Little Miss Muffet decided to make something with her curds and whey what would she be most likely to whip up?

She would most likely make cottage cheese. Curds and whey are the primary ingredients of cottage cheese. If you leave milk to go off and separate, the chunky bit at the bottom is the curds and the watery liquid at the top is the whey. If you strain out most of the whey, leaving the curds moist and add salt and pepper, you would have cottage cheese.