How can US Supreme Court decisions be overturned?

already exists.

Would you like to merge this question into it?

already exists as an alternate of this question.

Would you like to make it the primary and merge this question into it?

exists and is an alternate of .

No single entity - not the President, Senate, House of Representatives, state Governors, nor anyone else - has the power to overturn a US Supreme Court ruling. Supreme Court decisions cannot be nullified by other parts of government. However, if the Supreme Court strikes down a federal law, Congress can always modify the law until it is such that the Supreme Court does not consider it to violate the Constitution, then pass it again.

Supreme Court decisions can only be overturned in two ways:

Legitimate Methods
  1. The US Supreme Court reverses a decision on an earlier case by making a contradictory decision on a current case.
  2. Congress and the States can overturn a decision by amending the Constitution.

Illegitimate Methods (Passive Resistance)
  1. Sometimes the Executive Branch obstructs or fails to enforce a decision.
  2. Sometimes Congress rewrites legislation to bring it into compliance with constitutional guidelines.
  3. Sometimes Congress strips the Supreme Court of its appellate jurisdiction over certain types of cases to deprive them of the ability to overturn a law or policy.
  4. Sometimes states pass laws that clearly violate Supreme Court decisions, forcing someone with standing to challenge the new law's constitutionality. Meanwhile, the law can be enforced even if violates established civil rights. State legislatures do this with the hope of overturning, or slipping around, precedents set by earlier Courts.

Contributor's Example
Don burns the US Flag on the steps of a state capitol. The state arrests him because the state amended its own constitution to make this illegal. However, the US Supreme Court ruled that flag burning is protected speech, thereby making flag burning lawful under US law.

If the case is appealed to the US Supreme Court, it would rule that the state constitutional amendment violates the US Constitution (which is superior) and strike down the state amendment.

The state then writes a law that Don has to buy a permit to burn the flag in any form of protest. The US Supreme Court might uphold that law (if challenged) as long as it fulfills a legitimate government purpose, but does not: 1) discriminate in who the permits are issued to, or 2) make the cost or time involved in issuance of the permit unbearable. Sometimes such laws are deemed unconstitutional, and sometimes not.
60 people found this useful

How often has the US Supreme Court overturned legislation?

There is no specific frequency pattern to indicate how often the US Supreme Court overturns legislation. Some Courts, such as the one seated during President Franklin Roosevelt's first two terms of office, overturned quite a bit of legislation; other Courts have been more restrained. According to ( Full Answer )

How can supreme court decisions be overturned?

By making a rule or letter to the president saying i want some power because the president doesn't really do anything they just states the laws i am a person from the supreme court and how the president treats us

When does the US Supreme Court announce decisions?

The US Supreme Court releases opinions on Tuesday and Wednesday mornings, and on the third Monday of each sitting. The public is usually alerted a few days prior to an opinion being released, but the specific case name and docket number are kept secret until the formal announcement. This practice ma ( Full Answer )

How does the US Supreme Court make decisions?

The Supreme Court justices vote to determine the outcome of a case. The decision is made when a simple majority (for example, five of the nine justices) agree on a judgment. Explanation Most US Supreme Court cases are heard under the Court's appellate jurisdiction, whereby the issue was in ( Full Answer )

What US Supreme Court decision overturned minimum wage laws and employment protection for women?

Adkins v. Children's Hospital, 261 US 525 (1923) The Supreme Court held that minimum wage laws artificially restricted the bargaining rights of the corporation, and raised the possibility that Congress could pair minimum wage laws with maximum wage laws, thereby removing the right of employees ( Full Answer )

Decisions of the supreme court can only be overturned by the court or by?

The Supreme Court cannot directly enforce its rulings; instead, it relies on respect for the Constitution and for the law for adherence to its judgments. Because the Supreme Court simply bases its decisions on the Constitution, the decisions are not overturned. The decisions simply uphold the Consti ( Full Answer )

A decision of the us supreme court can be overturned by?

A later decision, or refinement ruling of the same court; or a ruling of that same court based upon a new or amended law to comply with that ruling. For example: John burns the US Flag on the steps of the State Capital. The State arrests him because the state amended its constitution based on a ( Full Answer )

Can you appeal a decision by the US Supreme Court?

The Supreme Court rules allow 25 days after the opinion is releasedduring which either party may request a rehearing (from the SupremeCourt) on the decision. Rehearings are seldom granted without acompelling reason.

What US Supreme Court decision overturned the separate but equal doctrine in 1954?

