0
What is the difference between categorical imperative and hypothetical imperative?
Wiki User
∙ 14y agoWant this question answered?
Be notified when an answer is posted
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
What is the difference between a hypothetical and a categorical syllogism?
Hypothetical is something that is not known yet and is just an educated guess. The categorical syllogism is one that has been found by formal reasoning.
What is the difference between a hypothetical imperative and a categorical imperative?
The hypothetical imperative is a test used to determine whether or not you will do an action. You must imagine a world in which everyone does the proposed action. If it is not possible the action should not be performed. For example, if everyone didn't speak until they were spoken to, no one would ever speak, so this idea would not get thorugh the first test. However, if you can imagine a world in which everyone did certain action then this action must go though a second test. This is the categorical imperative. If everyone did the propoesed action would you like that? For example. If you can imagine a world in which everyone spat out their gum on the sidewalk this would go through the hypothetical imperative but you wouldn't want to live in this world so it wouldn't go through the categorical imperative. Hope i helped :)
How do you Contrast the considerations that Mill and Kant would advance with respect to what is morally wrong with making a promise that one has no intention of keeping?
What you have here basically is the rather simplistic, but effective, distinction between teleological (Mill) and Deontological ethics. If we quickly sketch out their respective view points, the contrast will become clear.Mill was the first proponent of Rule Utilitarianism. That is, Ethics was based of a set of rules that were adjudged to promote greatest happiness most of the time. Keeping your promises would be one such rule. Note how Mill's basis for ethics is merely the result - if my some fluke robbery promoted greatest happiness most of the time, robbery would be the correct thing to do. This is what is meant by teleological - ethics is a tool towards an end. So for Mill making a promise with no intention of keeping it is not inherently wrong. If you make a promise to serial killer that you'll hide them, with no intention of keeping it, you're clearly promoting the greater good. This admittedly is a simplistic account of Mill's utilitarianism, ignoring slightly it's rule base, but still holds good.Kant is different however. For Kant ethical doctrines are logical results derived from reason - this is his notion of the categorical imperative. By the very nature of being Man, we can derive moral propositions from our Reason, which are therefore universal and unchanging, compelling man toward the moral action. The Categorical Imperative (CI) is made more clear through it's comparison to the Hypothetical Imperative (HI). The HI compels action in given circumstances - e.g If you are tired, you should go to bed. The Hypothetical is given in the word 'If'. But the CI results in propositions such as Do Not Kill. There is no circumstantial qualifier here; the proposition is categorical.We can put this along side another of Kant's ideas, the Kingdom of Ends, whereby all men must be treated as Ends in themselves, and not as means to an end. These two doctrines combine to present Kant's Deontological ethic - an ethic where the injunction to act well is logical consistency with the Categorical Imperative. So for Kant, you could never make a promise you didn't intend to keep. In the serial killer scenario listed above, Kant could not lie to the serial killer. He would HAVE to tell the truth, this being the very nature of the categorical imperative.Mill and Kant reach differing conclusions because of the function, and perhaps the ontology, of their ethics. Mill's utilitarianism is very much Human based, and is flexible according to subjective human circumstance. The Kantian approach though is derived from the activity of the transcendent self, and is therefore inflexible whatever the circumstance. The contrast lies mainly in this teleological/deontological distinction.
What is the difference between an abstract and a conclusion?
difference between abstract and conclusion
What is the difference between values and traditions?
what is the difference between the values and tradition
What is the difference between a hypothetical and a categorical syllogism?
Hypothetical is something that is not known yet and is just an educated guess. The categorical syllogism is one that has been found by formal reasoning.
What is the difference between a hypothetical imperative and a categorical imperative?
The hypothetical imperative is a test used to determine whether or not you will do an action. You must imagine a world in which everyone does the proposed action. If it is not possible the action should not be performed. For example, if everyone didn't speak until they were spoken to, no one would ever speak, so this idea would not get thorugh the first test. However, if you can imagine a world in which everyone did certain action then this action must go though a second test. This is the categorical imperative. If everyone did the propoesed action would you like that? For example. If you can imagine a world in which everyone spat out their gum on the sidewalk this would go through the hypothetical imperative but you wouldn't want to live in this world so it wouldn't go through the categorical imperative. Hope i helped :)
WHY MUST THE VOLUME OF A STEREO IN A ROOM WITH WALL TO WALL CARPET BE TURNED HIGHER THAN IN A ROOM WITH A WOODEN FLOOR?
Because of the refractive difference between non-cognitive utilitarian viewpoints (surrounding the categorical imperative).
What is the difference between a declarative and imperative?
The difference between a declarative sentence and an imperative sentence is that a declarative sentence is a statement and an imperative sentence is a command.Here is an example of a declarative sentence:A spider has eight legs.Here is an example of an imperative sentence:Please go get me some water
What is the difference between declarative and imperative programming?
Imperative is how the computer should do something. Declarative is what you would like the computer to do.
What is the difference between interrogative and imperative?
Interrogative is putting a question towards something, but imperative is commanding and a polite request .
Difference between dummy and categorical variable?
A dummy variable assumes a value of either 0 or 1. A categorical variable assumes one of a usually small number of values. For example, a categorical variable might assume the values 'F' or 'M' for female or male.
What is difference between imperative and declarative sentences?
With an imperative sentence, the subject is understood and not necessarily stated. "Close the door." The subject is you and the verb is close.
What is the difference between a declarative statement and an imperative statement?
In a declarative statement, you initialize the object. But in an imperative statement, you use a preexisting statement and use it.
What is the difference between continuous and categorical independent variables?
A categorical variable (also known as a discrete variable) is one whose range is countable; e.g. the variable answ has values [yes, no, not sure]. answ is a categorical variable with range 3.A continuous variable is one which is not categorical; e.g. weight is a continuous variable which can take any value between 0 and 1000 kg (say) for a human being.
What is the difference between exclamatory and imperative sentences?
Imperative sentences are sentences that gives command and requests while exclamatory sentences are those that expresses emotions and ends with an exclamation point.
What is the difference between a pronoun and an imperative?
A pronoun is a word that replaces a more direct noun, such as replacing "Lisa is here" with "She is here". An imperative is a type of word that expresses a command. For example, in the sentence "Come over here", come is an imperative
