Best Answer

Answer The ability to sing in tune is not a thing that can be taught (however can be improved)

but is an entity that is genetic. parts of the brain are specific to "singing" this comes from our ape like ancestry and is a recessive character. hence the minority of people are able to sing in the same way that there are less blonde people, the "brunette" gene is dominant. talking from a first hand perspective (having the ability to sing) i can see that it has been passed down from my mothers side of the family and very little effort if required for me, personally, to sing in tune over a wide vocal range. i am 15 years old so my voice box is not full developed and over time, my vocal range will improve and will mature.


*That is because some people do not sing from their diaphragm so they sing out their nose or throat and it doesn't come out as good.

Everybody can sing, it is only the listener who says that a person cannot sing. A person may be said to be tone deaf, but if one listens carefully to the so called "off" notes one will find that it is indeed singing. Any sequence of notes made by the voice are in themselves music. We are so used to listening to "perfectly pitched notes" that anything different is not pleasing to the ear. Each "off" note is in itself a perfectly pitched note.

Listen to an instrument playing the chromatic scale, some notes you will like while the in between notes may sound unpleasant to you, yet all are perfect.

**this also depends on the depth of your voice for example if you have a deep base voice your not going to be singing an Opera. and if you have a high soprano you wouldn't be singing a sound written for people with a deeper voice. i know this because i teach at a school as an choir teacher.

*The diaphragm provides "support" for your singing, and has to do with breath not the actual pitches produced.

**Note: Those who are bases may sing operas if they wish to. There is no law, as I know it, currently against it. Although...there are some bases who should be outlawed from singing. Namely, those who cannot sing. And although they may technically "sing" as outlined above, that does not mean that they are good at it.

To answer the question:

The ability to sing ON KEY is a talent one is born with. While the mechanics of singing can be taught, the "ear" for it cannot. Like any other talent, some people have it, some people don't.

AnswerUnless you don't have functional vocal cords, you should be able to sing. Singing doesn't necessarily mean it's on key or other folks will think it's pleasant. There are many ways to sing. Answer99.55% of the people on this planet can learn to sing, the hardest thing to develop is resonance and tone. The ear is the easiest thing to develop because all you have to do is practice listening (and try to describe what you heard)! Seriously!

Source: 3 years of college level vocal training.

Additional information:

While genetics do play a HUGE role in a person's 'range' ((the notes they can hit)) even if they can't hit the 'perfect' notes as deemed by society, the strength of one's muscles in the vocals also play an almost equally large role in one's musical range. If it's too weak, and under-excersized, then one simply wont be able to hit higher or lower notes, nor will they be able to project their voice. This is the aspect musical classes focus on, the strengthening of these vocal muscles. It is also why people who start singing early will be better singers, where-as people who started singing at a high-school choir will not be as good for a long while. The person's genetic make-up will restrict just how much your muscles can be stretched, but practice can enhance it a bit.

User Avatar

Wiki User

โˆ™ 2016-04-10 02:13:26
This answer is:
User Avatar
Study guides


20 cards

Who was the founder of Motown

Which artist was known as the Father of the Blues

The black soul anthem Say It Loud you are Black and you are Proud was written by which of the following artists

Berry Gordy Jr had a unique approach to artist promotion Which of the following statements best describes his method

See all cards
6 Reviews

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: Why can some people sing and some cannot?
Write your answer...
Still have questions?
magnify glass
Related questions

Do people sing good?

Some people sing very well, a few sing superbly, and some do not.

Why can some people sing good and others sing awful?

because some people are tone deaf

Why can't some people sing?

Some people are born with the natural talent to sing. Others aren't. Some people can't sing because they are either inexperienced or they are tone deaf.

Can rabbits sing?

No, rabbits cannot sing.

Can a bunny sing?

No, bunnies cannot sing.

What can some birds do that other birds cannot?

fly talk sing swim

Do fat people sing good?

It really depends on technique, not of size. Some fat people sing good. Some skinny people sing good. It really doesn't matter, size wise.

Can frogs sing?

No they cannot.

Why are people musicians?

Because some people are born to sing and some are born to listen..

Do lions sing?

No. they roar sometimes, but animals cannot sing

Can butterflies sing?

No, I'm afraid that butterflies cannot sing.

Why does no famous people sing in El Paso?

Some do.

Why can some people sing good and some can't?

bigger nobs

Can Ashlee Simpson sing?

The ability to sing is often genrealised and thus, the meaning is lost in translation as people think different things about different kinds of singing. The answer is YES Ashlee can sing, she has a unique style of singing that not everyone can apreciate, and thus some people think she cannot. I'ts all down to perspective.

Can a bunny?

No, bunnies cannot sing.

How much do they pay a singer to sing?

some people pay 1,000 it matters of how u look and sing

How does cerebral palsy affect people?

some people cannot control their movements some cannot move at all

Where to get sing in Pokemon Pearl?

The move Sing cannot obtained as a TM or HM.

Why does some people not like jedward?

Probably because they're quite annoying to some people and some people think they cant sing!

Why do people like Jonas?

some people like how they sing and others think they are cute

How many octaves can a person sing?

The average is two octaves, but some people can sing three to four octaves.

Does Katy Perry Lip Sing Her Songs?

Some people believe that. but I don't. She does NOT lip sing her songs in Concert.

Why do some people hum sing or whistle all the time?

It is a genetic gift some people have. they are the lucky ones.

How do people sing songs?

People sing songs, if they are interested in singing and they are confidence to sing.

What animal has scales but cannot sing?