Did Hollyleaf turn evil

Answer 1

Yes, in "Sunrise" it is confirmed that she killed Ashfur, and she later attempts to kill Leafpool. yep Yes because she said that Leafpool deserved to die. Some people think she's evil because she kills ashfur. some people just thinks she goes crazy. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I think that she was really upset about somethings, and very upset with the warrior code. Splashmud: Hollyleaf just needed to calm down. I never liked Hollyleaf and I thought I would be happy when she died, but I was sad.

Answer 2

Hollyleaf does not turn evil. She becomes extremely distressed and freaked out to the point of madness after finding out that her mother is the medicine cat, Leafpool and her father is Crowfeather of WindClan. She couldn't bear the thought of being a mistake or being half-clan. She unsuccessfully tried to kill Leafpool and get revenge by making her eat deathberries(which did not work, as stated before)

She killed herself by running into the tunnels. The tunnels collapsed and killed her. However, her death was not intentional, but rather Hollyleaf was trying to escape the Clans and her crimes.

Lionblaze and Jayfeather then found out that one of Whitewing and Birchfall's kits was the other one of the prophecy "There will be three, kin of your kin, who hold the power of the stars in their paws." They never said they would have to be siblings, but had to be kin. Since Whitewing is the daughter of CLoudtail who is the nephew of Firestar they are related. Since Lionblaze and Jayfeather are the sons of Leafpool who is the daughter of Firestar they are related too. You could say Lionblaze and Jayfeather are 2nd cousins of Dovekit and Ivykit.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hollyleaf does turn evil. Here are many things that make her evil and breaking the code

1. Hollyleaf killed Ashfur, which is against the code

2. Hollyleaf tried to kill Leafpool

3. At the Gathering, Hollyleaf disobeyed her Clan leader by speaking when he said no

So therefore Hollyleaf is evil

Answer 3

In my opinion, I think she was just confused and lost. I mean, who wouldn't be after they found out their whole lives have been a lie? It would drive me insane too!

Hollyleaf had no right to do what she did. What about Stonefur and Mistyfoot? They had almost the same exact situation, yet they forgave Bluestar and Oakheart for never telling them. So Hollyleaf doesn't have an excuse.

And what about her brothers? They didn't try to kill their mother like her. She actually succeeded in killing Ashfur, but he was killed for no reason. If she was just going to spill the secret anyway, why kill him?

Answer 4

hollyleaf does not become evil, I dont know where people are getting that. she is just distressed because shes halfclan and her parents lied and broke the warrior code, so she runs into the tunnel leading to windclan and it collapses on top of her.

Answer 5

No, Hollyleaf did not turn evil. She struggled with inner turmoil and feelings of betrayal, but ultimately she did not become an evil character.

Answer 6

Yes. She dies first, though. Yes! she DIES!!! Starlingmist: Personally, I always knew that she would turn evil, from the start that I saw her name.

Answer 7

Yes she is evil because she killed Ashfur I HATE her

Answer 8

yes No she couldn't stand the fact she was half-Clan so she went mad.

Answer 9

She DID NOT turn evil.

Answer 10

yes