They used to date.
Joel Madden, though, has been with Nicole Richie for three years (as of 2009) and has two children with her.
Hilary broke up with Joel because she couldn't take the long-distance thing. The age difference was also a SMALL role in it. Hilary didn't want to hold Joel back from starting a family. He is old enough to be getting married and having kids and Hilary was too young and too focused on her career. you are entirely correct it was Hilary who broke up with Joel.
Hilary Duff is extremely popular as a celeb known worldwide. from this pressure she may soon be diagnosed with depression especially since she has just been dumped by rock star Joel MAdden. he has now moved on to Nicole Richie and the pair have already had a baby. All this traumatic pressure may soon make poor Hils sick.....
Paris Hilton recently broke up with Benji Madden, who she had been dating for quite a while. Currently, it's not clear if she is dating one person or looking around but it seems like she is playing the lesbian field. She was dating Benji Madden, Joel Madden's brother, but they broke up.... As of the end of May 2010 she is dating Cy Waits Sorce: I know him personally.
If you are 13 years old when were you born?
Is it true that one human year is equal to seven dog years?
What is half of 74?
What does minus 3 degrees mean is it 3 degrees below zero or 3 degrees below 32 degrees Fahrenheit?
Why can't we remember our dreams?
How do you protect the masonic emblem?
How much is 10000 quarters worth?
What gangs are in Ohio?
Can eggs break inside a chicken?
Why do books come out in hardback first?
What happens when a beehive gets too full?
What is the difference between an optometrist and an ophthalmologist?
How can you tell when someone's lying?
Why do some people celebrate Christmas in July?
Why is it bad luck to walk under a ladder?
What is a conservatorship?
How did Robert perault die?
Was Lucy meacock married to rob Mcloughlin?
What do you mean halim seeds in gujarati?
Who was giani maan singh jhaur?
Which of the following best describes what is required to be reported to congress?
What is a classified data spill or negligent discharge of classified information?
What is Ford Motor Credit payoff address OVERNIGHT?
Why the eastern Terai is cooler than than western one OF NEPAL?