The landmark case that desegregated schools was Brown v. Boardof Education of Topeka, 347 U.S. 483, a 1954 case in which theSupreme Court Justices unanimously ruled segregation in the publicschools was unconstitutional. Chief Justice Earl Warren, in writingthe Court opinion, declared "separate ed ( Full Answer )

Who can overturn US Supreme Court decisions?

Decisions of the Supreme Court can only be overturned by constitutional amendment, or by subsequent decisions of the Supreme Court, which is capable of reversing itself.

What are US Supreme Court decisions made by?

US Supreme Court decisions are made by a simple majority vote of the justices hearing the case. If all nine justices review a case, the vote must be at least 5-4.

Can a constitutional amendment overturn a supreme court decision?

A decision of the Supreme Court is an interpretation of the law as it is now.. If the law changes, through a constitutional amendment, for example, a subsequent Supreme Court case dealing with the same issue as before, but based on the amended law, could very well be decided differently.

Are US Supreme Court decisions final?

The Supreme Court's decisions are always final unless they agree to rehear a case, which rarely happens. The Supreme Court is the final authority on federal and constitutional law in the United States; there is no further avenue of appeal. There are only two ways in which a Supreme Court decision ( Full Answer )

What branch of government can propose amendments to the US Constitution that will overturn decisions made by the Supreme Court?

Legislative (the House of Representatives and Senate) can propose Amendments to the Constitution. The Judicial branch's power is to declare laws unconstintutional, so if an amendment is made to the Constitution, then the law is no longer unconstitutional, thus, in a sense, overturning a decision of ( Full Answer )

Can the US Supreme Court overturn a Presidential veto?

No. Creating and vetoing laws is part of the legislative process, which is the responsibility of Congress and the President, respectively. The Constitution does not grant the Supreme Court any power to make law or to override a veto. If a law is successfully passed, then challenged in court, the ( Full Answer )

Which Amendment first overturned a US Supreme Court decision?

The Eleventh Amendment revoked the Supreme Court's original jurisdiction over conflicts between a state and citizens of another state. This change was made in response to the decision in Chisholm v. Georgia, 2 U.S. 419 (1793), in which the Court declared the states lacked sovereign immunity agains ( Full Answer )

Who delivered the US Supreme Court's opinion overturning the Miranda v. Arizona Ninth Circuit court decision?

Miranda v. Arizona, 384 US 436 (1966) Miranda v. Arizona was appealed to the US Supreme Court from the Supreme Court of Arizona, having been heard exclusively in the Arizona court system. Only one of the three cases consolidated with Miranda , Westover v. United States, was heard in federa ( Full Answer )

What earlier decision did the US Supreme Court case Brown v. Board of Education overturn?

Brown v. Board of Education, 347 US 483 (1954) The Supreme Court of the United States of America in Brown v. Board of Education , 347 U.S. 483, 495, 74 S.Ct. 686, 692, 98 L.Ed. 873, (U.S. 1954) ( Brown I) , held that segregation of children in public schools solely on the basis of race, even ( Full Answer )

Is there a case cite where a pro se litigant filed for a Writ of Certiorari to the US Supreme Court to overturn an Oregon court decision on judicial disqualification?

An extensive database search of petitions and cases reviewed by the SCOTUS revealed no documents that met all of the following criteria: . Petition to US Supreme Court for Writ of Certiorari . Supreme Court of Oregon or Oregon Supreme Court or US Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit . Appell ( Full Answer )

When may the US Supreme Court overturn a precedent?

The US Supreme Court has the authority to overturn a precedent in any case under their review, if they feel the precedent no longer applies to current social and legal circumstances. They can also ignore precedents if they feel a case creates an exception to the rule, for whatever reason.

What happens to a law the US Supreme Court overturns?

It is nullified and can no longer be applied. Congress sometimes rewrites laws the Court has declared unconstitutional and passes them in a form more acceptable to the Supreme Court.

Does the decision of the US Supreme Court have to be unanimous?

No. Sometimes verdicts are unanimous, but more often they are splitdown political and ideological lines. The Supreme Court has becomeincreasingly polarized in the 20th and 21st Centuries, makingunanimous decisions the exception, rather than the rule. On theRoberts' Court, many decisions are made by ( Full Answer )

Why would the US Supreme Court overturn a state law?

The US Supreme Court only reviews state laws that are appealed through the court system on the grounds that they conflict with federal law or infringe rights protected by the Constitution. The primary considerations for using judicial nullification to overturn state laws would be: . if they infr ( Full Answer )

Who would benefit if Congress could overturn US Supreme Court decisions?

