In "The Giver," the community prioritizes safety over freedom of choice. They believe that strict control and conformity are necessary to avoid pain and conflict. However, the protagonist Jonas challenges this belief by seeking personal freedom and individuality.
The society in "The Giver" suppresses emotions, memories, and individuality. They also suppress the freedom of choice and differences among people.
Jonas wonders about his family, his friends, and the outside world when he is not with The Giver. He grapples with the lack of freedom and choice in his society, and questions the values and rules that have been imposed upon him.
The community in "The Giver" is safe because it is strictly controlled by rules and regulations that eliminate individuality, diversity, and freedom of choice. Citizens are closely monitored and conformity is enforced, resulting in a society without conflict or unrest. The absence of emotions, memories, and personal choices also contributes to the sense of safety in the community.
In "The Giver," living in a place where no doors are ever locked symbolizes a society that prioritizes safety, trust, and conformity over individuality and personal freedom. It reflects an environment where citizens feel secure enough to not need privacy or personal boundaries, suggesting a lack of real choice or autonomy. However, this also indicates a potential loss of deeper emotional connections and the richness of human experience, as true security often requires vulnerability and the acceptance of risk. Ultimately, it raises questions about the balance between safety and freedom in a controlled community.
Society today differs from "The Giver" in several ways. In the book, emotions are suppressed, truths are hidden, and individuality is discouraged. In contrast, today's society values personal expression, transparency, and celebrates diversity. Additionally, in "The Giver," there is no freedom of choice, while in modern society, individuals have the autonomy to make their own decisions.
The Receiver obtained wisdom in "The Giver" through memories transmitted by the Giver. By experiencing the pain, joy, and emotions of past generations, the Receiver gains a deeper understanding of the complexities of life and the importance of individual choice and freedom. This knowledge helps the Receiver to see beyond the controlled society they live in and question the status quo.
In "The Giver," the two things being compared are the community's strict conformity and control over individuality, compared to the freedom and emotions that come with embracing individual choice and experience. The novel explores the consequences of sacrificing personal autonomy for societal harmony.
Jonas feels conflicted about Climate Control and Sameness in "The Giver" because while they maintain stability and order in the community, they also suppress individuality and choice. He begins to question these practices when he starts to understand the cost of sacrificing personal freedom for the sake of safety and conformity. This inner conflict leads Jonas to ultimately challenge the society's values and seek a different way of life.
"The Giver" can be seen as both a utopia and a dystopia. On one hand, it presents a society that seems peaceful and orderly where conflict and suffering are minimized. However, the strict control over personal freedoms, thoughts, and emotions make it a dystopia for those who value individuality and freedom of choice.
The receiver
At the end of "The Giver," Jonas escapes from the community and finds a new place where he can experience true emotions and freedom.
"The Giver" was created in 1993 by author Lois Lowry. It is a dystopian novel that has since become a popular choice for young adult readers.