Anglo-Catholic

 

The terms Anglo-Catholic and Anglo-Catholicism describe people, groups, ideas, customs and practices within Anglicanism that emphasise continuity with Catholic tradition. Although the English Reformation had strong Protestant roots, there have always been Anglicans who identify themselves closely with traditional Catholic thought and practice. The concept of Anglo-Catholicism as a distinct sub-group or branch of Anglicanism came to prominence in the Church of England during the Victorian era under the influence of the Oxford Movement or "Tractarians."

Background

Anglo-Catholics claim historical continuity of the Church of England (and those constituent Churches derived from it through Apostolic Succession—see Anglican Communion) with Orthodox and Catholic Christianity, and hence uphold a "high" concept of the episcopate and of the nature of the sacraments (or Sacred Mysteries). According to The Concise Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church, the existence of such a school goes back to the Elizabethan Age; it flourished under the Stuarts, and came into prominence again with the Oxford Movement.

In the early 19th Century, various factors caused misgivings among English Churchmen, including the decline of Church life and the spread of laxity in theology in the Church of England. The government's plan to suppress ten Irish bishoprics in 1833 inspired a sermon from John Keble in the university church in Oxford which is regarded as the beginning of the Oxford Movement. The chief objective of the Oxford Movement was the defence of the Church of England as a Divine institution, of the doctrine of the Apostolic Succession, and of the Book of Common Prayer as a rule of faith. The key idea was that the Anglican Church was not a Protestant denomination but a branch of the "church Catholic" (along with the Roman Catholic Church and Eastern Orthodoxy), since it was argued that it had preserved the Apostolic Succession of priests and bishops and thus the Catholic sacraments. These arguments were spread by a series of "Tracts for the Times," hence the movement became known as "Tractarianism."

The Oxford Movement in the Church of England aimed at restoring High Church principles. The leaders of the movement were John Keble, John Henry Newman and Edward Bouverie Pusey. It soon gained influential support, but it was also attacked by the latitudinarians within the University and by Bishops. Within the movement there gradually arose a much smaller party which tended towards submission to Rome. After the censure by the Convocation of Oxford in 1845 of a book by W. G. Ward, and again after the Gorham Case in 1850, there were a number of conversions to the Roman Catholic Church. But the majority remained in the Church of England and, despite hostility in the press and in the Government, the movement spread. Its influence was exercised in the sphere of worship and ceremonial, in the social sphere (the slum settlements were among its notable achievements), and in the restoration of the religious life in the Church of England and many parts of the Anglican Communion.

However, despite the great effect of the movement, its theological basis, that the Anglican Church is a branch of the "church Catholic" with valid Apostolic succession and sacraments, has always been vulnerable to attack on historical and logical grounds. Neither the Catholic Church nor the Eastern Orthodox Church accept the branch theory of the Church - each claims itself to be the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church. Historical research in recent years has emphasised the essentially Protestant self-consciousness of the English Reformation, a consciousness which was dominant until the Oxford Movement. Catholic beliefs such as the Sacrifice of the Mass are specifically rejected in the Church's original doctrinal formulation, the Thirty-Nine Articles, and were unknown in Anglicanism until the advent of the Oxford Movement. The original Anglican Ordinal, which deleted any reference to the central priestly function, the offering of the sacrifice of the Mass, were the grounds for the declaration of Pope Leo XIII that the Anglican Church did not have valid orders, and thus did not have the Catholic sacraments. At the time, 1896, it was reported that the papal commission had voted 4 against validity, 2 in favor, and 2 abstentions. It has been revealed by the opening of the Papal Archives that the vote in fact was a tie: 4 in favor and 4 against, the Pope himself casting the deciding 'nay' vote. One may well ask what the motives were to hide the truth of the voting. The large Evangelical party in the Anglican church has continued since the Oxford Movements's inception to emphasise what it sees as the essentially Protestant nature of the Anglican church. Catholic doctrines are reduced to private opinion rather than being official doctrines of the Anglican Church, unlike in the Roman Catholic Church where they are official, bindingly taught by apostolic authority and tradition. Considerations of this kind led the Oxford Movement's intellectual leader, Newman, to convert to the Roman Catholic Church, as many other Anglo-Catholics have done since.

Practices and beliefs

Anglo-Catholic people and churches are usually identified by their liturgical practices and ornaments. The "six points" of the Oxford Movement's Eucharistic practice were the use of Eucharistic vestments, eastward celebration (the priest facing in the same direction as do the congregation), the use of unleavened bread, the mixing of water into the wine, and the use of incense and candles. Many other traditional Catholic practices are used in Anglo-Catholic liturgical ceremonies such as Eucharistic adoration and devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary in particular to Our Lady of Walsingham. Anglo-Catholic liturgical practices (sometimes called 'Ritualism' though many Anglo-Catholics resent the term) were a particular source of controversy in the nineteenth century, especially in England where Parliament was asked to legislate against certain practices. Many Anglo-Catholic "innovations" (or, rather, revivals of dormant practices) have, however, since become accepted by most mainstream Anglicans. In fact, the Liturgical Movement, ignited by Anglican divine Dom Gregory Dix with his book, The Shape of the Liturgy shaped the sweeping simplifications and standardizations in liturgical practice of the Roman Catholic Church after Vatican II, as well as of the churches in the Lutheran World Federation and the Old Catholic Churches of the Union of Utrecht and the Independent Catholic Churches derived from them. What little distinction is left in the Western liturgy has to do with the Anglican recourse to the customary of the Sarum Rite.

