Depends almost entirely on the age and condition. Since 16 GA guns were not as common as 12 GA guns, a good 16 will bring more than a good 12.
how much is an Ithaca model 37 shotgun worth in fair condition
Your model 37 was mfg. in 1972.
Call Ithaca at 1 877 648 4222 for answer.
1950
1000.00
I would say if its in like new condtion its probably worth $200.00
well i wanted to know what my 16 gauge featherlight Ithaca how old it was and how much it was worth i called Ithaca arms gun co. out of Ohio because they are no longer made in Ithaca New York so that's your best bet
1950
100-500 USD
The serial number indicates Ithaca manufactured your Model 37 in 1956.
Made in 1968
Most all the Ithaca Pump model 37 were Engraved with 3 ducks and on the other side Pointer Flushing out 2 pheasants. It a common engraving we all see on Ithaca but you have an 1937 model like I do ,I have one as well with a serial number 2493, believe me they are worth keeping because that was the 1st year Ithaca made the Model 37 they only produced 3,500 shotgun in 1937