Was the New Deal a success or disaster?

Answer 1

AnswerA success, it was partially responsible for ending the depression by suppling jobs instead of handouts. AnswerThe New Deal was a failure because many of the New Deal agencies discriminated against black people. Black people either got no work or received worse treatment or even lower wages. This conveys to us that the New Deal was a failure because Roosevelt did not really achieve his aim of getting Americans back to work. This is the case because the majority of black people were not involved in work due to the fact they were seen as being inferior and not as important as the white race. Therefore this conveys to us that the New Deal was a failure because the New Deal did not improve the situation for black people.

On the other hand The New Deal did have its successes. The New Deal created millions of jobs. This suggests to us that The New Deal was a success because by introducing more jobs through The Public Works Administration people had more money to spend. As well as this by creating millions of jobs it put more Americans in to work. This therefore implies to us that The New Deal was a success because it met the aim of Roosevelt which was to put Americans back in to work. "Our greatest primary task is to put people to work" (Roosevelt's inauguration speech, 1933) supports this. This therefore conveys to us that The New Deal was a success because it met the "primary task" so it achieved one of Roosevelt's goals. This is supported by a source showing the number of unemployed people between the years 1929 and 1942. This source supports the fact that The New Deal put Americans in to work because in 1933( the year The New Deal was introduced) there was 24.9% labor force unemployed but this dropped to 21.7% the next year and dropped to 14.3% in 1937. This source shows that the New Deal was a success because it supports the fact that The New Deal put Americans back to work.

Moreover, The New Deal projects provided the USA with valuable resources such as schools, roads and power stations. This suggests to us that the New Deal was a success because it conveys to us that without The New Deal buildings such as schools would not have been built meaning that education would not have been the same. Also it implies to us that transport would not have been the same without The New Deal as roads would not have been built. As well as this The New Deal introduced further jobs in construction through the construction of schools, roads and power stations. This also suggests to us that The New Deal was a success because it produced more jobs for the people of America. This makes it a success because the more jobs people had the more money they would earn. The more money means that the people of America would have the ability to purchase goods which could have boosted the economy.

Answer 2

Both AT ONCE. There will always be successful "arguers" on both side of ANY debate. The US' socio/political/economic democratic "experiment" has survived (not too shabbily), so it MUST have been a GREAT success. Others may dissent, and probably will.

Answer 3

There were many successful aspects to the New Deal. These positiveaspects included the Social Security Act, the Securities andExchange Commission, and the Fair Labor Standards Act.

Answer 4

The new deal brought many elderly, umemployed, and homeless alot of attention. These people suffered from alot during The Great Depression and the new deal DID help them.