0
Why did the Senate reject President Reagan's Supreme Court nominee Robert Bork?
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
The most recent candidate rejected by the Senate was Ronald Reagan's nominee, Robert Bork, chosen to replace Justice Lewis Powell, who retired in 1987.
Bork was a controversial choice because of his ultra-conservative ideology, which alarmed many civil rights groups. Bork also had ties to the Nixon administration, where he briefly served as United States Attorney General following the infamous "Saturday Night Massacre" (for more information on this subject, see US v. Nixon, (1974), in Related Links, below). In addition, Bork was a judicial restraint extremist who supported disproportionate Executive branch powers, bordering on "supremacy."
A large number of political activists opposed Bork's nomination and applied pressure to the Senate (many of whom had their own reservations) to reject him. Bork was blocked by a bipartisan vote of 58-42 on October 23, 1987.
The vacancy was ultimately filled by incumbent Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, whose views are more moderate.
Bork, who was offended by his treatment in the confirmation process, resigned as a federal judge in 1988. He is currently a lawyer, law school professor, and author of several books.
Wiki User
∙ 14y ago
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
If the Senate feel that the president has not made a good choice for an appointment what can the Senate do?
According to Article II, section 2 of the U.S. Constitution, the President shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint Ambassadors, judges and other high ranking officials. The senate holds hearings to determine the suitability of the nominee and confirms the nomination by a majority vote. Plainly, the Senate could vote not to confirm the potential nominee. President Ronald Reagan's nomination of Judge Robert Bork is an example of a defeated nomination, as Bork was denied a seat on the US Supreme Court by a vote 42 to 58. (42 voted to confirm; 58 voted to not confirm) More practically, the nominee simply realizes there is little support for their nomination and chooses to withdraw. President Bush's nomineee for the Supreme Court, Harriet Miers, chose this route. Although not done by Senate "action" the withdrawal is recognition the nominee likely would not be confirmed. The Senate also has the ability to allow a nominee to languish in committee hearings. This typically happens toward the end of a President's term when the opposing party holds control of the Senate. Again, while not an action of the whole Senate, the implication is clear: We will not schedule a vote because the President will soon be gone. Hope this helps.
Who holds hearings to question and investigate US Supreme Court nominees?
The Senate Judiciary Committee is responsible for conducting a hearing and formulating questions related to the nominee's personal and professional life. The FBI conducts a background investigation and reports its findings to the Committee.After the Committee is satisfied it has gathered enough information to make an informed decision, the members vote whether to recommend approval or rejection (occasionally, the committee is divided in its opinion and makes no recommendation). Often, the vote has more to do with partisan politics than with the candidate's suitability as a justice.Finally, the full Senate has an opportunity to question the nominee and then votes whether to confirm the nominee's appointment. Most are confirmed, although there have been a few instances in which the Senate voted against the candidate. The most recent Supreme Court rejection was that of President Reagan's nominee, Robert Bork, in 1987.
When was Robert Kennedy elected president?
Robert Kennedy was never elected president. He was killed while campaigning for president in California by Sirhan Sirhan.
What Supreme Court nominee withdrew her name from consideration in 2005?
Harriet MiersOn October 3, 2005, President George W. Bush nominated Harriet Miers, his private attorney and White House counsel, to the seat being vacated by Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, who was retiring.Miers had no judicial experience, and was rated "unqualified" by the American Bar Association, which passes unofficial judgment on all Supreme Court nominees. The Republican party was outraged at the nomination and indicated they would not vote favorably for her appointment. Miers quietly requested her nomination be withdrawn before her Senate Judiciary hearing.Ironically, one of Mier's most scathing critics was Robert Bork, the most recent nominee rejected by a vote of the Senate.
What is Harriet Miers' relationship to the US Supreme Court?
AnswerHarriet Miers was nominee to the US Supreme Court for a brief period in 2005, but her nomination was withdrawn when it became clear she was considered unqualified.ExplanationOn October 3, 2005, President George W. Bush nominated Harriet Miers, his private attorney and White House counsel, to the seat being vacated by Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, who was retiring.Miers had no judicial experience, and was rated "unqualified" by the American Bar Association, which passes unofficial judgment on all Supreme Court nominees. The Republican party was outraged at the nomination and indicated they would not vote favorably for her appointment. Miers quietly requested her nomination be withdrawn before her Senate Judiciary hearing.Ironically, one of Mier's most scathing critics was Robert Bork, the most recent nominee rejected by a vote of the Senate.
Whom did Robert Mugabe succeed as the President of Zimbabwe?
Whom did Robert Mugabe succeed as the President of Zimbabwe?
What has Robert Bork done?
served as a judge on the supreme court?
Who is John G Robert Junior?
Supreme Court person.
Where did Robert Boyle Conduct His experiments?
Robert Boyle conducted his experiments in the supreme court or at his science lab
The chief commander of the confederate states of America?
I don't think they appointed a supreme commander. Robert E. Lee was in charge of the army in the East and was undoubtedly their leading general. Jefferson Davis was the president - I do not know if he was commander-in-chief of military forces like the US president.
Who was Robert Lee?
Robert E. Lee was the supreme commander of the Confederate army during the American Civil War.
What is the name of president of Zimbabwe currently?
Robert Mugabe has been president and dictator of Zimbabwe for 26 years.
