answersLogoWhite

0


Best Answer

A vibrating one might be less harmful to the animal but neither really should be used. Shock collars are part of what is called negative reinforcement training, where something bad happens to the dog if they do not do what you want.

Negative reinforcement teaches your dog to do what you want because they fear you. They don't do it because they want to please their owner, they do it for fear they may get hurt or shocked again. This method produces quick results, but destroys the bond between dog and owner, and often the dog is not taught and corrective behaviour - just not to do something.

Positive reinforcement teaches your dog to do what you want because they get something good and they want to please you. Positive reinforcement is always the way to go with training. You and your dog will be much happier. It will also depend on the dog as a vibrating collar may not work as well with some dogs.

User Avatar

Wiki User

12y ago
This answer is:
User Avatar

Add your answer:

Earn +20 pts
Q: What is better a shock collar or a vibrating collar?
Write your answer...
Submit
Still have questions?
magnify glass
imp
Related questions

What year was the shock collar invented?

what year was the shock collar invented?


Can you start walking your dog after shock collar?

no


What is the highest level on a shock collar?

10,093,849 Volts! :)


How does a shock collar perform?

A shock collar works by distracting a dog from barking through a device that delivers a stimulation. This might be a vibration,electrical shock, or audio sound. There is much controversy over the use of these devices.


How do you put a dog shock collar on a dog?

Do not put on a dog shock collar. It is inhumane for dogs and can cause nerve damage to people acting stupid. Trust me it is not healthy for you.


Is a shock collar a good training method?

Yes they can be very effective and pretty harmless. Some dogs who are neurotic can be affected negatively by them though .If you have a pretty mentally stabe dog then i recommend them . As long as your getting an electric fence and not tryin to torture your dog :] 2nd Answer: Play and pats are the best training method. If you are training a dog not to bark, then a shock collar is appropriate. Many dogs simply ignore the spray collars. BUT, if you use a shock collar, follow the dog around on the few times that you use it, and firmly command, "No Bark!" along with the shock. In short order, it will learn to obey your voice command. Unless it is a border collie, etc, which will also quickly learn when it has the shock collar on, and when it doesn't. When using the shock collar, you most likely will have to remove the regular collar with the dog's name and rabies tags . . . BE CAREFUL to not let the dog get away from you. Do not leave the dog unattended with the shock collar on and turned on! Most important be sure you KNOW what you are doing and how to handle the shock collar properly before you use it on your dog.


How can you make a Wheaten Terrier quit excessive licking?

You could try using a shock collar, or a 'lampshade' collar.


How many volts are in a dog shock collar?

why do people put shock collars on there dogs


Will static shock on a bark collar damage a dog's trachea?

it shouldnt. it normally just depends on the voltage of the bark collar


How do shock dog collars work?

The dog is equipped with a shock collar which can be triggered by the owner to give the dog a reminder that what she's doing is wrong. The trigger sends a radio signal to the collar which causes it to emit a small electric shock that feels unpleasant for the dog.


Where can someone purchase a petsafe shock collar?

There are many different retailers that sell a petsafe shock collar. In addition to the Amazon website, one might also try purchasing from the local pet store.


Can a shock collar be dangerous?

Yes it can! A shock collar can be extremely dangerous in the wrong hands. Some may even see this as animal cruelty. It is also considered and in some way very similar to tazering a human being.