call people from Iraq?

An Iraqi. Iraq is home to many cultures and religions, including ethnic Kurds, Shias, Sunnis, and Muslims.


If shi'a is wrong so why they people proud to be shi'a and why they don't realize that they are wrong?

shias are not wrong who are you to judge other people religion. in what ways are you trying to say they are wrong just because they are more sunnis then shias doesn't mean they are wrong


What are the sunny and the shia?

The sunni and the shia are two different branches of Islam. They had the same belief at one point, but then the beliefs changed. Some differencess are, sunnis believe everything in the ocean is halal (halal means clean for Muslims to eat) while shias eat no shelled fish (except for shrimp) or fish without scales. Sunnis cross their arms while praying, shias keep their arms at their sides. Sunnis believe abu bakar was the first caliph after prophet muhammud, shias believe imam ali ( they believe he's prophet muhammud's successor) was the first caliph.


Why do shia pray on the turba?

Not all Shias do that. But some of us pray on it because we believe that putting our forehead on a material, which is not made directly by Allah, is a bad thing. So instead of praying directly onto the mat, we use a turba, or if there is no truba we can use paper, tissue or a leaf But Zaydi Shias dont do that. Many twelver Shias dont do that either.


Who does Shia support?

The split between the Shias and the Sunnis is based on one thing: who they believe should be the next caliph. Other than that, they are pretty much the same. Remember that this split occured years ago. The Shias believed that the next caliph should be a blood relative of Prophet Muhammad(sw). The Sunnis believed that the next caliph should be selected my leaders of the Muslim community.


Why all practice of sunnis are anti Quran and shias are per Quran as Sunnis are washing their foot in wuzu while shias doing masah as in quran?

No Muslim, who ever, can claim that Sunnis are anti Quraan and Shias are followers of Quraan or vice versa. Both Sunnis and Shias are Muslims and brothers in Islam. Both worship God the only one God. Both are followers of prophet Mohamed the Messenger of God. Both observing the five Islam Pillars. Both have the same basic Islam beliefs. It is very sinful for any Muslim to accuse another Muslim of being anti Quran. The only differences between Sunnis and and Shias are in the details of some practices and never having differences in the basic pillars of Islam. Now we come to the issue of washing feet for Wuzu (or Wudu). In Quran, said that: "O ye who believe! when ye prepare for prayer, wash your faces and arms to the elbows; wipe partly your heads and (wash) your feet to the ankles" verse 6- chapter 6. In Arabic , grammatically washing is not only for faces and arms but also for feet while wiping is only for heads and partly (not necessarily full head). However, if anyone- whether Sunnis or Shias - has another different view or explanation of the verse (or other prophet saying) than the above, then no other Muslim has the right to accuse him that he is against Quran or that he nonbeliever.


What religious sect in Iraq is causing the US the most trouble is it the Shi'ites Sunni or the Kurds?

That's not really a valid question since Shia and Sunni are beliefes and Kurd is a race of people, but anyway the Kurds are not causing any trouble at all - so that leaves Shias and Sunnis. Between them the sunnis are causing ALL the problem against the US. Take Al-Qaida (sunnis) for instance they hate usa and the shias equally. In fact they have a saying - "kill 10 shias and you will be given a pass to heaven". Doesnt make any sense since the Koran (islams holy book) says killing is prohibited unless it's done in self defense.


How did Muhammad's followers respond to his death?

They split into the Shia and the Sunnis because they didn't know who the leader should be. The Shias believed it should be blood relation, while the Sunnis believed the leader should be chosen.