What Anglo-Catholics believe is highly debated, sometimes even among people who identify themselves as such. In agreement with the Oriental Orthodox Churches and Eastern Orthodox Churches, Anglo-Catholics — along with Old-Catholics and Lutherans — generally rest their case on the authority of Vincentian orthodoxy. This canon of St. Vincent of Lerins is accepted as the rudder for divining the Catholic and Apostolic Faith of the undivided Church: "What everywhere, what always, and what by all of us has been credited, that is truly and properly Catholic."

The Anglican Thirty-Nine Articles make distinctions between Anglican and Roman Catholic understandings of doctrine. Because they were purposely written in such a way as to be open to a wide range of interpretation, Anglo-Catholics have defended Catholic practices and beliefs as being consistent with the Articles, yet the Articles, because of their harsh tone, have never been regarded with much favor by Anglo-Catholics. Anglo-Catholic priests often hear private confessions and anoint the sick, regarding these practices (as do Roman Catholics) as sacraments; whereas more Reformed-Protestant-minded Anglicans generally think of them as merely optional sacramental rites. (The classic Anglican aphorism regarding private confession is "All may, none must, some should").

Anglo-Catholics usually share with Roman Catholics a belief in the sacramental nature of the priesthood, the sacrificial character of the Mass, and the Real Presence in the Eucharist, and lay great stress on these points to counter the tendency of Evangelicals to try to promote ideas such as lay presidency at the Eucharist. Some Anglo-Catholics encourage priestly celibacy.

Since the 1970s at least the Anglo-Catholic party in the Anglican church has been fracturing in two directions, though in retrospect the tensions could be traced to Charles Gore's work in the 19th century. The Oxford Movement had been inspired in the first place by a rejection of liberalism and latitudinarianism in favour of holding to the traditional faith of the "Church catholic", defined by the teachings of the Church Fathers and the common doctrines of the (Roman) Catholic Church and Eastern Orthodoxy. Thus until the 1970s most Anglo-Catholics, emphasising the need to stay in line with tradition and the doctrines of Rome and the East, would have rejected such innovations as the possibility of women receiving Holy Orders. However, Gore's work, bearing the mark of liberal Protestant higher criticism, paved the way for an alternative form of Anglo-Catholicism influenced by liberal theology. Thus, in recent years, many Anglo-Catholics have accepted the ordination of women. Many Anglo-Catholics have embraced other aspects of liberalism such as the use of inclusive language in Bible translations and the liturgy and, more recently, progressive Anglican views of homosexuality.

Thus today there are two strands of Anglo-Catholicism. The classical type seeks to maintain tradition and to keep doctrine in line with that of the Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches, and often allies with low-church evangelicals to defend traditional teachings on sexual morality. The main organisation in the Church of England that opposes the ordination of women as priests and bishops, Forward in Faith, is largely composed of Anglo-Catholics, and other Anglo-Catholics of this stripe have left the official Anglican Church to form churches in the Continuing Anglican Movement such as the Traditional Anglican Communion, or have left Anglicanism altogether for the Roman Catholic or Eastern Orthodox Churches, on the basis of their argument that the liberal doctrinal innovations in the Anglican Church prove it is not a branch of the "Church catholic." The other type is the inclusive movement represented by Affirming Catholicism, an organization in favour of the ordination of women as deacons, priests, and bishops.

A minority of Anglo-Catholics (sometimes called Anglo-Papalists) consider themselves under Papal supremacy even though they are not in full communion with Rome, and may use the Mass of Paul VI. Many Anglo-Catholics seek eventual reunion with the Roman Catholic Church and Eastern Orthodoxy.

Various liturgical strands of Anglo-Catholicism also exist, variously based on the Sarum Rite, or the Tridentine or Modern Roman rites. Also, preferences for either contemporary or traditional, Elizabethan language vary within the movement.

In the Anglican Communion three terms are frequently — but not always correctly — used to denote the parish's style of worship: High Church, Low Church, and Broad Church (or Latitudinarian).

• "High Church" is generally used to describe moderate to advanced Anglo-Catholicism.
• "Low Church" is used for Anglicans of a more Evangelical or Reformed-Protestant theology who emphasize the primacy of scripture, salvation by grace through faith alone, and — usually (with the notable exception of the Australian Diocese of Sydney) — worship based on the official prayer books but with much less ceremonial. Sydney Diocese does not mandate the use of any prayer book and worship services in its parishes are often considerably at variance with the shape of traditional Anglican liturgies.
• The term "Broad Church" is sometimes used for those Anglicans who are somewhere between the "high" and "low" traditions, or those who stress that there is room for various traditions in the Anglican Communion.

