answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

An easy answer might be that a federal case is one that is tried in federal courts and a state case is one that is tried in state courts, but it is not that simple.

A federal case is one which involves enforcement of federal statutes or the Constitution or civil cases under the so-called diversity jurisdiction of the courts. Diversity jurisdiction allows issues that would ordinarily be state cases to be tried in federal courts if the parties are located in different states and the amount in controversy exceeds a statutorily fixed amount. One might say that this is simply a state case in a federal court, but it is more correct to call it a federal case since federal law created federal diversity jurisdiction and since it is being tried in a federal court.

A state case is one which involves enforcement of state statutes or case law (like personal injury, contract and state criminal offenses).

Sometimes federal issues are raised in state courts. Nothing prohibits a party in a state court from raising federal constitutional issues. In fact it is common, such as when in a state criminal trial, the accused alleges his federal constitutional rights have been violated. Examples are demands to exclude evidence that has been obtaine through an allegedly unreasonable search and seizure, or that a new trial should be had because the defendant was denied competent counsel and other protected rights. The mere raising of a federal issue does not require it to be heard in a federal court.

User Avatar

Wiki User

13y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar
More answers
User Avatar

Wiki User

14y ago

A case goes to a federal court if the case deals with the constitutionality of a law. Most of your criminal cases, contract cases, tort cases, family law etc. go to your state court.

This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: How do you tell if a case is state or federal?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

Is ted kaczynski a state or federal case?

Ted Kaczynski, also known as the Unabomber, was prosecuted in federal court. He was charged with multiple federal offenses due to his bombing spree targeting individuals involved in modern technology.


If you get 5-10 in a state case and 77 months in a federal case do you serve time in a federal or state prison?

both


Was the Louise Woodward case federal or state?

state case held in Massachusetts


What takes priority State Constitution or State Regulations?

Federal. The dual government is set up in such a way that if federal and state are in conflict, federal trumps. The order is as follows: Federal constitution Federal statute Federal case law Federal regulations and administrative law State constitution State statute State case law State regulations and administrative law


Do state laws have an impact in federal courts?

Under some situations, a case involving a person from out of state can be tried in a Federal Court according to a state law. While state law never supersedes Federal law, a lawyer can bring up a case from state law that might have bearing on a Federal Case. The way the United States Supreme Court ruled on that state case would affect Federal Law and could influence the federal court.


How do you transfer your court case to another state?

You can not transfer acourt case unless yours is federal. If it is google transfer federal co.urt case


If a state is party to a case the Constitution provides that original jurisdiction shall be in?

The constitution does not provide specifically for jurisdiction when a State is party to any state case. When the state is party to a case filed in FEDERAL court then that case is heard in the federal district court in that state. Every state has at least one, some have more. There are 6 federal district courts in the USA. This includes one in each territory to include DC and Puerto Rico. If the case is a state based case (filed under that state's law) then procedurally that state will hear the case.


When is a case classified as a federal trial?

When you are charged with a federal offense as opposed to a state offense.


Who chose the punishments for which crime?

In the case of state offenses - it is the state legislature. In the case of Federal Laws - it is the US Congress.


Was the David Westerfield case held in a federal or state court?

state court


Where can a case be tried that is in violation of state and federal laws?

Crimes that violate both state and federal laws can be tried in either state or federal court. Frequently, they are tried in both.


Can a state case be admissible in federal court?

With one exception, a case that raises only state related issues cannot be tried in federal courts, because federal court jurisdiction is limited to cases that raise federal questions. The only time a case that raises only state issues can be filed in federal court is where the case qualifies for federal diversity jurisdiction, i.e. both parties reside in different states and the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000. Federal diversity jurisdiction parameters are fixed by a federal statute.