Hollyleaf killed Ashfur. As you may remember, she was the one out of the three that constantly referred to the warrior code. After she found out that she was the daughter of Leafpool and Crowfeather, she was very frusterated that she was born out of something completely against the warrior code. The code that she had so carefully followed had let her down. So, she killed Ashfur, because Ashfur was going to tell every cat who Hollyleaf and her brother's parents really were.
Do you mean Ashfur? At the end of Long Shadows I thought it was Squirrelflight but in Sunrise it reveals that the killer was Hollyleaf!! It's true!!
After the events of Long Shadows, yes, Ashfur dies, presumably murdered by his former love. he is murdered by hollyleaf
Several cats died in "Long Shadows," including Longtail, Smokefoot, and Firestar's mate Sandstorm.
many people think that Ashfur is in the dark forest because of what occured in Long Shadows, however, in Sign of the Moon, Jayfeather sees him in Starclan. Yellowfang tells Jayfeather that Ashfur's only fault was that he loved to much.
Ashfur-Revenge
Yes there is. Ashfur of ThunderClan. (Murdered by Hollyleaf) = in Long Shadows, but revealed in Sunrise. Ashfur of ShadowClan. (Died of sickness in Rising Storm. Introduced in Into the Wild). NOTE: Ashfur of ShadowClan was not evil or bad. Also he was introduced as an elder.
Hollyleaf
Hollyleaf
Hollyleaf was the cat who killed Ashfur. She did so to protect her siblings and keep their secret from being exposed.
Hollyleaf yep,hollyleaf.many say squirrelflight,but there wrong![i read the books i know the truth]
Yes, he was found dead in the the stream that marked the WindClan-ThrunderClan border with a warrior death bite in his neck. The most popular answer to the question 'who killed Asfur' is that Hollyleaf did, to keep him from telling the Clans a big secret at the gathering. There are three other theories, that don't seem to be at all correct: 1. That Ashfur was killed by WindClan. 2. That he fell and hit his head on a rock in the stream, or it snagged on a stick. 3. That Sol killed him. Read Sunrise and I'm sure you'll figure out why the first answer is the most popular.
Maybe, because they were sharing tongues. But then Ashfur got killed by Hollyleaf and Whitewing had kits with Birchfall.