The "indianapolis" Colts have never been to the Super Bowl. The
Baltimore Colts went twice. ==
Answer Update ==
As of the start of the 2007 season, the Indianapolis Colts have been to one Super Bowl and their quarterback was Peyton Manning. The Baltimore Colts had been to two Super Bowls and their starting quarterbacks were Earl Morrall in SB III and John Unitas in SB V.