Is ashfur evil

Answer 1

Ashfur is considered evil because he plotted with Hawkfrost to kill Firestar . But the only reason he threatened squirrelflights kits was because he had loved her at a time. Ashfur was a noble warrior and was killed by hollyleaf, who went crazy in the end of sunrise and died in the tunnels after they collapsed.

Answer 2

He tried to kill Jayfeather, Hollyleaf, and Lionblaze in the fire to hurt Squirrelflight, like she did him by choosing Brambleclaw over him, as he says. During the fire scene he also annouces that he conspirited with Hawkfrost and lured Firestar out of camp to fox trap that nearly killed him. Then, after Squirrelflight reveals that they are not her kits, Ashfur threatens to tell everyone her secret.

Answer 3

Yes, because he was threatening to tell everyone that Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather weren't Brambleclaw's and Squirrelflight's kits.

I'd say it's a matter of opinion, but I think that Ashfur was a good and loyal warrior of ThunderClan, but his attempt on murder made him a traitor, so, yes. -manningpeyton959 I don't think he deserved to die, but I was glad when he did, actually. He was a good, loyal warrior, that was just miserable because Squirrelflight had left him. He was always trying to get back at her, trying to kill lionblaze in his battle training, and almost killing them in a fire and then planning on spreading the news about squirrelflight to the clan at the gathering. It probably did the clan good that he died, even if they don't know HOW he died.

Answer 4

Ashfur is a controversial character in the Warriors series. Some fans believe he is evil due to his actions, such as trying to harm Squirrelflight's loved ones. Others argue that he is more of a misguided character consumed by his emotions. Ultimately, his morality is a topic of debate among readers.

Answer 5

Ashfur isn't really "evil"; he is mad at Squirrelflight for choosing Brambleclaw over him, causing him to do evil things, but he didn't have a truly evil character.