History

Anglo-Catholicism claims continuity with the early days of Christianity in Great Britain. Pope Gregory the Great sent St. Augustine in the late 6th Century from Rome to evangelise the Anglo-Saxons, a process completed in the 7th century. It is commonly thought that the conversion of the Anglo Saxons marked the beginning of Christianity in Britain. However, it should be noted that the Romano-Celtic society which existed in Britain prior to the arrival of the pagan Anglo Saxons was already substantially Christian. There are, for example, around forty churches still in use today which were already, either entirely or in part, in existence prior to the arrival of the Anglo Saxons.

When the Reformation broke out on the European Continent, the tide swept up England as well. King Henry VIII took England into schism from Rome when the Pope refused to declare null his marriage to Catherine of Aragon, but retained Catholic views in theology and liturgy, while some reformers (such as Bishops Ridley and Latimer) wanted to follow the radical reforms of Geneva. It was under the reign of Edward VI that the English Church was reformed with a sparer liturgy in the common vernacular and the tolerance of variant and new theological positions. These reforms were reversed, briefly, during the reign of the staunchly Roman Catholic Mary I who resumed communion with Rome as part of a general campaign to end the Reformation in England and Wales. Consequently when Queen Elizabeth I took the English throne, she sought to steer a via media between what her bishops felt were the excesses of Rome, on the one hand, and those of Geneva, on the other. Thus was born the Elizabethan Settlement, and the promulgation of a single Book of Common Prayer, for whatever theological party was to use it within the Anglican Church. This marks the birth of a special ethos for the Anglican Church. This ethos, peculiar to Anglicanism, was championed by the Elizabethan divine, Richard Hooker.

From that time, through Archbishop Laud and the Caroline divines, up to the time of the Oxford Movement Tractarians, and the Anglo-Catholic Congresses, to the present day, there has always been a theological party within Anglicanism which has sought to stress apostolic continuity all the way back to the Apostle Philip, although the movements before the Oxford Movement were self-consciously Protestant. In response to Pope Leo XIII's Apostolicae Curae (1896), which declared the Anglican apostolic succession invalid, the Anglican Archbishops of Canterbury and York have claimed, starting with their official response, Saepius Officio, that there is an unbroken apostolic succession in the Anglican priesthood, and that the historical episcopate has been in the British Isles from the earliest days of the Church. Rome usually does not dispute the latter point, inasmuch as the Catholic Church has continued to exist in the British Isles, even under Puritan and Anglican persecution. Rather, the Roman Catholic Church maintains that this apostolic succession was broken by the use of the Ordinal of King Edward VI, which deletes all reference to the central priestly function, the sacrifice of the Mass, the unbloody renewal of the sacrifice of Calvary according to Roman Catholic doctrine, and deliberately was designed to contain no indication of the "fullness of the ministry", specific tasks of the Catholic bishop or the "high priesthood", which the Holy See considers essential. The Romans assume that their point of view, based on Late Medieval sacramental theory, is valid for all periods of church history. In their refutation the Archbishops of Canterbury and York pointed out, amongst other matters, that no such priestly functions or sacrmaental theology were event in the Papal ordinations rites of the 9th and 10th centuries, which would render their ordiantions invalid as well using the same criteria aimed at the Anglicans.

Anglo-Catholicism has been weakened at regular intervals by secessions by its prominent leaders to the Roman Catholic Church or occasionally to the Eastern Orthodox Churches, among whom was John Henry Newman, the later Cardinal. Moments of crisis provoking such defections include the (narrowly avoided) condemnation of Tract 90 in 1841, the ritualistic controversy and the Public Worship Regulation Act of 1874, the Prayer Book controversy of 1927-28, and more recently decisions by most Anglican provinces to proceed to the ordination of women priests.

In recent years, elements of Anglo-Catholicism have been accepted within Lutheranism by the Evangelical Community Church-Lutheran, however within the context of Luther's justification teachings and deletion of certain "papist" doctrines on the Eucharist.

Examples

• List of Anglo-Catholic Churches

See also

• Continuing Anglican Movement
  • Anglican Catholic Church
  • Anglican Church in America
  • Anglican Province of America
  • Anglican Catholic Church of Canada
• Anglicanism
• Anglican Breviary
• Anglican Communion
• Anglican devotional society
• Anglican Missal
• Anglican sacraments
• Affirming Catholicism
• Broad Church
• Catholicism
• Church of England
• Evangelical catholic
• High Church
• High Church Lutheranism
• Liturgical Movement
• Low Church
• Neo-Lutheranism
• Our Lady of Walsingham
• Ritualism

External links

• Anglican Catholic Christianity - Vast listing of links and resources
• Anglo-Catholic Central - Listings of Parishes, Dioceses, Orders, and Societies
• Anglican texts at Project Canterbury
• Affirming Catholicism
• The Anglican Breviary
• Anglican Religious Communities
• Anglo-Catholic Socialism
• A Guide to the Solemn High Mass
• The Anglican Independent Communion
• What is Anglo-Catholicism? - A Response in Six Parts by the Revd John D. Alexander, SSC
• What is an Anglo-Catholic Parish?
• The Anglo-Catholic Vision
• The Knott Missal Ordinary of the Mass
• Forward in Faith

Donate to Wikimedia