The Legislative (Congress) and possibly Executive branches would benefit if Congress had the power to nullify US Supreme Court decisions, because their power would then be unchecked by the Judicial branch. Such authority would violate separate powers established by the Constitution to ensure no s ( Full Answer )

Can the US President overturn Supreme Court decisions?

No. US Supreme Court decisions are final unless Congress and the States ratify an amendment that effectively changes the Court's ability to rule on certain issues; or the Court agrees to a rehearing based on new information; or (more common), a later Supreme Court may have a different constituti ( Full Answer )

Can the US Supreme Court overturn laws passed by Congress?

Yes , under certain circumstances. The Supreme Court uses judicial review to overturn laws if they are contrary to the Constitution, but only if the law is part of a case or controversy under review by the Court.

Can a US Supreme Court decision be overturned?

Supreme Court decisions can only be overridden in two ways: . The US Supreme Court reverses a decision on an earlier case by making a contradictory decision on a current case. . Congress and the States override a decision by amending the Constitution. There are several legitimate and illeg ( Full Answer )

How can court decisions be overturned?

Court decisions can be overturned by higher courts, with the highest being the Supreme Court. Once the Supreme Court has issued a ruling, it can only be overturned by another Supreme Court ruling if the court agrees to hear that case or a similar case again. It is also possible for Congress to pa ( Full Answer )

Can the Military Court of Appeals overturn the decision of the US Supreme Court?

No. The Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces (Military Court of Appeals) and the US Supreme Court are in separate chains of authority. The former is a military court (an Article I tribunal), while the latter is a civilian court (and an Article III tribunal). Cases may be appealed from the Court ( Full Answer )

Can the Senate overturn a US Supreme Court decision?

No. The Senate does not have the authority to overturn a Supreme Court decision because of constitutional separation of powers. No single entity - not the President, Senate, House of Representatives, state Governors, nor anyone else - has the power to overturn a US Supreme Court ruling. Suprem ( Full Answer )

What are the latest US Supreme Court decisions?

Any answer to this question would quickly become obsolete. You can review recent Supreme Court decisions on their website, accessible via Related Links, below.

Can US Supreme Court decisions be overturned by the Judicial Activism?

Yes , but only the US Supreme Court can overturn its own earlier court decisions. Judicial activism is a label subjectively applied to legal decisions believed to go beyond the intent of the Constitution or Congressional lawmakers, or to overturn established legal precedent. The term has negative ( Full Answer )

Who confirms US Supreme Court decisions?

The Court itself. The US Supreme Court is head of the Judicial Branch and its decisions are made independently of the other two branches of government.

Where are US Supreme Court decisions published?

Print The official, government bound editions of the US Supreme Court's opinions is United States Reports . West Publishing produces annotated editions that include opinions, commentary and precedents published as The Supreme Court Reporter and The Federal Practice Digest . The diges ( Full Answer )

Can a US Supreme Court decision be overturned by Congress?

No. Congress does not have the authority to overturn a Supreme Court decision because of constitutional separation of powers. No single entity - not the President, Senate, House of Representatives, state Governors, nor anyone else - has the power to overturn a US Supreme Court ruling. Suprem ( Full Answer )

Has a US Supreme Court decision ever been overturned?

The US Supreme Court has overturned many of its own past decisions (the list would be too long for this format); however, there were a few instances when a decision was nullified by constitutional amendment. These are the only two ways a Supreme Court decision may be overturned. Only one constitu ( Full Answer )

When has a state Supreme Court overturned the US Supreme Court?

State supreme courts cannot lawfully overturn US Supreme Court decisions, per the Supremacy Clause of Article VI of the Constitution. The only ways a decision may be overturned is by the Supreme Court itself or by constitutional amendment.

Can the Supreme Court overturn a bill?

The Supreme Court can rule that a law is unconstitutional, and since the constitution takes precedence over other laws, that effectively overturns it.

This U.S supreme court decision overturned Plessy v. Ferguson?

Brown v. Board of Education- Linda Brown had to walk 21 blocks to the nearest black school because her neighborhood school was only for white students. Her parents sued and the Supreme Court ruled that segregation in schools violated the equal protection clause.

Can the constitutional amendments overturn a supreme court decision?

The Supreme Courts job is to interpret and uphold the laws of today based on their knowledge of the constitution. They would not be able to decide anything directly violating the constitution, but they do have their own interpretation of what it says. Knowing this, it is possibly that the amendm ( Full Answer )

How can supreme court decisions later be used?

As 'jurisprudence'. Which means that other courts throughout thenation will take them as a lead for their own future decisions.This is not only standard procedure, but also because these courtsknow that if they go against an earlier Supreme Court decision,they will in the end be overturned if the pa ( Full Answer )