0
What do one or more justices write when they disagree with the majority?
Wiki User
∙ 11y ago
A Justice may write a dissenting opinion if he or she votes against the majority and wants to record his or her legal reasoning for consideration in future cases. Dissenting opinions, although written in opposition to the majority, or Court Opinion, may be cited as precedents in future litigation. An opinion that agrees with the decision in the case (although not necessarily the reasoning) is called a concurringopinion.
For more information on opinions of the Court, see Related Questions, below.
Wiki User
∙ 13y ago
Wiki User
∙ 13y agoWritten opinions represent the constitutional theories, logic and case law supporting a decision or a response to that decision.
The Supreme Court may issue more than one type of opinion. The majority decision is released as "the opinion of the Court." Other justices may write concurring (agreeing) or dissenting (disagreeing) opinions.
Wiki User
∙ 12y agoThe justice may write a concurring opinion, or an opinion "concurring in judgment only."
Wiki User
∙ 12y agoA dissenting opinion.
Wiki User
∙ 14y agoA concurring opinion
Add your answer:
Earn +20 pts
The nine Justices hear cases and deliver?
The nine Justices hear cases and deliver rulings and opinions on them. One or more Justice will write a dissenting opinion if they disagree with the ruling.
For the majority ruling on the Supreme Court there needs to be at least justices who agree?
For a majority ruling on the Supreme Court, a minimum of five out of the nine justices must agree. This is because a majority decision requires more than half of the justices to support a particular outcome or opinion. It is necessary to have a majority in order to establish a binding decision for the Court.
What is it called when five or more justices rule a particular way?
A Majority Opinion
What type of vote is required for a majority decision in the US Supreme Court?
For a case to be heard before the U. S. Supreme Court there must be a quorum. This requires at least six Justices to be present. There is a total of nine Justices on the Supreme Court but illness or recusals could cause less than 9 on a case. For a decision to be rendered it requires a majority of the Justices hearing the case. If all Justices are present the majority would require 5 or more to met this requirement.
What is the decision of most of the justices on the Supreme Court called?
The agreed ruling of more than half of the Supreme Court justices is called a majority decision.
Which member of the US Supreme Court interprets the law?
All nine members of the US Supreme Court interpret the law, then they discuss their perspectives on individual cases in twice-weekly conferences. When the Court votes on how to dispose a case, the decision with the most votes (the majority) writes the official opinion of the Court.If the Chief Justice is a member of the majority, he may choose to write the opinion himself, or select another member of the majority to handle the task. If the Chief Justice is not part of the majority, then the most senior justice in that group decides who will write the opinion.If the justices not in the majority want to present a unified dissent, they decide amongst themselves who will write it.All members of the Court may write opinions about a particular case, explaining why they agree or disagree with the decision.For more information on US Supreme Court opinions, see Related Questions, below.
What is a written explanation of a US Supreme Court decision called if five or more justices agree?
Five or more justices who agree on a decision form a majority. The written decision is sometimes called the "majority opinion," but is officially known as the "opinion of the Court" to signify its importance.
What is the 'opinion of the Court'?
The Court's Opinion is synonymous with the Court's decision, and usually refers to the majority opinion. The "Opinion of the Court" gives the verdict and explains the reasoning behind the decision reached. The privilege of writing the official opinion falls to the most senior justice in the majority group, or to the Chief Justice if he (or she) voted with the majority; this person may choose to write the opinion, or may assign the task to another member of the majority. If the justices who voted against the majority wish to issue a unified opinion, they simply decide amongst themselves who will write it. Individual justices may write their own opinions, regardless of whether they agree with the majority. Justices may also "join" or sign any other written opinion they agree with, even if they agree with more than one point-of-view. This generally strengthens the opinion.
What is a written statement by most of the justices in support of a Supreme Court decision?
The agreed ruling of more than half of the Supreme Court justices is called a majority decision; the written document is called a majority opinion or the "opinion of the Court."
How do a concurring opinion and a unanimous opinion differ?
Majority opinion - Also called the "Opinion of the Court," this is the official verdict in the case that represents the vote of the majority of justicesDissenting opinion - An opinion written by a justice who disagrees with the majorityConcurring opinion - An opinion that agrees with the decision but may disagree with the some of the reasoning behind the Court opinion, or may elaborate on a point made or introduce further relevant informationThe most important type is the majority opinion. The majority opinion is, as the name suggests, the opinion of the majority of judges hearing the case. In most cases, a majority opinion requires five Justices, unless one or more Justices have recused themselves from a given decision. The majority opinion is important because it defines the precedent that all future courts hearing a similar case should follow.Majority opinions are sometimes accompanied by concurring opinions. Concurring opinions are written by individual Justices in the majority. These opinions agree with the majority opinion, but may stress a different point of law. Sometimes, concurring opinions will agree with the result reached by the majority, but for a different reason altogether.Opinions written by justices not in the majority are known as dissenting opinions. Dissenting opinions are important because they provide insight into how the Court reached its decision.the statement written to explain why the decision was made (GradPoint)For more information, see Related Questions, below.
How many justices are needed to make a decision?
US Supreme Court decisions require a simple majority vote (more than half). For example, if all nine justices hear a case, five must vote in agreement to form a majority.
Who decides which justice writes the dissenting opinion in a Supreme Court case?
If the justices who voted against the majority wish to issue a unified dissenting opinion, they decide amongst themselves who will author the opinion, then the others, if in agreement, will "join" the opinion. Individual justices may write their own (concurring or dissenting) opinions, regardless of whether they agree with the majority. Justices may also "join" or sign any other written opinion they agree with. This generally strengthens the opinion.
