0
Under the orders of Major General Henry W. Halleck, both generals US Grant and Don Carlos Buell were ordered to Pittsburg Landing in April of 1862. It was clear to Major General Halleck, who commanded Union forces in the Western Theater, that US Grant had been caught by surprise by the Rebels at Shiloh. If Buell's army did not reinforce Grant the night before the second day of battle at Shiloh, the Rebels would have been the victors there. With that said, Buell did indeed arrive in time to reinforce Grant. The now badly outnumbered Rebels were forced into retreat on day two of the battle. While "history" gives the victory to General Grant, his superior officer, General Halleck did not. He immediately left his base in St. Louis to take charge of Union forces after Shiloh. Halleck believed Grant had made a terrible error. Only when Halleck was called to Washington DC to become the new general in chief, did Grant regain his army.
Wiki User
∙ 6y ago
Wiki User
∙ 6y agoThere was a dispute between generals Buell and Grant over which general should be given credit for the Union victory at the Battle of Shiloh. Clearly the two day battle would not have been a Union success unless Buell's reinforcements had not reached Pittsburg Landing the evening before the second day of the battle. The commanding general of the West, Major General Henry Halleck took over the Union forces at Shiloh and wanted Grant either dismissed or demoted. President Lincoln came to Grant's defense. Grant, however, did not regain his command and Halleck the Union armies to Corinth, Mississippi. General Grant regained his command when Lincoln called Halleck to Washington DC to become the Union's new general in chief.With hindsight having 20-20 vision, it's best to say that the Union won the Battle of Shiloh.
Wiki User
∙ 14y agoWiki User
∙ 11y agoGeneral Ulysses S. Grant
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
Although the Battle of Shiloh Church seemed to be a victory for the North why was the apparent winner General Grant highly criticized?
General Grant was criticized for the Battle of Shiloh Church because of how many casualties there were during the battle. There were reports that General Grant had been drunk during the first part of the battle.
What mistake did grant make at Shiloh?
General US Grant was taken by surprise at the Battle of Shiloh. Even with the surprise, the outcome of the battle was a Union victory.
What Confederate General planned the frontal assault at the Battle of Shiloh?
Reporting to commanding General Sidney S. Johnston, General Beauregard submitted his plan to Johnston for the frontal assault on Union troops at the Battle of Shiloh in April of 1862.
What did Union General Sherman say about the battle of Shiloh?
In the aftermath of the Battle of Shiloh, General Sherman remarked that the battle would have cured anyone who wanted a war. This battle was devastating. It doubled all the previous casualties, and the destruction caused by then modern weaponry was immense.
What did the Battle of Shiloh show about the future course of the Civil War?
The Battle of Shiloh was fought on April 6-7, 1862. 23,746 soldiers were killed or wounded in the battle, 13,047 Union soldiers and 10,699 Confederate soldiers. The battle was a union victory, but the heavy casualties demonstrated that the war would be bloody and difficult.
Who was the Union leader in the Civil War at the Battle of Shiloh?
The answer is General Ulysses S. Grant.
Who were the losers in the Shiloh war?
The Battle of Shiloh was a battle in the American Civil War in which the Confederates attacked Union soldiers in Southwestern Tennessee. The Union eventually won this battle.
Who was the union general in command at the Battle of Shiloh?
Grant commanded the Federal forces at Shiloh.
Who was the general of the union of the Battle of Shiloh?
Ulysses S. Grant
What battle changed the union view that the civil war would end quickly with a union victory?
Battle of Shiloh
Who was the military leader for the union in the battle of shiloh?
General Grant was the commander
Who was the union leader at the Battle of Shiloh?
General Ulysses S. Grant
The Union's General Grant and the Confederate's General Johnston engaged in a terrible battle at?
shiloh
What was Ulysses S. Grant involvement in Shiloh?
General Grant was one of the Union Generals in the Battle of Bloody Shiloh.
Although the Battle of Shiloh Church seemed to be a victory for the North why was the apparent winner General Grant highly criticized?
General Grant was criticized for the Battle of Shiloh Church because of how many casualties there were during the battle. There were reports that General Grant had been drunk during the first part of the battle.
What mistake did grant make at Shiloh?
General US Grant was taken by surprise at the Battle of Shiloh. Even with the surprise, the outcome of the battle was a Union victory.
What is the date of the US Civil War Battle of Shiloh?
The US Civil War Battle of Shiloh was on April 6-7 1862 in Tennessee. It was the first major bloody battle of the war. Previous ones had been large, however their casualty rates were low compared to Shiloh. The battle was a Union victory for generals US Grant, Buell, and the head of the Western Theater for the North, General Henry Wager Halleck. In fact, for military purposes, the Union victory at Shiloh boasted the image of the commanding general of the West, Henry Halleck. He was so disturbed at the events at Shiloh, he came from Missouri to take control of Northern forces in Tennessee. Even though the Union won, Halleck believed that Union General Grant was to blame for almost having the South win.
