0
Why was it necessary to pass the thirteenth amendment after the emancipation proclamation had been an issue?
Wiki User
∙ 10y ago
Wiki User
∙ 10y agoThe emancipation proclamation had freed the enslaved african americans only in the states at war with the union.
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Why was the Thirteenth Amendment necessary if President Lincoln freed the slaves with the Emancipation Proclamation?
The Emancipation Proclamation was not a law but an executive order by the president. It needed the 13th amendment to the US Constitution to give it the weight and force of law.
What did the emancipation proclamation still leave into question according to the southern states?
The problem with the Emancipation Proclamation is that it did not outlaw the institution of slavery. As the Emancipation Proclamation was issued by President Lincoln under the War Powers Act, he could have outlawed the institution of slavery, but he chose not to. A further problem with the Proclamation was that it only freed the slaves in states or territories that were not occupied by Union forces. For example, slaves in places like Maryland and Delaware, both slave states, were not freed by the Emancipation Proclamation. Maryland was never allowed to vote on secession, because President Lincoln sent Federal Troops into the Maryland statehouse and prevented the state legislature from voting. President Lincoln was very skillful in wording the Emancipation Proclamation so that it only freed the slaves in ten states of the Confederacy, and not in all slave states. However, as these states were not under the control of the United States, but under the control of the Confederate States of America, the Emancipation Proclamation had no effect there. Further, in some areas in the Confederate states where the Union Army had taken control were specifically listed as areas where the Emancipation Proclamation would have no effect, and slaves in those areas would not be freed by the Proclamation. For example, in southern Louisiana, where Union forces had captured New Orleans on 1 May 1862, and later spread their control over surrounding areas, those parishes in southern Louisiana were specifically listed in the Emancipation Proclamation as areas where the slaves would not be set free. The idea behind this was that where slaves were working under Union control then they needed to remain slaves for the good of the Union and the Federal government. This clearly demonstrates that the Emancipation Proclamation was not a humanitarian act of President Lincoln, but rather was only a military tactic to attempt to weaken areas of the Confederacy where the Union forces were not in control. So, if no slaves were freed in Federally controlled areas, and if the Proclamation had no effect in areas controlled by the Confederacy, then no slaves were freed by the Emancipation Proclamation. In order to outlaw slavery, and to free the slaves, it was necessary to pass the 13th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. It was that Amendment that actually ended slavery and freed the slaves.
Was the Emancipation Proclamation constitutional?
It's iffy at best. Lincoln called on his position as Commander in Chief and his ability to issue a federal order "as a necessary war measure" that slaves in the rebel states could be regarded as free.
What role did Lincoln play in enacting the thirteenth Amendment?
his part was critical. He used all his influence to get the measure the necessary 2/3 vote in the house of Rep., and it was finally carried by a margin of 3 votes. with/o him the amen. would have been long delayed.
What requirement was necessary for African Americans to become citizens under the fourteenth amendment?
The requirement that was necessary for African Americans to become citizens undr the fourtheenth amendment was that they had to be born in the U.S.
Why was the Thirteenth Amendment necessary if President Lincoln freed the slaves with the Emancipation Proclamation?
The Emancipation Proclamation was not a law but an executive order by the president. It needed the 13th amendment to the US Constitution to give it the weight and force of law.
Why might it have been necessary to pass the 13th amendment even after Lincoln delivered the Emancipation proclamation?
because it is the only way to stop slavery.
What did the emancipation proclamation still leave into question according to the southern states?
The problem with the Emancipation Proclamation is that it did not outlaw the institution of slavery. As the Emancipation Proclamation was issued by President Lincoln under the War Powers Act, he could have outlawed the institution of slavery, but he chose not to. A further problem with the Proclamation was that it only freed the slaves in states or territories that were not occupied by Union forces. For example, slaves in places like Maryland and Delaware, both slave states, were not freed by the Emancipation Proclamation. Maryland was never allowed to vote on secession, because President Lincoln sent Federal Troops into the Maryland statehouse and prevented the state legislature from voting. President Lincoln was very skillful in wording the Emancipation Proclamation so that it only freed the slaves in ten states of the Confederacy, and not in all slave states. However, as these states were not under the control of the United States, but under the control of the Confederate States of America, the Emancipation Proclamation had no effect there. Further, in some areas in the Confederate states where the Union Army had taken control were specifically listed as areas where the Emancipation Proclamation would have no effect, and slaves in those areas would not be freed by the Proclamation. For example, in southern Louisiana, where Union forces had captured New Orleans on 1 May 1862, and later spread their control over surrounding areas, those parishes in southern Louisiana were specifically listed in the Emancipation Proclamation as areas where the slaves would not be set free. The idea behind this was that where slaves were working under Union control then they needed to remain slaves for the good of the Union and the Federal government. This clearly demonstrates that the Emancipation Proclamation was not a humanitarian act of President Lincoln, but rather was only a military tactic to attempt to weaken areas of the Confederacy where the Union forces were not in control. So, if no slaves were freed in Federally controlled areas, and if the Proclamation had no effect in areas controlled by the Confederacy, then no slaves were freed by the Emancipation Proclamation. In order to outlaw slavery, and to free the slaves, it was necessary to pass the 13th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. It was that Amendment that actually ended slavery and freed the slaves.
Evaluate the following assertion Preserving the Union was the necessary condition for abolishing slavery in the US?
Having issued the Emancipation Proclamation, Lincoln then had to win the war (i.e. preserve the union) in order for abolition to be enforced.
Was the Emancipation Proclamation constitutional?
It's iffy at best. Lincoln called on his position as Commander in Chief and his ability to issue a federal order "as a necessary war measure" that slaves in the rebel states could be regarded as free.
Why did Abraham Lincoln announce the emancipation proclamation after the Battle of Antietam?
He had wanted to issue it earlier, but could not do so after a string of defeats, or it would look like a desperate measure. The unexpected (and accidental) Union win at Antietam gave him the necessary credibility.
What role did Lincoln play in enacting the thirteenth Amendment?
his part was critical. He used all his influence to get the measure the necessary 2/3 vote in the house of Rep., and it was finally carried by a margin of 3 votes. with/o him the amen. would have been long delayed.
Why has it been necessary to make in the constitution by methods in addition to formal amendment?
Because the need to "repeal" amendments was sometimes necessary and desired by the people, as in the 18th amendment.
Was a constitutional amendment necessary before congress could impose a tax on income?
No. A constitutional amendment was necessary before congress could impose a tax on property.
What requirement was necessary for African Americans to become citizens under the fourteenth amendment?
The requirement that was necessary for African Americans to become citizens undr the fourtheenth amendment was that they had to be born in the U.S.
Which amendment process is demonstrated in the legislation that has been passed by Congress under the necessary and proper clause?
informal amendment process
Is it necessary to date or kiss on you're thirteenth?
its not necessary but by the time your thirteen you probably should have had a kiss at least once (not counting your mom or dad) so if you haven't you should get a move on!
