Is the Great Gatsby

Assuming the coin is circulated and has no mintmark, the 1925 Buffalo nickel is a high mintage common date. The value for average circulated coins is $1.00-$3.00.

$40 to $60 in moderately worn circulated condition

Assuming it is in circulated condition, it is worth around $22.50 in silver content.

1925 is correct. There's no need for an apostrophe.