David Tate wore the number 49 for the colts through 1994-1997. Then the number was never used again.
The Indianapolis Colts wore blue pants with their white jerseys for the first three games in the 1995 season.
No one wore the number 85 on the 1958 Baltimore Colts.
Dwight Hollier. Hollier played with the Dolphins between 1992-1999 and the Colts in 2000. He wore #56 for the Colts.
Johnny Unitas wore it, and then they retired the number after he retired.
Pierre Garcon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Garcon
Bobby wore #4 for the Tigers from 1995-2005.
Peyton Manning was the only player to have worn number 18 for the Indianapolis Colts. After leaving the team, his number was retired.
Punter Chris Mohr wore number 9 for the 1995 Buffalo Bills.
Tony Phillips. Phillips wore #4 for the Tigers between 1990-1994 and Higginson wore #4 between 1995-2005.
In 1995, Damon Mays wore the #86 for the Steelers.
Tony Fernandez wore uniform number 6 for the 1995 New York Yankees.
In 2005, tackle Trai Essex wore #79 for the Steelers.