Why does the boys rescue plan fail?

Answer 1

There is chaos among the boys, and no cooperation. There is not a collective effort to carry out the rescue plan, but only Ralph's tribe actually works to make it happen. However, Jack's tribe is only focusing and interested in hunting wild pigs and possibly even killing the beast( they do not know what the beast actually is). Thus, Jack and his boys let the signal fire die out because they were busy hunting, when Ralph ordered them to tend the fires. This also shows defiance and weakening of Ralph's power, which then leads to Jack hunting down Ralph and Piggy being murdered. Now, the boys' chances of rescue seem impossible.

Answer 2

The boys' rescue plan fails due to a combination of factors such as lack of proper planning, underestimation of the risks involved, and unforeseen obstacles beyond their control. Additionally, the boys' inexperience and impulsiveness contribute to the failure of the rescue attempt.