answersLogoWhite

0

Science with superstitions

Updated: 8/22/2023
User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

Best Answer

Lots of superstitions are based on observations, which are scientific data. For example:

Pele, the volcano god of Hawaii, was based on the observation that volcanoes could do major damage. So there must be a god there.

The ocean can cause major damage along the coasts. Clearly there is a god involved.

The point is this. While the observations are scientifically valid, the conclusions based on them are not.

User Avatar

Duane Anymouse

Lvl 9
3y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
User Avatar

Duane Anymouse

Lvl 1
2y ago
When the data are correct, but the conclusions are not, that is often caused by a case of faulty logic called "post-hoc fallicy."
User Avatar

Duane Anymouse

Lvl 1
2y ago
BTW...even the so-called scientific method acknowledges and accounts for false validation of the null hypothesis.
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

10y ago

Superstitious belief, by definition, have no scientific basis. Science requires that ideas are tested in a way that is repeatable and falsifiable. Falsifiable means that there must be a way that the test shows that a stated belief is not true, while most superstitions rely on metaphysical entities or powers that are so vague they can not be dis-proven.

Here are some examples of superstitions, and where they may have come from.

  • Breaking a mirror is seen as seven years of bad luck from a historical root.
    • Back in the medieval times mirrors were very expensive. And if you broke one, it was reguarly someone important, such as the lord of the kingdom of the king or a high-ranking nobleman. And if you broke it, it was common that if they were un-forgiving, they would put you in jail, possibly for seven years.
  • Walking under a ladder is seen as bad luck
    • Typically a ladder means someone at the top of the ladder and that person can easily drop things - onto your head. So it really is a bad idea to walk under one.
  • Never sweep the floor at night or you'll sweep sorrow into your life.
    • You may not be able to see where you're sweeping and fall and get injured.
  • Chase away any owls outside your window; they are a harbinger of death.
    • They may erode your windowsill by pecking on it, and when you lean on it, it may break and you may fall.
  • Never start or buy anything on a Friday.
    • Since Friday is the last business day, you or your order will probably not be active on the weekend.
  • Cut your hair on a full moon and it will grow back faster.
    • Well, if you cut your hair at a barber's shop, and you can see the moon, the barber will probably bee in a hurry to leave and so will give you a shorter haircut.
  • Crickets in your home are good luck (not in my home and definitely not for the nasty crickets!)
    • They tell the temperature.
  • Killing a spider is bad luck.
    • In addition to reducing local disease-carrying insects, Spiders provide humans with other medical benefits. Spider venom is used in neurological research and may prevent permanent brain damage in stroke victims. The silk produced by spiders is used in many optical devices including laboratory instruments.
  • Ivy growing on a house protects the inhabitants from witchcraft and evil.
    • Evil may mistake it for poison ivy and stay away.
  • Friday the 13th is unlucky
    • The Templars were all arrested (and most were tortured and executed) one Friday the 13th!
  • Actors believe that using real money as a prop is bad luck.
    • This is probably rooted in the fact that leaving real money on stage or in your costume means that there is a good chance that the prop will disappear before the next performance.
  • Opening an umbrella in the house is bad luck.
    • Like walking under a ladder, this is just a hazard; you could hit someone or break something.
  • Bad luck comes in threes.
    • This is sometimes expressed in notable deaths occurring in threes. In fact, this is a well-known psychological bias known as "confirmation effect"; when two events occur, people naturally anticipate a third (two things don't form a pattern, but three do). When the expectation is satisfied, it "proves" the adage. Of course, if it is not, then the pattern is not recognized.
This answer is:
User Avatar
User Avatar

Duane Anymouse

Lvl 1
3y ago
You've missed the point. Data can be true but conclusions based on those true data can be invalid. EX: Every time the rooster crows, the Sun comes up. And that's true. So the myth that's based on those data is that the rooster causes the Sun to rise.

User Avatar

Malama Kose

Lvl 5
2y ago

A lot of people always look for lucky stars, lucky planets, lucky numbers – all kinds of stuff. In this process of looking and waiting for things to happen, things they could have easily created for themselves are completely lost. With every aspect of life, it is you who has to make it happen. Your peace and your turmoil is your business. Your joy and misery is your business. The devil and the god within you is your business. When you live by chance, you also live in fear and anxiety. When you live by intent and capability, it does not matter what is happening or not happening – at least you are in control of what is happening to you. It is a more stable life.

