Who killed sutton in the book series the lying game?

Answer 1

alright, so in the first book it doesn't tell us who kills her... but i think it was Ethan only because when she was trying to leave he pretty much forced her to stay, and he knew she wasn't Sutton, also because he keeps to himself a lot and is always nervous. whenever Emma walks up to him he's alway really firm until he realizes who it is, and also because he's trying to get close to Emma so that she doesn't leave so she can keep on covering up Suttons murder. but i mean i guess we will have to wait for the next book, but for i think it was Ethan.

^ I agree, because it kind of seems like he was there whenever something bad happened to her - e.g. the light crashing down at the dance - but I also think Thayer may be involved somehow too.

Im answering this question after starting on reading the fourth book of THe lying game series and i think its Charlottes dad. Im saying this because in the first book when Emma first got to Arizona to meet Sutton she met Charlottes dad and after Suttons friends did the gun prank on her and took her away it only makes sense that Charlottes dad would have taken her things since he was also there and left. Another reaosn why i would suspect him is because at the sleepover at Charlottes house whe she went downstairs all her friends where asleep so it couldnt have been them but it could have been Charlottes dad...after all it was his house. at first i was also suspecting Ethan cause he was pushing her away from telling the police and she never got a warning letter after telling him but Ethan doesnt really have any reason to kill sutton, or atleast not yet. its just my opinion but it made lots of sense and maybe Madelines dad may have something to do with it? afterall he is a violent man and his son thayer ran away so he probably blamed sutton for it and his dissapearence to hong kong?

Answer 2

It says that Sutton watched Emma tell Ethan the whole story, everything. It didn't go through the convoersation so I'm sure Emma told Ethan her name. I think it's too early to tell who killed Sutton. There are too many different possibilities. There's Laurel, Madison & Charolette who all had motives to kill her. Then there's mysterious Ethan. There's the disappered Thayer and Madison's dad who is supposed to be in Hong Kong. There's too many possiblites to tell so soon.

I completely agree with the person above me, it's too early to tell. She probably told him her name while telling the story.

I agree with the two answers above me. It's definitely not Ethan. Emma told Ethan the whole story and the two are trying to figure out Sutton's murder. As said towards the end of book two "This has to end now." (meaning we should tell the cops). I myself don't think it was Laurel, Charlotte, or Madison. I think it was the Twitter Twins according to the clues in book one and two.

It's not the Twitter Twins. As much as they hated Sutton they wouldn't kill her all they wanted was to be in their group. I don't know, but my possibilities are Ethan, Emma's real mom, Madison's dad. Madison's dad cause he's abusive and maybe to get back at Sutton for what she did to Thayer.

Answer 3

Well neither the books nor the show have said yet but the following people are innocent:*

1. Emma- Didn't know about her until she died

2. Char- Was at Mads's house

3. Mads- With Char at home

4. Laurel- At a tennis sleepover

5. The Twitter Twins (Gabby and Lilli)- Only interested in being in Sutton's club

6. Nisha and the tennis team- Were all together at a tennis sleepover

*These are the people named innocent from books 1 and 2

Hope this helped!

Answer 4

It isn't confirmed yet. Ask sara shepard

Answer 5

In the book, Yes in the t.v show, No.