This answer is:
User Avatar
User Avatar

Forrest Brakus

Lvl 1
2y ago
How do you know that

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

There are many superstitions that go against science.

The 2 most common examples are:

1)the eclipse

superstition: the devil swallows the sun and vomits it back due to indigestion!

theory: the moon comes in between the sun and the earth and blocks it from sight.

2)lightning

superstition : wrath of the sky god

wrath of

Zeus in Greek mythology

Indra in Hindu mythology

Mut in Egyptian mythology

Curse of spirits in Zulu mythology!

theory: Lightning is a discharge of a large electrostatic charge that builds up on clouds near the surface of the earth during atmospheric disturbances such a thunderstorms

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

The only superstitions about science/scientists come from Christianity:

1) Since man's first sin was eating of the "Tree of Knowledge", anything that comes from Science (or knowledge) must be invented by the Devil.

-This one might be true. Neat.

2) Science is working to establish an atheistic New World Order set on destroying Jesus and raising the Antichrist.

-Science is trying to make a world where people no longer need to starve or suffer. If that's what the Antichrist wants, he may not be so bad after all.

3) Science is a religion

-Science relies on observation and repetitive testing/experimentation to determine "truths". It is not a religion because it does not focus on the idea of a God, and is subject to validation, testing and peer review. In addition, where as religion is unalterable (because God is infallible) no matter what, science changes constantly as new evidence is discovered.

4) Science hates God.

-Science doesn't care.

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago

Washing your hands before eating was a religious belief. Chewing on willow bark eased headaches (aspirin came from that). Apple a day provided necessary vitamins. Eating limes prevented scurvy (vitamin C)

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

YuXi

Lvl 6
2y ago

Lots of superstitions are based on observations, which are scientific data. For example:

Pele, the volcano god of Hawaii, was based on the observation that volcanoes could do major damage. So there must be a god there.

The ocean can cause major damage along the coasts. Clearly there is a god involved.

The point is this. While the observations are scientifically valid, the conclusions based on them are not.

This answer is:
User Avatar

User Avatar

SANTOSH KUMAR

Lvl 3
2y ago

come India you will see many supersticious people

and the rumors also have scientific reason!!

This answer is:
User Avatar
User Avatar

Rafaela Morissette

Lvl 1
2y ago
can you elaborate?
User Avatar

Elvis Franecki

Lvl 1
2y ago
great answer ty!

User Avatar

Johnathan Alexander

Lvl 4
3y ago

Superstitious beliefs that is not a tale or a story with real examples based on scientific evidence.

-John

This answer is:
User Avatar
User Avatar

Duane Anymouse

Lvl 1
2y ago
Huh?

User Avatar

Wiki User

8y ago

If there is a scientific explanation for a phenomenon then it is no longer a superstition.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Science with superstitions
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

Has science banished superstitions?

Definitely not.


What is the view of science on superstitions?

Scientifically, superstitions are considered as a psychological need for supernatural belief


Is there any scientific basis for superstitions?

While there are certainly historical, anthropological and cultural reasons behind most superstitions, they are called superstitions because of the very fact that they have no basis in Science.


Is it OK to believe in superstitions?

There is nothing wrong with it as long it doesn't become the science or replace science.


Are superstitious beliefs Science or not?

No. Superstitions are not scientific in any way whatsoever.


How do science and technology affect superstition?

By definition, a superstition is an unscientific belief. Science and technology are therefore unable to shake many people's superstitions. Lack of understanding of science and technology has led to the development of new superstitions, such as the belief that Mercury retrograde can cause your computer to malfunction.


Superstitions with scientific basis?

Superstitions are not based in science. There might be a logical reason like breaking a mirror is bad luck but does not cause bad luck but this is not scientific.


Cite and enumerate local superstitions belief that is related to science technology?

ewan nakakaadik na to.HAHA XD :P


Examples of science-related beliefs?

When it comes to superstitions, there are none. Science relies on repeatable, redundant results from experiments in order to consider it valid. Superstition relies on a weakness of a believer.


That you should believe in superstitions?

You should not believe in Superstitions. Superstitions is the product of ignorance among people. Many superstitions are not true.


What are the advantages in believing supertitious beliefs?

There are no advantages to superstitions. They are not based on rational facts or science and come to us from a time when there was no science to explain the world. It is fun to do some of them, but other than that they have no value.


What is role of science in superstition?

There is none. Superstition is completely bereft of science. However, a savvy person may use scientific techniques to gain advantage over someone who believes in superstitions.